3 ms·
There have been dairy issues since forever. It works like this, if you just let the market decide then a few big dairy producers will drive all of the other da
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
There have been dairy issues since forever.
It works like this, if you just let the market decide then a few big dairy producers will drive all of the other dairies out of business and the only milk products on the market will be of lower quality than they are today. If you prop up the market with subsidies and minimum prices you force the cost of milk to rise and natural economics causes people to substitute something else that is less expensive. But if the subsidies are paid to the farmers, and not to the consumers, the farmers keep producing milk products even when the market doesn't want them at the price they are producing them.
Places that would like dairy products outside the US are already protecting their own dairy farmers and so they are tariffing the heck out of milk (see the Canadian discussion as part of the USMCA proposal).
Many dairy products are perishable with a short life although a big chunk of my uncle's dairy output ended up as non-fat dry milk. This makes it harder to store over periods of lower demand, and cows produce at a fairly constant rate whether you like it or not. Supply management is tough.
Milk and cheese would be a good candidate for a basic income sort of scheme. Where everyone would be issued milk and cheese vouchers every month that could be exchanged for milk and cheese at the local package milk store. People who didn't want their coupons could give them to people who did. That would create a 'base layer' of milk production and consumption that would keep dairies around but take milk and cheese out of the cost of living equation. I'm sure there are other reasons why this is impractical but the whole problem is fairly intractable as it is without putting farms out of business.
EDIT: One interesting thing would be to tie the price of sugared drinks to the price of milk. So it wouldn't be cheaper to give your kids soda than milk. Again, impractical but it is a challenging problem.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Milk and cheese would be a good candidate for a basic income sort of scheme Why milk? Vegetables make more sense. Milk is not a necessary foodstuff. Creating labelling standards for high-quality milk and letting the market do its job would be the most-reasonable outcome.
- barrkel 8y agoThat's a universal argument for industrializing all food production. No food is a necessary foodstuff. It does not follow that all our food should be industrially produced. (Free market food production will end up industrially produced, because that's how you minimize costs and maximize profits. I, for one, don't want to live in a country like that and will vote for laws that help prevent it happening.)
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Free market food production will end up industrially produced, because that's how you minimize costs and maximize profits Post-war Americans prioritised price. So the market made industrial food. (There was also the influence of World War II’s military-oriented factories pivoting to peacetime production.) The situation is not the same today. There is demand for non-industrially produced food among those who can afford it. For those who can’t, I find it morally disturbing that those of us who can afford it want to tell them what they can and cannot buy. If a low-income person decides to spend their food voucher on industrially-produced cheese so they can use the surplus on fruits and vegetables (or pizzas), that’s their choice. In any case, if the goal is less industrially-produced cheese, our subsidy regime accomplished that inefficiently.
- barrkel 8y agoThe trouble is that there's a ratchet effect which makes non-industrial food increasingly uncompetitive over time, and the only people who can afford decent goods and services are those who are wealthy. I wrote a long comment on this over a year ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13306700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13306700 I'm sorry for your feeling of disturbance. I can't help your sense of righteous indignation, but I don't believe free markets always deliver superior results to democracy.
- taborj 8y ago> If a low-income person decides to spend their food voucher on industrially-produced cheese so they can use the surplus on fruits and vegetables (or pizzas), that’s their choice. That only works if there are no carry-on effects of their eating habits (i.e. subsidized health costs, etc). If we can reduce those carry-on costs by forcing the purchase of healthier options, then the system is more sustainable. Add to that the fact that food subsidy programs are not intended to be a lifestyle -- they're supposed to be there to help people in times of need, a crutch to help them between jobs, not a solution to their joblessness. In other words, there should be some motivating factor to become self-sufficient.
- Twirrim 8y ago> Milk and cheese would be a good candidate for a basic income sort of scheme. Where everyone would be issued milk and cheese vouchers every month that could be exchanged for milk and cheese at the local package milk store. People who didn't want their coupons could give them to people who did. That would create a 'base layer' of milk production and consumption that would keep dairies around but take milk and cheese out of the cost of living equation. I'm sure there are other reasons why this is impractical but the whole problem is fairly intractable as it is without putting farms out of business. Been there, done that? Government Cheese! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_cheese https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_cheese https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/08/31/643486297/episode-862-big-government-cheese https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/08/31/643486297/epis...
- tim333 8y agoAlso when I moved to Ireland we got butter vouchers (pic https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B6Vv4MGCYAA424H.jpg:large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B6Vv4MGCYAA424H.jpg:large)