8 ms·
Microsoft could have a flawed development process but the slowness of the update procedure and how it seizes control of the machine is much worse in terms of UX
by pmontra 8y ago
Microsoft could have a flawed development process but the slowness of the update procedure and how it seizes control of the machine is much worse in terms of UX. My Ubuntu laptop gets updates almost every day. I could make them happen in background but I want to know what's going on so I make it display the list in a window, check it and click OK. From now on it takes little time to finish, even if there are new versions of the kernel. I recently updated a Windows Server 2016 VM switched off since September and it was a half day long nightmare of downloading / updating / rebooting loops. If I ever considered to move back to Windows (I never did) that would have made me change my mind. Anything but Windows.
- coldtea 8y agoDoesn't sound like a relevant complaint. Your Ubuntu desktop only takes security and bugfix updates regularly. If you've tried going from an Ubuntu LTS to another Ubuntu LTS, 2+ years on, you'd find tons of things changed too -- even if your old LTS had everyday updates.
- simion314 8y agoThis is true, the difference is that your not forced into feature upgrades, you can stay with an LTS 5 years if it works for you. Second difference is that upgrades will take less times and reboots. There is also a risk that stuff will not work better after the upgrade.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoThe Windows equivalent is Enterprise LTSC. Its not available to the common public though.
- simion314 8y agoThat is unfortunate, why not have a Home edition that is an LTS, only security updates, less chances of bricking computers or deleting user data. I know MS hated that people were using XP and not buying Win7 but they exaggerated by pushing updates like Chrome browser does.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoBecause MS knows nobody wants to pay $€200+ for an OS anymore? They are giving away win10 practically for free. MacOS is free. ChromeOS is free. Windows had to evolve as well. Paying for software is the past. If MS did commercially release Enterprise LTSC it wouldn't sell. Instead it would just encourage piracy.
- syrrim 8y agoThe motte for forced updates is that they are security updates.
- didibus 8y agoI use the rolling release of OpenSuse and my daily updates are still flawless and non intrusive. There's definitly room for Windows to improve in this regard, specially considering Linux already does it better and that was developed by volunteers for free.
- kurtisc 8y agoTo be pedantic (of course), most of the contributions to Linux are from people paid to do it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AsyncAwait 8y agoI don't buy this, am on a rolling-release distro and have pretty much the same experience as the OP.
- coldtea 8y agoA rolling release is not an LTS (of which I was talking about). Windows follows an LTS model. It can't go changing from under pros and businesses that use it everyday...
- AsyncAwait 8y agoHuh,? you said: > Your Ubuntu desktop only takes security and bugfix updates regularly. A rolling release explicitly doesn't just provide security updates, so my point is Windows updating more core components than Ubuntu LTS is no excuse.
- coldtea 8y agoI'm saying, Windows does it like Ubuntu LTS (and has to do it that way, for pros and businesses like it to not change under them unless they explicitly switch version which can happen after many years), not like a rolling release.
- AsyncAwait 8y agoBut nor Ubuntu LTS, nor a rolling-release takes as long to update as Windows does, so what's your claim? In either case it takes significantly longer to upgrade Windows than it does Linux.
- netheril96 8y agoOne of the cause is that Windows by default does not allow you to remove or replace opened files. So to update anything you have to close all applications holding an handle to it.
- spatulon 8y agoThe fact that FILE_SHARE_DELETE has to be explicitly specified in calls to CreateFile, and that the file APIs in most languages don't use it or allow it to be specified, has to be one of the top three annoyances I have in using Windows as my primary development machine. There's a parallel universe in which FILE_SHARE_DELETE is opt-out, not opt-in, and Windows is a far more pleasant OS in that universe. My other two top annoyances, for anyone curious, are the appalling filesystem performance and the high process-creation overhead.
- AnonymousPlanet 8y agoThe many lockdowns on opened files (even just reading) is one of biggest design flaws in Windows and has cost me many hours dealing with it. It makes a lot of things needlessly complicated: from updates over file based backups to sometimes even just reading a fscking logfile or config file.
- selimnairb 8y agoYes, pessimistic file locking is a fatal design flaw in Windows. Where did they get this idea, VMS? What problems is it meant to solve? Unixen seem to get along fine without it.
- elpocko 8y agoWindows Update and Telemetry made me switch from a Windows 10 + VMWare setup to a Linux + KVM setup for my desktop. The new setup has its flaws, but it works much better than Windows overall. Windows Update is terrible.
- on_and_off 8y agoAndroid has an interesting model here : IIRC on newer versions of the OS, updates are applied on a separate partition without interrupting you. I don't know if it causes performance loss during that time, so far it has been seemless for me but I don't have updates everyday either .. Only when the update completes will the OS asks you to reboot so it can start from that new version. Sure it uses a ton of storage to do things this way, but it is very secure and pleasant to use.
- amaccuish 8y agoThat started with Chrome OS
- dijit 8y agoIf we’re going to assign praise to the invention then I remember seeing it as part of FreeNAS nearly a decade ago. (Interestingly they recently deprecated this method of updating.) And JunOS (the juniper network appliance operating system based on freebsd.) has had this since version 10.4 which was released in 2010.
- canhascodez 8y agoMicrosoft's approach to updates has always been a criminal waste of their users resources, particularly their time.
- collyw 8y agoTrue. I have had Windows machines from work which I install Linux on as a dual boot. I need to use Windows maybe two or three times a year, and it can take hours for software updates to install when I do log in.
- chris_wot 8y agoI cannot understand why there are so many updates. It's seriously ridiculous.
- pizza234 8y agoI humorously think that when Microsoft does bad hires, it puts them in the Windows Update team (Google makes them work on Google Keep, instead). I've always wondered (seriously, not rhetorically) which are the technical grounds that make Windows update so bad. In addition to reboot loops: - WU has a long history of hanging; it took I think a couple of years to release the "final" patch for update hangs. I'm not even sure if it works; I wouldn't bet that a machine with Windows 7 would be able to download all the updates without hanging or taking days (we're talking about around 100 updates; apt, for reference, manages a pool at least 2 orders of magnitude bigger) - the workflow is not deterministic; updates may or may not succeed - the UX is abysmal: the status descriptions are unclear; the progress percentage doesn't reflect the actual time, or is disbalanced towards stages which don't make evident why they take so much time; the error messages are completely unhelpful. - it's also completely unclear why some updates need to be applied both after shutdown and before startup. "Thankfully" they gave the option to download them once a month, which all in all, equals to choose between usability and security.
- romed 8y agoDamn, that was harsh on Google Keep. It was basically written by and operated by a single person in his spare time.
- threatofrain 8y agoEspecially in light of the fact that one of Google Keep's competitors on the iOS context is Apple Notes, which presumably has more than one person working on it through spare time.
- bertjk 8y agoIs this still the case? I would be very interested in reading more about the person/team behind it.. Are there articles/blog posts you can point to?
- freditup 8y agoI actually quite like Google Keep. Curious why you view it as so bad?
- juststeve 8y agoI'm also running Windows Server 2016 in a vm at home, i notice that i start up this vm less and less because i am expecting a long update cycle before i can start any work. sometimes it's actually unusable until it's finished applying updates. (this is on an i7 with 8GB of ram, 4gb for the vm). The contrast with linux is night and day.
- slavik81 8y agoe.g. "[Windows update has] been going for 4 hours and I need to present my masters thesis in 7 minutes." https://www.reddit.com/r/Wellthatsucks/comments/9j72qb/been_going_for_4_hours_and_i_need_to_present_my/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Wellthatsucks/comments/9j72qb/been_...
- cptskippy 8y agoIs it fair to compare your daily update experience to a month's worth of Windows updates? That's like me saying it takes over an hour to update my OctoPi instance when I remember to do it semi annually, therefore all *nix updates are broken.
- AgentME 8y agoLinux distros generally are still usable while updating. Maybe there's a normal-length reboot at the end to switch to a new kernel, but you aren't required to do that immediately.