3 ms·
I want to see the dyno chart. Either there are some serious power spikes/valleys with this setup, or they are nerfing (ie reducing) power at various points to
by sandworm101 8y ago
I want to see the dyno chart. Either there are some serious power spikes/valleys with this setup, or they are nerfing (ie reducing) power at various points to smooth things. There is no way direct-drive IC engine makes anywhere near similar power at 100kph as at 200 (double the rmp). This may be fast, but a transmission would make it much faster.
(A modern trans, at this power/price, would only be 200lbs at most. Less than carrying a passenger.)
- bagels 8y agoWhy add 200 lbs to a performance car? You may reduce acceleration rates (including braking and cornering), which is kind of the point in a car like this.
- acct1771 8y agoTo express it in simple terms, sometimes you run out of traction before you run out of engine to propel additional weight.
- bluetomcat 8y agoThe clutch is a hydraulic coupling, meaning that it acts pretty much like a torque converter. They claim that it stays "locked" most of the time (at constant speed), but the amount of slippage during heavy acceleration must be considerable. Looks like far from an ideal setup in terms of drivetrain efficiency.
- arghwhat 8y agoLocked means a regular, slip-free friction clutch housed inside the torque converter. Unless that clutch slips (which would be a mechanical failure), then there will be no slippage during heavy acceleration. The torque converter is most likely to handle a bit of slippage at low speeds, or just to provide a smoother activation than slamming a clutch. It's also supposedly a low-slip converter, unlike the normal "comfort" type.
- taneq 8y agoI think it's literally just there to allow the engine to idle when the car's stationary. Otherwise it'd stall since it's direct drive gearing. With a redline at 8250rpm at 249mph, that gives you ~600rpm (which many V8s can idle comfortably at) at 20mph and ~1500rpm at 45mph. I'd expect it to lock somewhere around 45mph and be effectively a rigid connection above that. Edit: From TFA the hydraulic coupling starts to engage around 30mph, so not a bad guess. :)
- upofadown 8y agoA torque converter a type of liquid transmission. At low speeds it converts most of the slippage to torque to allow the IC engine to deliver power without stalling. A hydraulic coupling just slips and the extra power ends up as heat.
- pedrocr 8y agoI think the point in this car is that they have enough torque to spin the tires at any of those speeds where they've had to "nerf it" to make things smooth. Once you're at that point might as well take advantage of it to simplify. A transmission wouldn't add anything except maybe some efficiency which they don't care much about given the application.
- taneq 8y agoIt basically sounds like the car's "stuck in 5th" with electric boost to make up the shortfall in torque when the motor's at low RPM. They're not getting maximum engine power out of it at 100km/h, you're right there, but they don't need to because the electric motors make up for it when accelerating.
- arghwhat 8y agoThere shouldn't be any spikes, really. Much less so than with a transmission, which has peaks for every gear. The car would basically have the following stages: 1. All electric. ICE is just powering a generator. 2. 50km/h+: ICE clutches in at 1000 RPM. Not much power provided. 3. 100km/h+: ICE starts delivers at 2000 RPM. 4. 250km/h+: Peak torque (assuming sweet spot of around 5000 RPM, just a guess)) 5. 400km/h+: Redline at 8250 RPM, nothing left. You'll probably have two torque peaks: Initial electrical acceleration and its drop-off, and ICE peak and drop-off. Depending on how well-tuned this is, it might be smooth between those two peaks. A trans, on the other hand, would have lows, peaks and shift losses between every gear change, and that's combined with a higher permanent loss. However, arguably, you could have made a more impressive car while saving weight: By removing the ICE. You'd probably lose a bit of top speed, but make up for it in acceleration. 400km/h is useless.
- brian-armstrong 8y agoThe engine powers the electric motors. The car would be in a sad state of affairs with just its batteries.
- arghwhat 8y agoYeah, my broken list does mention that ICE powers generators. Sometimes I hate HN comment syntax.
- bluetomcat 8y agoProbably a fine setup for optimising straight-line acceleration and 0-400 times, with questionable track performance. A conventional high-performance car is able to make use of the engine torque at any time by shifting to the appropriate gear and keeping the engine in a narrow rev-range. This, on the other hand relies solely on the electric motors to fill that gap before the torque peak at, say, 250 km/h.
- arghwhat 8y agoI'd argue the exact opposite. A conventional high-performance car will struggle with its lacking acceleration and narrow optimal rev-range. Every shift is a performance penalty, and the transmission itself is inefficient. It's only really acceptable for straight-line 0-400, where the shift range is only gone through once, and even then it's often too much, with people preferring two-speed transmissions for drag. For a real race, it becomes extremely wasteful. The only benefit of a conventional setup is the ability to handle extreme top-speeds that direct-drive will have difficulty with. However, in most races you're quite far from 400km/h, making this benefit useless. Instead, you constantly need immediate acceleration and power from variable speeds, which an ICE with transmission will always struggle with. While this particular car is not that impressive performance-wise, it's tuned for racing, not top-speed. An purely electric racer will run circles around it, with their only downside being tendencies to battery overheating for certain races. On that note, see VW's recent pike's peak record: https://electrek.co/2018/06/21/vw-all-electric-race-car-fastest-time-in-pikes-peak-qualifying-round/ https://electrek.co/2018/06/21/vw-all-electric-race-car-fast....
- londons_explore 8y agoI agree with you, but I don't think it matters. Unlike combustion engines, electric motors have much higher peak power output compared to steady state maximum power. (ie. they are limited by cooling, both of the motors and controller). Typically the pulse power for 1 second might be 10x the steady state output! That means, for the typical use case of accelerating from 0 to 250 mph, they can afford to use the electric engines in 'peak' mode rather than steady state mode, then let them cool down when the IC engine is engaged at higher speeds. Attach the system to a dyno and require it to run at a particular speed for an extended period of time and it's going to look very disappointing though.
- sandworm101 8y agoIs accelerating from 0 to 250 a typical use case? What about steady speeds, or repeated acceleration between speeds? As i said, they will have nerfed this thing. It would be a better car by adding a tramsmission. Performance should not be abandoned just to make a point.
- mywittyname 8y agoThe ICE in this is a 5.0L, twin-turbocharged monster that produces 1100hp and 950ft.lbs of torque. The electric motors really just need to carry this thing to about 30mph before the RPMs are high enough for the ICE to propel this thing with some authority. 900ft.lbs of torque at 3,000 RPMS is still 515 hp.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoThe combined HP of the car is actually around 1,800, but they've overlapped the curves to peak at 1,500, you never get the full combined power of both ICE and electric, in order to make it smoother.