6 ms·
> Pretty much every single comment so far is cynical. "No one really wants to know how the sausage is made", lots of money is tainted anyway, it's just PR fluff
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> Pretty much every single comment so far is cynical. "No one really wants to know how the sausage is made", lots of money is tainted anyway, it's just PR fluff, etc etc.
It seems like a deeper problem than that, which is that money is fungible. It's the same thing as saying we shouldn't buy Saudi oil. If the only result is that you buy some other oil and the people who would have bought that oil buy the Saudi oil, nothing meaningful has changed.
To get a meaningful result you need one of two things. One is solidarity (i.e. market power), but you never have that in a diffuse competitive market. The other is to do something that isn't fungible. For example, if you actually use less oil (buy an electric car and solar panels, or support nuclear etc.), it makes a proportional difference even at the individual level, because then it isn't a matter of everyone having to act together to accomplish anything, it's a matter of each person doing their share adding up. Then the cost to them is in proportion to how many people act rather than the cost being effectively zero unless you reach a critical mass you can't achieve.
But there isn't any obvious equivalent to that for venture capital. For oil, basically all of the foreign exporters are antagonistic, and burning oil itself is harmful regardless of the source, so everything lines up for that working as a mechanism of retaliation. But if solar/wind/hydro/nuclear/etc. are the alternatives to oil, what is the alternative to money supposed to be?
To get anywhere on that front you need market power, which essentially means something like government sanctions. But we don't do that because we still need their oil. So it seems like we're right back to stop burning oil.
- ericjang 8y agoInvestment opportunities (which VC firms get the money, what deal flow they have, what investment opportunities the VC has) are most certainly not fungible. So I think it's helpful to think of the deal flow in reverse - even though "someone else can take the Saudi money", that "someone else" most likely does not represent exactly the same investment opportunity to the LPs. FWIW - I do think your assessment of oil is correct (since oil and money are both fungible). But for venture capital, one side of the investment (startup talent, VC skill and network, etc.) are not fungible. (elaborated a bit more in a twitter rant: https://twitter.com/ericjang11/status/1054115724996694016 https://twitter.com/ericjang11/status/1054115724996694016)
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe distinction you're making matters at the level of individuals. If you're a person choosing a startup to dedicate years of your life to, the choice you make has major consequences for you. At the level of a huge wealth fund, those details are noise that gets canceled out because the more promise a startup has the more capital dollars are chasing it, so the buy in price is proportional to the value. Arguing that investments aren't fungible is essentially arguing that the efficient market hypothesis is wrong. (Which it can be, but not in a way that seems particularly relevant here.)
- ericjang 8y agoFungibility can hardly be true for the venture capital ecosystem. Many people who wanted to invest in Facebook, Snap, Uber, etc. could not do so. Founders of highly successful startups (or at least those on a promising growth trajectory) are in practice sensitive to which VCs participate in each round (and I suspect in the next few years they will start to pay attention to LPs as well). The "buy-in" price that you mention is not efficient because some people cannot participate no matter how much they are willing to pay. Similarly, imagine if Uber wanted to hire a top Computer Vision researcher, and they could not. This hiring situation might not even get noticed by a LP, but an LP would surely notice if a VC was not able to invest their money in the next Uber / Facebook.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Fungibility can hardly be true for the venture capital ecosystem. Many people who wanted to invest in Facebook, Snap, Uber, etc. could not do so. Many people who want to invest in Amazon right now cannot do so, because the shares are very expensive. That doesn't mean they're not fungible, it only means the existing owners won't sell for what you're willing to pay. > The "buy-in" price that you mention is not efficient because some people cannot participate no matter how much they are willing to pay. If you went to Zuckerberg in 2004 and offered to buy in for the equivalent of Facebook's 2018 valuation, would he really have turned you away? Early stage startups are sensitive to who invests because early investors typically get seats on the board. The problem with the Saudis was not that they would use their board seats to ruin your company. > Similarly, imagine if Uber wanted to hire a top Computer Vision researcher, and they could not. This hiring situation might not even get noticed by a LP, but an LP would surely notice if a VC was not able to invest their money in the next Uber / Facebook. The thing about "the next Uber / Facebook" is that nobody knows who they are yet. And the number of startups who could be them is huge, even though most of them won't. Not being able to invest in a random startup that might become the next Facebook is hardly an issue when there are a hundred more that you can.
- akiselev 8y agoSaudi Arabia is a counter example to your point: Iran has a considerable amount of oil but because of unrelated geopolitical circumstances, it can't easily sell that to the global market like KSA can. That imbalance has little to do the nature of oil and a lot to do with the KSA-United States' petrodollar and arms deals. The geopolitics of the world put KSA in a position to capitalize on its oil wealth and trade it for influence, not the nature of the product. Currency may be fungible but the quality of investments an LP has access to are not. The hope is that closing off the best avenues for return in an oversaturated capital market will cause rich people with influence to put pressure on the governments.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Saudi Arabia is a counter example to your point: Iran has a considerable amount of oil but because of unrelated geopolitical circumstances, it can't easily sell that to the global market like KSA can. That imbalance has little to do the nature of oil and a lot to do with the KSA-United States' petrodollar and arms deals. It has little to do with oil and much to do with Trump making the Iran deal a campaign issue and therefore doing everything he can to pressure them into renegotiating. The outlier is Iran rather than Saudi Arabia. Russia and Venezuela aren't having any trouble selling their oil either. Moreover, as Iran's production is down, oil prices are up. This, ironically, actually hurts the Saudis too, because it makes oil less competitive against alternatives in the short term, encouraging faster adoption of alternatives that suppress oil prices in the long term. And Iran's production is only down because of US-led international sanctions, which clearly falls into the category of market power. But they're also the reason the US can't go after the Saudis at the same time, because until we transition away from oil (which takes time), the US economy is still highly sensitive to oil prices, which are already higher due to Iran. The Saudis are actually doing Trump (not to say themselves) a favor by increasing production during the sanctions on Iran.
- richardknop 8y agoTrump is not an important player in this saga (yet, maybe after 2 full terms, if he would get reelected, he will have more of an impact). Iran has been sanctioned and prevented from selling their oil to global markets easily (thus crippling Iran's income and economy) for a long time before Trump and through multiple presidents from both parties. Sure, Trump made the Iran deal a campaign issue but this goes decades back.
- bigiain 8y ago> nothing meaningful has changed Except that you don't now have blood on your hands... If "being able to sleep at night" gets counted as "meaningful", I'd say something has changed. If the only question you count as "meaningful" is "did we leave any money on the table". Perhaps you should think more deeply about the world...
- unknownkadath 8y agoThank you for this. It needed to be said.
- notafraudster 8y agoFungibility matters if your only goal is to make it impossible for bad dudes to sell their product / invest. But keeping your own hands clean is an admirable goal in and of itself, and certainly concluding "this doesn't make a difference in the grand scheme so why should I care" seems to be the exact kind of cynicism the parent comment was critiquing
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe point is that some things make a proportional difference, which at the level of an individual is minimal but make a real impact if 30-70% of people do it, whereas other things only work with a critical mass, which are then still useless even if 30-70% of people do them because you need 70-100% of people to do it for it to be effective at all. If you as an individual are going to do something, do the first kind of thing.
- afro88 8y ago> It's the same thing as saying we shouldn't buy Saudi oil. If the only result is that you buy some other oil and the people who would have bought that oil buy the Saudi oil, nothing meaningful has changed. I think this touches on another thing I've struggled for clarity on lately. How many degrees of separation do you need before you're willing to take investment from someone linked to something you find morally repugnant? 1 degree is relatively clear cut (though can still get muddy depending on how desperate your situation is). Is 2 degrees enough to decide it's ok? 3 degrees? At a certain stage, it's arguable that benefiting one end of the chain won't result in observable benefit for the other. Where though? And at what stage does the benefit to society of your project outweigh the negatives of where the money that funds it came from?
- rocqua 8y agoThere isn't a clear line, and there probably cannot be one. First of all, more than just 'degree of separation' matters. You also need to know what fraction comes from bad sources. If it is 3 fronts stacked, you are still essentially dealing with the bad source. I see 2 options: 1) Flip it. At what standard do I eliminate e.g. 20% of all funding. Or more generally, plot repugnancy against the percentage of funding sources lost, and pick an optimum 2) Make news matter. It might not feel objective to drop a deal for 3 degrees of separation when you read a story. After all, there is probably other stuff that has 3 degrees of separation. However, by reacting to that news you: * Outsource information gathering to Journalists, who are specialized and do it for many more people than you * Increasing the impact of journalism. By making investors care about what is written about them. The second point matters, because fear of bad PR is essentially the only capitalist force that pushes companies towards moral behavior.
- Applejinx 8y agoMany journalists (and news outlets) are currently fired and not working in the sense you mean, because Facebook made a compelling (and fraudulent) case that millenials only watched videos. Across the industry, news outlets got rid of journalists to repurpose investment in video production.
- richardknop 8y ago> It's the same thing as saying we shouldn't buy Saudi oil. If the only result is that you buy some other oil and the people who would have bought that oil buy the Saudi oil, nothing meaningful has changed. I'm not sure this is true for oil. For example, long standing sanctions against Iran prevented them from selling a lot of their oil and crippled their economy quite a lot (decreasing their income). The same could be done with Saudi Arabia if there were will to do it (there isn't, western politicians are too intertwined with Saudi money, especially so in US & UK, to a lesser extent in other western countries but without US/UK approval, no action against Saudis will happen). Oil would come from other countries, they could increase their output while Saudis are under sanctions. I think it's not as fungible as money (and even with money I don't it's 100% fungible as bank accounts can be frozen, again see Iran).
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I'm not sure this is true for oil. For example, long standing sanctions against Iran prevented them from selling a lot of their oil and crippled their economy quite a lot (decreasing their income). You're referring to international sanctions (i.e. acting with market power), not something anyone can do at the individual level. Not even the US could do it on their own -- if the US put sanctions on Iran by itself, Iran would just sell to Europe or Asia and not care. The only way it works is if nearly everyone agrees not to buy from them. But the reason countries don't like sanctions on oil exporting countries isn't that they're ineffective, it's that they raise oil prices. > Oil would come from other countries, they could increase their output while Saudis are under sanctions. Yes it would, that's normal for a commodity market. When you remove a supplier, the price increases, which attracts new suppliers who may have higher production costs. But the relevant part of that dynamic is that the price increases. The problem isn't that oil becomes unavailable, it's that your consumers have to pay more for it and the money goes to other countries you don't really want to enrich. And if you have an international coalition willing to suffer higher oil prices then the much better alternative is a carbon tax, because then you get the money from the higher prices instead of Russia and OPEC, and can use it for things like subsidizing renewable energy or electric cars to mitigate the cost to your consumers and reduce the length of time you have to pay it.