4 ms·
Well, what did they expect? This is sounding ever more like the Quebec referendum, they didn't separate in the end, but the damage was done. I'm in favour of
by raverbashing 8y ago
Well, what did they expect?
This is sounding ever more like the Quebec referendum, they didn't separate in the end, but the damage was done.
I'm in favour of letting them eat their cake and enjoy a complete separation.
- yostrovs 8y agoIf there wouldn't be the Northern Ireland/Ireland border, an intractable problem, this would be over long ago.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y agoAre you saying that the Irish border is the only intractable problem in brexit? I don't think that's actually true.
- vidarh 8y agoBut it's the only part of the problem where the "wrong" solution has a real risk of reigniting armed conflict.
- nailer 8y agoI don't think they are, but it's obviously the biggest. EU want a sea border keeping RoI/NI open, UK won't accept the break up of their union.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoIn other words, UK wants to keep their union, EU wants to keep their union, nobody bothers to ask the Irish, as usual.
- dorchadas 8y agoWhich is hilarious, as NI voted 'Remain'. However, I'm still not sure if it's time for a United Ireland. Still a lot of animosity between the sides.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoI don't think there's any good solution: even the current one took over a decade to negotiate. Any territorial changes are unlikely to remain nonviolent - united Ireland, hard border, independent NI, it's all very explosive.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y ago> EU wants to keep their union, nobody bothers to ask the Irish I don't think so, no. The Republic of Ireland is the EU in this case. Or part of it, in agreement and solidarity with the other parts. There are plenty of statements from the ROI's political leaders to this effect.
- jimnotgym 8y agoNo, but it is a big issue that involves messing with an agreement (the Good Friday Agreement) put in place to stop a bloody conflict. An agreement that is co-guaranteed by the USA and... the EU!
- Piskvorrr 8y agoThere's plenty of hard problems to go around, but this one is definitely incompatible with any peaceful brexit. Brace yourselves, Troubles 2.0 are coming.
- raverbashing 8y agoTrue, and it's much more complicated than it looks from the outside (or even from the rest of the UK)
- pknight 8y agoActually, no, companies still would be facing sudden & unwanted barriers and there would still be the unresolved issue of whether the UK would diverge from the Single Market or not. It would still have the potential to wreck several sectors, with companies being forced to trigger their contingency plans. Even just taking the IT industry, with the UK slated to leave the Digital version of the Single Market while repelling talent, it is a disaster by design.
- yostrovs 8y agoBrexit would certainly be done by now without the border issue. Maybe painfully or imperfectly, but intractable problems don't even have painful solutions.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y agoIreland isn't even the only border issue to Brexit. There's also Gibraltar.
- Lio 8y agoWho’s “they” in this scenario? I know it’s easy to pretend that Brexit got a massive majority but really it didn’t. It was just 52-48%. A large number of us didn’t vote for it and still don’t want Brrexit.
- raverbashing 8y agoThe leavers, who think untangling a web of commercial, legal and financial connections (which a lot of them depend on - I can't wait to see the face of the farmers when their EU subsidies stop coming) is as easy as unplugging their kettle.
- BozeWolf 8y agoDo not be so so harsh on the people who wanted the brexit. They have made a mistake, probably. Some of them realize that. As a pro eu person from nl(if that even exists) i would prefer not to give uk a hard time to come back on their decision. And even íf they really quit: we still have to work together. It is in interest of all of us to have the uk with us. It is just impossible to negotiate for brexit and cherry pick all the good parts of the eu, while not doing something in return. They will end up with a eu type of deal, with a few minor things stripped off. Or a hard brexit, which may not even happen. It is a shitty situation, which starts to affect my life as well. I have some stocks on a company “degiro” which has its license in the uk. This is a problem because i am unsure what is going to happen. I moved my investments to a broker with dutch bank accounts and licenses.
- raverbashing 8y agoFair enough > They will end up with a eu, with a few minor things stripped off. Maybe. They had that already
- matthewmacleod 8y agoThat's the ideal outcome. The problem is that rhetoric in the UK has shifted away from "Leave the EU in a structured manner with most of the bits intact" to "full-scale immediate departure with no planning for the future". That's going to be a medium-term disaster. Honestly the problem isn't Brexit itself. I don't agree with that policy, but it's possible to see how it could be executed in a constructive and honest fashion. If we were able to accept that there are benefits to EU membership, but that we were willing to give those up in exchange for theoretically greater sovereignty, the situation would be better. If we were working towards a scenario that was minimally damaging, while importantly being honest about the tradeoffs, then the country would make some progress. Instead we have an absolute catastrophe of untruth circulating. Large parts of the party of government appear to be aiming for a no-deal, cliff-edge event, claiming that everything will be fine. A huge share of the population seem to think that "no deal" means "status quo" instead of "immediate large-scale problems". I don't know how we deal with that. We're genuinely in the time of post-facts, post-truth politics, and I don't know that we currently have the tools to fix that.
- frabbit 8y agoWhat damage was done to Quebec? Sure, a bunch of francophobic anglos fled to Ontario, but Quebec remains a vibrant society with a semi-functioning healthcare system and a decent univeristy system. Now, the election of the CAQ last mont: _that_ is likely to cause some damage if they succeed in enacting their stale neo-liberal policies and fail to react to the CLIMATE CHANGE CRISIS.
- raverbashing 8y agoToronto became the effective "capital" of Canada, in place of Montreal (Even the Bank of Montreal moved to Toronto) Not everyone who left QC is a francophobic, and while I do understand some of the French side's worries, things like Loi 101 are sometimes "too much" (like requiring board games to be in French)
- JeanMarcS 8y agoAs a French, it was strange to see Happy Meals called Joyeux festin in Montreal, and other stuff like that. In France, we also got a law (Loi Toubon) saying you must translate anything from another language to French, for exemple in ads (most propably for preventing misunderstanding). But you can still have slogan in english (or another language).
- frabbit 8y agoLooking at the impact of the City of London on Greater London, or the finacial services sector on Dublin or Silicon Valley on Palo Alto it seems to me that the flight of major, centralized economic powers (with the ability to distort democracy) is a net win for most locations. Quebec continues to do well despite the relocation of a few businesses.