7 ms·
The indefatigable efforts of J. M. Keynes
- pfschell 8y agoIf I could only erase one person from history, Keynes would be very close to the top of the list. The damage caused by his malevolent theories has done immeasurable harm to all humankind.
- maxxxxx 8y agoCan you explain?
- patrickg_zill 8y agoI used to think that, however I would like to point out that Keynes did believe that the gold standard was necessary. What we have in economics now are Neo-Keynesians, who perhaps can be said to have hijacked Keynes.
- cuchoi 8y agoWhat's the problem with Neo-Keynesians?
- patrickg_zill 8y agoMy point is that they are different from Keynes' own views.
- cuchoi 8y agoThey usually are working towards proving mathematically (with microfoundations) Keynes theories, so I don't see how they would differ besides the issues were the economic mainstream have shifted.
- vanderreeah 8y agoWrong - Keynes believed the exact opposite. Perhaps his most famous opinion is that the gold standard was "a barbarous relic".
- dragonwriter 8y ago> however I would like to point out that Keynes did believe that the gold standard was necessary. Keynes advocating against the reintroduction of the gold standard, and then—when Churchill got it reintroduced anyway—for its abandonment until it was again abandoned. You must have mistaken Keynes for someone else.
- jacinabox 8y agoI suppose we shall be in need of a new explanation for the Great Depression then.
- bassman9000 8y agohttps://archive.is/aeXVP https://archive.is/aeXVP > We found that a relapse isn't likely unless lawmakers gum up a recovery with ill-conceived stimulus policies
- snackman7 8y agoThey already exist. Here are some articles from mises.org that look at it from the Austrian school's point of view. https://mises.org/wire/how-artificial-boom-1914-1929-caused-great-depression https://mises.org/wire/how-artificial-boom-1914-1929-caused-... https://mises.org/library/great-depression https://mises.org/library/great-depression https://mises.org/library/fake-history-depression https://mises.org/library/fake-history-depression
- UncleEntity 8y agoBetter than "animal spirits"?
- pretendscholar 8y agoYou have a youtube level understanding of Keynes if thats what you think his explanation boils down to.
- Matticus_Rex 8y agoYou realize that Keynes' explanation of the Depression makes no more than cameos in the modern explanations, right?
- bitwize 8y agoMarx would not be a better candidate?
- justicezyx 8y agoIf we continue this, I'd say let's just erase the first human. After all, human has not done much net positive thing to the Earth.
- classicsnoot 8y agoYou can't do "positive" or "negative" things the The Earth. It is a lump of mass shot through with potential energy and lattice opportunities. Net positives and negatives are subjective assessments by perspectives constrained within a framework. The earth is the super constraint on humanity, at least for the time being. The oxygen rich atmosphere is not objectively better than the nitrogen rich atmosphere, but it is subjectively worse for us. It's a fools game anyway. Erase the homo sapiens and some other primate gets spared a genocide. I have never understood the value in anthropomorphizing the planet outside of political manipulation. Economic structures, on the other hand... ;)
- vkou 8y agoMarx described the problem, communism tried, and failed to solve it. He didn't create the problem of capital vs labour inequality, though. (Meanwhile, many of the rights workers have gained over the twentieth century were given to them because of the fear that they will turn to communism.)
- sfcguyus 8y agoThis is extremely debatable. One could argue the exact opposite. I wholeheartedly disagree completely. One could presume you attribute boom and bust to him but stability came after the arrival of his theories. If you want a dive into what it looked like before look out for a book called Lombard Street. Infact our problems with trade deficits and imbalances at the moment can be attributed to his defeat by Harry Dexter White in the implementation of Bretton Woods in negotiation (Bancor).
- hellogoodbyeeee 8y agoMy personal pet peeves with HN is that there is a vocal minority that is completely dismissive of the entire field of economics. Obviously, the field has pluses and minuses, but it's nuts there are people that completely think the whole field is useless or harmful. Economics didn't become a major academic field studied in every college in the country (world even?) by being a bunk science.
- dpwm 8y ago> My personal pet peeves with HN is that there is a vocal minority that is completely dismissive of the entire field of economics. I am mostly dismissive of a lot of economically-motivated political arguments, because a lot of the time the people advancing such arguments are abusing models that are simply not applicable. > Obviously, the field has pluses and minuses, but it's nuts there are people that completely think the whole field is useless or harmful. I'm very critical of the "because economics" when money is involved on one side or the other. When the opaquely-funded Cato institute's neo-libertarian nonsense is being funnelled through here from one of the two accounts that only serve to post their content, then I'll criticise them and be in a minority. I also think that people cherry picking arguments based on following microeconomics into a realm it isn't really applicable is responsible for some of the most cruel and savage human behaviour we see today. When supply and demand is applied to public services with no regard for taxation and planning and you have bullshit-economics acting as a mask for racists, I think it's right to call it out in the same way that I would call out someone claiming that migrants breathe too much air. > Economics didn't become a major academic field studied in every college in the country (world even?) by being a bunk science. Some critics argue that it got there by supporting those with the money to keep it there. If your field is funded by people who have an interest in the direction and implications of that field of study, we start to see problems. People tend to see this more with the pharmaceutical industry than with economics. Ubiquity is not a very good measure for a sign of its quality. Nonetheless I am actually quite a fan of Keynes. I found it quite tragic to hear about his heart attacks and lack of recovery that seemed to come at such an unfortunate time.
- eiaoa 8y ago> If I could only erase one person from history, Keynes would be very close to the top of the list. The damage caused by his malevolent theories has done immeasurable harm to all humankind. Hitler, Stalin, Mao, or any dictator that's ever lived seem like better candidates for erasure. At least with them, you'd be saving the lives of the people they each malevolently murdered. You'd have to be clutching narrow-mindedly onto some economic dogma and view Keynes as a heretic to choose him for erasure.
- hellogoodbyeeee 8y agoActually, Keyenes correctly predicted some of the main reasons WWII happened. If more world leaders had listened to him, then we probably could have prevented world war 2. He predicted that after WWI that the reparations required of Germany would be too burdensome on their economy which would in turn lead to another war.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here, and especially not on controversial topics. That combo amounts to trolling, whether you meant it that way or not. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- UncleEntity 8y ago> Worse, it has led to increasingly frequent financial crises. These began first on the fringes of the global economy (in the 1970s and 80s), but in 2007–9 moved to its core, the US and Europe. Far as I got in TFA... Anyone who doesn't recognize "financial crises" have been going on for, like, forever probably isn't that much of an expert on the subject to even consider their argument.
- ashrk 8y agoThe first of the "increasingly frequent financial crises", I should think, is what's intended. Not the first one period. Not to defend that point—my background is little help here—but I think yours is a misreading.
- hellogoodbyeeee 8y agoRecessions have become increasingly less frequent since Keyenes. I think there may be an argument around the US experiencing fewer, but greater in magnitude recessions, but im not sure of the specifics.
- neffy 8y agoNo you´re right. The banking system was bouncing up and down like a yo-yo in the 19th century, on average there was a crisis every 10-12 years (also astonishingly regular). The mean time to crisis is several years longer these days.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoWe had a respite after the Depression and banking regulations. Then Reagan(?) and deregulation, and now we're right back to the yo-yo
- chcknsammich 8y agoMarkets and bubbles crash because of a mismatch between a price and actual comparable value (which, in their large form, are usually caused by artificial market levers or _regulations_). Stop with this mysticism inspired "greed is bad and therefore actions inspired by greed are inherently bad so we need even more powerful people who are of course not influenced by greed to set rules for the greedy" nonsense.
- gweinberg 8y agoI think Keynes is a lot more comparable to Freud than to Darwin. Hugely inspirational in his day, inspired a lot of interesting ideas, clearly a very bright guy. But not necessarily ever right about anything, or at least anything new.
- lewis500 8y ago"This revolutionary theory – his Liquidity Preference Theory – is still considered too radical to be acceptable today." What? Liquidity preference was taught in my undergrad macro class using the textbook by Greg Mankiw. It's the basis of the IS/LM model. And central banks are constantly worrying about interest rates and liquidity. To whom is it too radical? Probably some people disagree with it, but I wouldn't call it very "radical" today. The author is fighting straw men.
- zackmorris 8y agoShort summary of the difference between supply-side (Milton Friedman) economics vs demand-side (John Maynard Keynes) economics: https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/012615/what-difference-between-keynesian-economics-and-monetarist-economics.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/012615/what-differe... My main experience with this on a microeconomic level was during the housing bubble and recovery. I tried working at home flipping used Macintosh computers to sell on eBay and found that as money got tighter and tighter around the country, prices kept falling from $300-500 in the course of a year to $150-300 and eventually I couldn't make any money at it. Part of this was the natural drop in price of electronics but part of it was also the fact that everyone was broke so demand for computers fell. I think we could do a lot for the US economy by putting more money in the hands of consumers and raising demand. We could also think about what people are buying, and start investing in projects that pay off in the long run (renewable energy, permaculture, automation etc) vs projects that are unsustainable (coal, monocropping, the service economy). The fact that most people have never really heard of these sorts of government-driven public works since roughly the late 70s tells me that supply-side economics won. But I think on a local level, we might see a resurgence in demand-side economics with recycling, cooperatives, some level of universal basic income - things that make life easier for working people. At least, I thought that before the last presidential election. But if people are looking for hope in these times, Keynesian economics is a great place to start.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoI think you need those programs to start at the federal level rather than the local level if you want to avoid bankrupting the more local governments. I would like to see more of those programs by the way.
- nickik 8y agoI'm sorry but your comment and the post you link to is complete nonsense economically and worse applied to Keynes and Friedman is utterly wrong. The article you linked is an honestly an embarrassment. Furthermore nothing in the actual economics of either of these two people puts them squarely in the supply-side/demand-side 'camp' and furthermore those terms are used competently wrongly to the point of meaninglessness in public discussion anyway. I don't want to get into a long post here, but your way oversimplifying the issue economist discuss to a point where it borders on satire. To get a somewhat better understanding in a short time: - https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/KeynesianEconomics.html https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/KeynesianEconomics.html (written by Alan S. Blinder) If you are further interested in the history of economists long dead, consider: - https://www.mruniversity.com/courses/great-economists-classical-economics-and-its-forerunners https://www.mruniversity.com/courses/great-economists-classi...
- nickik 8y agoThis article contains so much nonsense its hard to comprehend how this is not an attempt at satire. It seems the anther has read some Keynes and has defined a whole new history around it. I highly recommend people against reading this text, it represents the worse kind of historical rewriting and reinterpretation to serve the needs the person writing it. I would also point out that a lot of the insights that Kaynes made popular and enjoyed wide popularity from the 1950 to 1970s has since gone away. The theories today called 'New Keynesian' really are far more evolution of 70s monetarism. > Keynes’s development of the science of macroeconomics goes largely unacknowledged by a profession still So all of this is wrong. In no meaningful way did Keynes develop the science of macroeconomics. There were working on the exact same topics as him for a very long time before him. One might argue that he was the most well known macro economist in England at the time, but that's about it. Furthermore, the idea that Keynes is 'unacknowledged' is unfathomably wrong. There are macro economics schools today that refer to themselves as 'New-Keynesian', 'Post-Keynesian' or 'Old Keynesian'. > by a profession still steeped in classical microeconomics I don't even know what he is referring to. Nobody does 'classical' economics since the 1870 (except some forms of Marxist economics).
- person_of_color 8y agoIs there an "Economics for Hackers" resource or book that isn't tainted by political bias?
- angrow 8y agoNo, but there are plenty whose politics are obfustacted enough that you could confuse it for steely-eyed objectivity.
- cuchoi 8y agoWhat would you like to see in a book like that? Seems an interesting idea
- person_of_color 8y agoWhy rich countries/cultures are rich and poor countries/cultures are poor.