4 ms·
> kicks businesses out of food stamp program on dubious fraud charges > Mejia violated the agency’s rules, which prohibit retailers from establishing informal
by chrisseaton 8y ago
> kicks businesses out of food stamp program on dubious fraud charges
> Mejia violated the agency’s rules, which prohibit retailers from establishing informal credit systems with their customers.
> many of them, like [Mejia], were probably unjustly caught in the crosshairs
So which is it? Is the charge unjust and dubious, or did he violate the rules?
(Not making any political point myself - just can't even work out what the opinion of the article is on whether he was doing something that was not allowed in the system he was using.)
- anon4738383 8y agoMost likely, the the charge is unjust. There are many such algorithmic processes across the country that also accuse people of fraud without any evidence, based solely on weak, inferential, correlation of indirect data... and these accusations come with criminal and civil penalties. It's just another indictment of America's two-tiered justice system, where the poor are guilty-until-proven-innocent, and often just brushed into prison with little or no due process or representation.
- raincom 8y agoHe violated rules, rules that were set up to avoid fraud. This is what happens, when one reduces everything to a set of rules. There are actions that are not fraudulent (as the case with Mejia), but considered fraudulent by rules set up by the agency. This is a case where agencies hide behind rules, algorithms, etc.
- stretchwithme 8y agoYou have to have rules for such a program. You can't have fraud judged arbitrarily or allow anything regardless of how easy it makes it to commit fraud. This guy should have read the rules and followed them. If he's not willing to do that, then the decision to end the relationship with him makes sense.
- geofft 8y ago> You can't have fraud judged arbitrarily or allow anything regardless of how easy it makes it to commit fraud. Why not, exactly? Whatever rules you set up, you'll have false positives and false negatives. Some people will figure out how to do illegitimate things without being noticed by the rules. And some people will find the rules too burdensome and fail to do legitimate things aligned with the program's goals. There is an old proverb in law: Better that ten guilty persons go free than that one innocent person is punished. It might serve the program's goals better to decide, we're willing to allow some amount of fraud in order to make sure the program functions smoothly and people don't get trapped by rules, or we're willing to allow some amount of fraud because the cost of enforcement outweighs the fraud itself. (Major retailers work like this, for instance; they budget in some amount of expected shoplifting, because it's cheaper than both increasing security and potentially scaring off customers with increased and hostile security.) It might also not serve the program's goals better, and you want to take a hard line at the risk of blocking legitimate use. But it's not obvious the latter is the right approach.
- stretchwithme 8y agoBecause we live in a democracy and everyone has access to the court system and you don't want to be in court all of the time. This program is funded by the taxpayer, after all. And, yes, rules aren't perfect. But you can keep improving them as you learn more. And that leaves you with, yet again, a set of rules.
- candiodari 8y agoI would bet that for a government agency, merely calling that "fraud" in any public communication is highly illegal. They are the government, and they cannot make such statements about individuals or individual businesses, they can only file a legal complaint, and the point out they've done so, nothing more. I can claim someone comitted fraud, you can (still risky though, but not per se illegal, only illegal if you do it to damage the other person in any way, not if you merely genuinly think they committed fraud), but they can't (not even if there's zero damage). Not allowed. So sue them. They deserve it.
- geofft 8y ago> So which is it? Is the charge unjust and dubious, or did he violate the rules? Both these things can be true. I think the point of the article is that there was no fraud against the government, in the sense that he did not bill them for food stamps that never existed - he maintained a credit system, which is against the rules, but not fraudulent. (The definition of fraud requires the victim of fraud to have actually lost something; unless you argue that the government lost interest from floating some people's food for a few days, they weren't actually defrauded.) This is why (if I'm reading it right) the article says that the government didn't prove fraud (because he didn't keep itemized receipts) - the intent of the rule and the algorithm is to catch people using food stamps on ineligible purchases, using nonexistent food stamps, etc. The investigation could have proved that no fraud existed if it turned out he gave them credit for eligible purchases, or that it did exist if he gave them credit for ineligible purchases, or made up credit out of thin air, but it didn't prove anything because there were no records. So violation of the rules got him kicked out of the system.
- protomyth 8y ago> I think the point of the article is that there was no fraud against the government Mejia violated the agency’s rules, which prohibit retailers from establishing informal credit systems with their customers. The agency wanted itemized receipts for the purchases that had been flagged, but Mejia’s cash registers at the time printed only total sales figures; he couldn’t provide an accounting of the individual products that his clients had bought on credit. He admitted to breaking a rule of the program, so all his transactions were now fraudulent. Then he couldn't prove that those transactions weren't fraudulent because he had no itemized records of each purchase. He is quite lucky all they did was kick him out of the program. Frankly, anyone who enters one of these programs and doesn't keep records of what was purchased is foolish. This is a program that will come down like a hammer if you let someone microwave a legally bought burrito while still in the store since it then becomes illegal.
- geofft 8y ago> He admitted to breaking a rule of the program, so all his transactions were now fraudulent. I don't think that's what "fraudulent" means. The agency might assert that it's fraudulent, but that doesn't mean that it is fraudulent. That's the article's point. (And if there's a way for him to have proved it wasn't fraudulent, that necessarily means it hasn't been proven fraudulent yet.) To your second point: sure, he probably did something strategically wrong. And yes, he broke the rules. But that's not the question the article is asking. The question the article is asking is, is an agency that brings down the hammer on illegally microwaved burritos actually doing something responsible, just, and good for society?
- UncleEntity 8y ago> [Mejia] says he knows he broke the rules by allowing customers to buy on credit, and he accepts the agency’s decision to permanently disqualify him from SNAP. So he broke the rules, not in an attempt to defraud the system but by helping out the neighbors by giving them credit on purchases. ...which I could see as causing a problem, you spend all your benefits for next month, pay off the bill when they put money on the card, spend all your benefits for next month, rinse and repeat.
- protomyth 8y agonot in an attempt to defraud the system but by helping out the neighbors by giving them credit on purchases At this point, he cannot prove that was the case since he doesn't have records of the items purchased. He might be on the side of angels, but he sure is doing everything a scammer would do. Plus, the whole pay next month thing is just fundamentally a problem (what happens if eligibility is lost?) in addition to the treadmill you pointed out.
- geofft 8y ago> Plus, the whole pay next month thing is just fundamentally a problem (what happens if eligibility is lost?) Then the store owner can't cash in the food stamp and has extended credit to the customer, which is a problem for the store owner but not for the food stamp agency. Why should the food stamp agency get involved?
- protomyth 8y agoBecause its specifically is outlawed and the store owner is going to try to collect which is the reason it was outlawed in the first place. There is a long history of people / companies extending credit in a manner that would indenture people to the people / company. See any reference to company stores in the US. That's the environment that the law was setup in.