4 ms·
As someone who is definitely layman in the area, can somebody break it down to me why would people choose an RPi, ODroid, OrangePi or any other small and fanles
by pdimitar 8y ago
As someone who is definitely layman in the area, can somebody break it down to me why would people choose an RPi, ODroid, OrangePi or any other small and fanless computers for this or that scenario?
I am very interested in making a home NAS, a Pi-Hole, an OpenVPN server and possibly a VM host -- what are my options if I want a few servers in my bedroom with zero fan noise (even during the summer when the room temperature can be at 35-40 Celsius)? Or should I just sacrifice one floor of shelf space in my small storage room and make sure the machines have good fan cooling?
I've been meaning to inform myself on the subject but real life and job changes have been very annoying and I was recently shocked by the memory that "I've been meaning to do it" for like 2 years now.
So can somebody give a layman a few pros and cons of our options?
(I will definitely use Ethernet on all my home servers. Not interested in how good -- or existent -- their WiFi adapters are. It would even be a bonus for me if I can physically turn off the WiFi on them.)
- vtail 8y agoYou are opening a Pandora’s box :). There is truly no easy answer - too much depends on your budget, needs, OS of choice, etc. A good way to start is to follow a few subreddits, like r/datahoarder or r/homelab to get some inspiration and understand what are the options etc. But since you still need an answer, here is something to get you started: 1) For fanless and ease of setup, buy a Synology/QNAP NAS, and install additional software there - $300+ w/o disks. 2) For future proof, buy Dell T30 on eBay for $300 and install FreeNAS on it.
- pdimitar 8y agoEh, why Pandora's box? It's true I didn't give tons of details though. ...Is there any other option than Linux for a server OS? Like, practically? I know there are a bunch of others but speaking about everyday classic needs... is there really a choice? Budget -- I never did mind paying $1000 instead of $150 but it has to be worth it. I don't want to sheepishly buy the latest and greatest, especially after seeing many times in my programming career how a very modest machine (when properly tuned) can be a very decent server that can last you all the way until you need rented dedicated servers in several data centers. (Example: I gave up on the idea of an OpenVPN server on an RPi 3 after making a research on the expected bandwidth. It would be too small.) Thanks for the recommendations! Writing them down (not joking).
- vtail 8y agoI was half-joking, of course, and what I meant is that it’s an optimization problem with multiple dimensions and tons of trade-offs. E.g., - low power or performance? - ease of use vs. tunability? - closed vs. open-source? For the server OS, your choices are practically either Linux or FreeBSD (FreeNAS is based on the latter). If you don’t need zfs for NAS, OpenBSD becomes another interesting option - assuming the hardware is supported, is rock solid and easy to administrate, but may have some learning curve. Tinkering with something like RaspberryPi is not a bad idea - you will spend $50 or so but will learn a ton and in the process will understand your own requirements better. However, if you want NAS, I recommend buying a server-class hardware (like T30 mentioned above) and invest time in understanding how to use zfs and do reliable backups, assuming your data is valueable. I personally don’t think you should aim for lower power for NAS with any serious amount of data.
- pdimitar 8y agoSounds like a lot of learning I have to do. I am not opposed to it; everything gets more and more hijacked to closed gardens so I feel more of us should go the extra mile and find out how open-source things work. Just not sure when will I be financially secure enough for it. Thank you, I am definitely writing down everything written in the thread. I will get to tinkering at some point.
- fulafel 8y agotl;dr - get X86 hardware, not ARM. Most ARM boards have lacking software support and run vendor supplied patched distributions or kernels that are out of date (or at least will be after a short period of lagging updates). If you wanted to run a robust and patched up ARM Linux distribution for networked use, you usually want timely security patches, and this requirement narrows down the options a lot. Even the best board-specific distros (like Raspbian) lag in the security updates dept so for many uses you want to look at which boards are officially supported by mainstream distros.
- pdimitar 8y ago> tl;dr - get X86 hardware, not ARM. Thank you for the down-to-earth advice. It helps a lot. I realize I can search for that myself but in any case, which machines work well with the more conservative distros -- like Slackware and some of the BSDs?
- makomk 8y agoRaspbian actually has more of a problem with security updates than some of the competing distros, because the original Raspberry Pi and the Zero use an obsolete ARM sub-architecture that none of the major upstream distros support, so they have to recompile every single package. If you use a board supported by the Debian flavour of Armbian for instance, that gets security updates for everything but the kernel and bootloader direct from the Debian stable repositories.
- watchdogtimer 8y agoIt's true that many board vendors use out-of-date kernels and rarely update their software. But community editions like [Armbian](https://www.armbian.com https://www.armbian.com) are usually kept fully up to date. I've been using multiple ARM-based SBCs as desktop computers over a year now and have really been impressed with how software support has improved. It used to be only older versions of Firefox would run. Now most boards that use Ubuntu 18.04 (which include most versions of Armbian) will run Firefox 62.
- rjsw 8y agoI'm really happy with an HP MicroServer, it does have a fan but is using a low power CPU so doesn't run hot. None of the cheap ARM systems can take ECC RAM.
- zmix 8y agoSame here. I never understood, why people would opt for an embedded ARM board if other, more attractive options, were available. No ECC and USB<->SATA bridges rule out any serious NAS/server use.
- slantyyz 8y ago>> "I've been meaning to do it" for like 2 years now. If this is the case, I'd suggest you get an appliance instead. ASUSTOR (and others) make NASes with Intel processors and upgradeable RAM. In addition to having a wide selection of apps/servers, they can do Docker and VirtualBox and can be up and running in a matter of minutes.
- pdimitar 8y agoThese look well-supported. A bit bigger than what I hoped for but if they are indeed whisper-quiet then it's well worth it. Thanks!
- slantyyz 8y agoI don't know that they're whisper quiet though. You'll probably hear the clicking of the mechanical hard drives when they're doing I/O. I'm not sure you can avoid size when you're dealing with multiple NAS appropriate drives, i.e. those in the 3.5" form factor. My 2 drive unit is about the size of a small toaster.
- pdimitar 8y agoI don't mind the drives much but the constant stronger fan noise from CPU / GPU / motherboard can really tick me off. For my NAS I would bet that I would have to put it in a storage room, yep. Especially having in mind I would want to expand it with further drives in the future.
- ttsiodras 8y agoMy personal experience: I started looking into this category of HW - SBCs, that is - 4 years ago. Initially, it was mostly curiosity ; to see whether I could apply my UNIX knowledge on these tiny machines, and whether I could coax them into doing actually useful things. The result: I am addicted :-) Not in the sense of idiotic consumerism - no, I only bought two of them (a Raspberry PI 2 and an Orange PI Zero). But in the sense of realizing that they can be put to many, many uses - and perform this work utilizing only a fraction of the energy cost of even the best of x86 designs. I wrote a detailed blog post [1] about what I did with my 11 Euro (not a typo) Orange PI Zero. After that, I set it up as my NFS and Borgbackup server (i.e. I attached my two external portable USB drives on it - and it has multiple USB root-level hubs, so it gives me decent speed on them). A complete backup of my Arch Linux laptop (250GB SSD, MB Air from 2012) takes around 6 minutes to complete over Wi-Fi - and due to the magic of Borgbackup's deduplication, I have about 150 such complete "images" in a bit over 300GB total storage on the two drives. A periodic "scrub" run once a week makes sure there's no bit-rot - and if there is, the btrfs mirror over the two drives corrects it. As for my Raspberry PI2... - setup as an `sslh` gateway; this means that I can use `sshuttle` from the outside world to create on-the-spot SSH-based "VPN"s and access places that are blocked (during travels, work, etc). It basically "transports" my laptop/work computer into my home LAN. - At the same time it is serving up my collected notes over the years on a Let's Encrypt-ed HTTPS private site via NGINX. - FreeDNS provides a nice, easily accessible name for both these services. - An attached RPI camera is used to take a picture every 5 seconds - and if the picture is sufficiently different from the previous one, it encrypts it and uploads it to my Digital Ocean droplet. Whatever happens to my apartment while I'm gone, I get a record of it on a remote server that only I can decode (the remote server doesn't have the GPG key necessary to do so, I have those on me). - The SPI functionality of the PI is also used in my various micro-controller experiments - e.g. to "flash" my ATMEGA328p and have it do silly things [2]. - In general, I am tinkering with electronics - and there's a lot of fun in doing this with SBCs. - At some point, I had it run exim4 as well; and got my mail-tester.com score up to 10/10. The PI2 was 35Euros - the Orange PI zero 11 Euros. The fun I've had building the stuff above? Learning skills? Connecting to them over serial ports and reliving my Uni-days? Priceless :-) [1] https://www.thanassis.space/thebeast.html#thebeast https://www.thanassis.space/thebeast.html#thebeast [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nsqmnkfZtSw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nsqmnkfZtSw