4 ms·
The concept of basic income seems kind of absurd to me, honestly. Infrastructure is crumbling, the educational system is slowly falling apart, urban areas in ce
by keiferski 8y ago
The concept of basic income seems kind of absurd to me, honestly. Infrastructure is crumbling, the educational system is slowly falling apart, urban areas in certain cities are becoming less and less maintained, etc. I see no reason why basic income would be preferable to a Public Works Administration-style program that pays people to do these tasks.
- ddingus 8y agoSame. I dislike Basic Income because it boils down to a payoff to prop up otherwise unbridled capitalism. I am a capitalist. Markets, innovation, and all that are beautiful. But, we take too much. There must be more investment in the mutual, public good.
- RaceWon 8y agoI fall into the basic mold that you describe (a capitalist and so on), and I felt the same until I read everything Y Combinator was doing regarding basic income. It made sense to me. Here's the link if you have some time to read all the docs... https://basicincome.ycr.org/ https://basicincome.ycr.org/
- ddingus 8y agoI have read that. Not sold. And to be clear, the intent is good. No problem. I do not see a positive outcome, as in a healthy, balanced society with robust and meaningful checks and balances. We need that. I do not trust the outcomes without it.
- RaceWon 8y agoOk, I'm glad you read it. For sure the jury is out on this, and your instincts may well be correct. It does seem as though YC is at least looking to see if this is truly a good idea or not based on the way the experiment is being conducted.
- ddingus 8y agoTotally. I think the experiment so far have been interesting. I don't think they're long enough, and I think the sample sizes are small too. But we might learn something.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I see no reason why basic income would be preferable to a Public Works Administration-style program that pays people to do these tasks. Basic income naturally scales up with improvements in productivity driven by automation and reduces labor market friction and enables adjustment to changing conditions. PWA beginners increasingly obviously pointless, wasteful soul-crushing make-work with progressive automation and increases labor-market friction obstructing adjustment. The latter works as a short-term collapse in demand for a kind of work that is expected to recover, the former is a long-term alternative to means-tested else programs that mitigates adverse incentives and other inefficiencies. Both are potentially useful but don't address remotely the same set of problems.
- keiferski 8y ago> PWA beginners increasingly obviously pointless, wasteful soul-crushing make-work with progressive automation and increases labor-market friction obstructing adjustment. I don't know what this sentence is supposed to mean. Can you clarify?
- raquo 8y agoAt the scale of the problem that UBI is supposed to fix, there probably won't be nearly enough meaningful (needed) PWA-like jobs for people to do.