4 ms·
But. Not all those betters are better. For example, spending less on food is not the same as eating healthier. In the first world obesity is creating a crisis.
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
But. Not all those betters are better.
For example, spending less on food is not the same as eating healthier. In the first world obesity is creating a crisis.
Taller? That traslates to needing more resources. More to feed. More to clothe.
I'm not waiting to be a cynic. But using 20th century metrics nearly two decades into the 21st century is not a status quo that makes me comfortable; especially as I extrapolate into the future.
- achamayou 8y agoAh, but check out the chart about average temperature, we might not need as much clothing after all! In all seriousness, I’ll take an obesity crisis over starvation any day. Sure we haven’t achieved perfect nutrition, but the situation is undoubtedly better.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoAh. Be careful what you wish for. Fact: More people now die as a result of too much food than not enough. Add on the related (healthcare) costs and we're over-eating our way to more problems we can't afford.
- achamayou 8y agoYes, but crucially, they choose to eat too much. They could stop. Those who starve never do so of their own will, and would absolutely take the alternative if it was available to them. As for the healthcare costs, I expect we will see something very similar to what happened with tobacco. A combination of economic disincentives and regulatory measures (no sugary drinks and snacks in schools, smaller portions etc), which will ultimately curb the problem.
- arbitrary_name 8y agoYou act as if free choice occurs in a vacuum. It does not. Billions spent on advertising, public policy designed to benefit the agriculture and food industries: let's not pretend we are all perfectly informed rational actors, that fallacy was debunked a generation ago.
- Zanni 8y agoBut they die later. No one’s dying of obesity in childhood. This is still an improvement.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoPerhaps. But that's not within the scope of the stat I referenced. Furthermore, childhood obesity __is__ on the rise. The related illnesses (e.g., type 2 diabetes) consume resources __unnecessarily__. Considering the infant mortality rate in the USA, I'd venture to say, obesity killing children. Please also factor in the dangers associated with obesity and pregnancy.
- otherme123 8y agoSpending less SHARE OF INCOME in food means that on average the food is cheaper and/or people are earning more. If you can empathize with people outside the US or Europe, that means that those people that earn $1 or $2 dollars per day all of their income was obviously spent on food. When those people earn $20 per day, they start to buy other goods. If you reduce the World to the USA, then the problem is indeed worst food. That is currently expressed in the lower life expectancy in the US, compared with the richest countries. But almost any US resident that spends the 10-12% of their wage (world average) in food is going to be correctly feed. Taller means that your genetics can express to their full potential. It's a very good index from when a country can feed the 100% of the needs of the youngest population. Poor countries malnourishes their youth (not on quantity but on quality) so they don't grow to their full potential height. Their people tend to be smaller. As soon as they become richer their youth starts to be taller. Are you saying that is better to starve the youth to save on future feed or clothings?
- chiefalchemist 8y agoRe: income as purchasing power. Perhaps. But none the less, as stated, that does not mean ppl are eating __better__. Fact: More ppl now die as a result of too much food, than not enough.
- otherme123 8y agoSomething to eat is __better__ than nothing. You keep reducing The World to The US and it's not the same thing. Many, many people in the world starved in terms of vitamins and other nutrients, and they just fill their body with rice or corn floor. Which is just shy of dying from starvation, and put any body in the brink of the death at the minimal illness. In those cases, almost any increase in the quantity of food different from rice or floor is beneficial. Suddenly, millions of people could add carrots, tomatoes, oranges, pepper... to their monotonic diet, for the same or even less money. Yes, billions of people are eating __better__ than 30 years ago. But you insist this is wrong because some people in the US cannot shut their mouth and somehow are forced to eat beef in buckets. Please, explain me how this is related to people starving in Africa 20-30 years ago, or if you are saying thantobesity is a problem there.