5 ms·
At any business effort beyond hyper local markets, there is virtually no way to avoid tainted money or unethical markets. You're going to have to compromise som
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
At any business effort beyond hyper local markets, there is virtually no way to avoid tainted money or unethical markets. You're going to have to compromise somewhere. The question is, how and where do you draw the line?
At some point as a founder/fundraiser, you will cross paths with finance or supply chains that support exploitation, coercion, violence or illegality.
The most successful business people don't seem to care about these cases, and as long as they don't come with explicit connections that would be bad for business or can't be managed, the more the merrier.
At any scale of business that is globally impactful, it's fundamentally impossible to avoid these chains, so I'm not sure what the actual response should be.
I've thought through many approaches here, from realpolitik pragmatism to ethical fundamentalism but none feel correct.
- loceng 8y agoIn fact for the corrupt, it could even be viewed as a net positive to know you have bad actor money "on your team" - whom may directly or indirectly help your cause to get things in your favour.
- threatofrain 8y agoThat's true for any "side", corrupt or non-corrupt -- you want more money because you trust your moral vision more.
- loceng 8y agoThen that "non-corrupt side" is corrupt, therefore it's only the corrupt who do this; is ignorance bliss and an acceptable excuse and make you less responsible, how far along the chain of trust is enough? Someone's moral compass is inherent to the equation - their path dictated by their ability to understand/be compassionate, and level of non-violent practice they hold themselves to; if they lead with bad acting and violence as "a means to the end" then I'd argue they're less intelligent - whether through emotional blocks from unhealed trauma early in life that put their ego mind up on guard and started layering coping mechanisms that blocked ability for compassion, and/or inherently on their genetics, brain structure, has prevented this. This is all a holistic fight against violence and aggression, which through intelligence, the battle has become more and more and more subtle as a means of violence sustaining itself; we quickly put someone in confinement if they're physically aggressive and attack someone in our society, however manipulation and the such is perhaps the least aggressive - and so doesn't cause a reaction until it's perhaps too late, when the network of bad actors is large enough - and where they as a whole eventually realize they are or can get away with more and more.
- dcposch 8y ago> I've thought through many approaches here, from realpolitik pragmatism to ethical fundamentalism but none feel correct. So, vet your LPs case by case, discuss with your partners and use your moral judgement. If a North Korean or Syrian national wants to invest, you are legally required to refuse, in the US. Saudis? Legally allowed, but you have a moral imperative to refuse. A Chinese firm, or maybe Jared Kushner's fund? That depends on your outlook and situation. Just be transparent about who your investors are. -- This idea that it's "virtually no way to avoid tainted money" is pretty cynical and self serving, IMO.
- rococode 8y ago> This idea that it's "virtually no way to avoid tainted money" is pretty cynical and self serving, IMO. Perhaps the real intention behind that idea is more like: "you can avoid tainted money but that money may go straight to your less scrupulous competitors". If you don't take the money, someone else will, and they may use it to beat you. To people whose primary focus is the growth of their own business, that could be a big cost for upholding their own sense of moral justice.
- empath75 8y ago> To people whose primary focus is the growth of their own business, that could be a big cost for upholding their own sense of moral justice. Not generally a fan of biblical quotes, but: "For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?"
- sneak 8y agoIt goes pretty deep everywhere. https://twitter.com/aplusk/status/1021409519098769408 https://twitter.com/aplusk/status/1021409519098769408
- avip 8y agoI think most "us" are aware of the fact that we are essentially exporting human rights violations and environmental impact in return for low-cost items. So, one can only conclude we don't really care. Caring would have implied an immediate, drastic change in lifestyle.
- enraged_camel 8y ago>>You're going to have to compromise somewhere. The question is, how and where do you draw the line? I think in this particular instance, the line is quite clear. I mean, “does not cut people to pieces alive with a hand saw in their own embassy” is a rather easy one to not compromise on.
- qaq 8y agoWhat would be the time frame you care about I would not be so sure that even most western governments did not cross a similar line in one form or the other. It certainly the case that US have being propping up or even installing regimes that were involved in mass atrocities. So as much as we like to feel like we are above this type of thing the reality is that we are directly or indirectly responsible for much worst atrocities. We have being propping up Saudi Royal family for how many decades now?
- sonnyblarney 8y ago" there is virtually no way to avoid tainted money or unethical markets." What is an 'unethical market'? Oil? Investors who vote for Trump? Or Clinton? Who support guns? Or who don't? Are citizens of Saudi Arabia punished because of the actions of their government? If missiles come raining down on Ridyahd, and Saudi's destroy the locale/group that did it, is this unethical? It's such a pandora's box. But I agree it'd be nice to have some transparency.
- buboard 8y agoThis doesn't sound so convincingly acceptable if we consider that their investments make profits, which end up funding whatever unethical thing they do.
- Kinnard 8y agoNo way to completely avoid? Perhaps. But there are many ways to reduce.