4 ms·
TBH, this article is a perfect example of the formulaic, semi-clickbaity articles that I can't stand. Take the title "Stop building websites with infinite scrol
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
TBH, this article is a perfect example of the formulaic, semi-clickbaity articles that I can't stand. Take the title "Stop building websites with infinite scroll", but then the article itself goes on the give some examples of when infinite scroll is appropriate. Even many of the arguments against infinite scroll feel like strawmen (e.g. "It messes up the footer." Well, seems obvious to me that putting a footer after an infinite scroll is a bad idea, but many if not most pages where you'd use an infinite scroll could do without a footer, or you could put that "footer data" elsewhere.)
All UX approaches have tradeoffs, and any UX paradigm can be implemented poorly or used where inappropriate. Bringing up some of these examples and then saying "stop using UX approach xyz" is disingenuous.
- cuddlecake 8y agoI agree. Since I intend to use this technique in a social network app I am working on, I clicked on this article expecting reasons to not use infinite scrolling. I feel discouraged. When every generalized statement is essentially clickbait, then I don't know where to look for arguments and advice anymore. I am truly lost.
- rossdavidh 8y agoI have been often annoyed at infinite scroll, and never at any of the other options offered. It's part of a general anti-pattern of pages loading new content when I didn't ask them to, but by far the most prevalent and annoying. I dislike infinite scroll, and I believe I am alone in that, and perhaps not even in the minority.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoWell, then we agree to disagree. Particularly with search results where it's likely I'm going to need to look through a lot of results (e.g. real estate, hotel, dating sites) I find infinite scroll, if done right, makes it faster to comb through results. More importantly, though, I think this article is an anti-pattern of attempting to make broad conclusions from anecdotes and personal opinion with zero data to back it up.
- dang 8y agoIn keeping with the site guidelines, we often rewrite such titles to something less baity like "Problems with". I've done so above. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html