4 ms·
Is this really the case? The two archetypal Western ancient fictions, the Iliad and Odyssey, display emotion front and center: Agammenon's greed and jealousy,
by woodruffw 8y ago
Is this really the case?
The two archetypal Western ancient fictions, the Iliad and Odyssey, display emotion front and center: Agammenon's greed and jealousy, the love between Achilles and Patrocles (and the former's rage at the latter's death), and Priam's mourning all come to mind. Similarly for the Odyssey, a story about nostalgia in the most literal sense: the pain of Odysseus's estrangement from his family, entangled with the pain of returning as a stranger. Homer even refers to him epithetically as "many-pained" and of "many-sorrows."
That's a small sample size, but the same can be seen in Roman love poetry: Horace does not hide the emotions of his subjects[1].
[1]: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Translation:Odes_(Horace)/Book_I/5 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Translation:Odes_(Horace)/Boo...
- paganel 8y agoA Persian poet like Hafez [1], who lived in the 14th century, also deals pretty extensively with feelings, much more so than a lot of novelists and poets from today's age. Granted, I've only read him in translation but even so I remember that his poetry left a definite mark on younger me. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hafez https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hafez
- smnrchrds 8y agoHafez's poems are not fiction. They don't have a plot, they are just pure expressions of emotions. I am curious to know if Ferdowsi ever talks about feelings in Shahnameh [0]. I cannot remember any such instances, but I have only ever read small parts of it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shahnameh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shahnameh
- olavk 8y agoThe Icelandic sagas certainly also portrays emotions. The characters are very much driven by emotions. The point is it is displayed entirely through their actions, not by internal monologue or direct description of their mental states like in 19th century literature. Ancient lyrical poetry like Sappho on the other hand is direct expression of feelings. Ecclesiastes (in the Bible) is a monologue about the narrators feelings and mental state. So it seems to more like a question of genre and narrative style rather than some kind of mental development of humanity. The sagas are not fiction, they are supposed to be about actual historical figures and events. You don't know what a historical figure actually thought and felt, only what they said and did. There are some examples in the sagas where characters directly express their feeling through poetry.
- dvlsg 8y agoIn the wise words of the robot devil, > You can't just have your characters announce how they feel! That makes me feel angry!
- gone35 8y agoLots of "talk about feelings" in the Epic of Gilgamesh (c. 2100 BC); or even the Old Testament, for that matter... Such a disappointing article.
- freddie_mercury 8y agoI guess you are replying to the subject line instead of the actual article because your post makes no sense in the context of the article. As the article says, "In ancient literature, emotions were predictable reactions to external actions or events." All you've done is list people having predictable reactions to external actions and events.... Just like the article says ancient literature did.
- idoubtit 8y agoMost of our emotions are predictable reactions to external actions or events. Fortunately, modern literature hasn't completely forgotten this. The article is not very consistent, because it also states that «in medieval or classical texts, “people are constantly planning, remembering, loving, fearing, but they somehow manage to do this without the author drawing attention to these mental states.” This changed dramatically between 1500 and 1700». The classical Greek tragedies certainly did draw attention to the mental state of their characters. I remember a long monologue of Euripides' Andromache that I would sum up as "This life is too hard. Why did I have a son? I shouldn't have, as my care for him doubles my suffering. But I should not lament, I should act and die for my son."
- drb91 8y agoWhile the Euripides is an excellent counterpoint, you’re not acknowledging the clear rhetorical turn that started with the western novel (or shakespeare, I guess).
- coldtea 8y agoThat's the thing. While we don't deny the "clear rhetorical turn that started with the western novel (or shakespeare)", I (and I think the parent) believe that this turn was in fact a return (to what e.g. ancient Greek, Chinese, etc literature did: talk about feelings) and not some wholly new direction.
- drb91 8y ago
- drb91 8y agoI interpeted “feelings” as “explicit emotional introspection”. There’s a little of this in the Oddysey, but the first book I can think of that clearly does this is Don Quixote. It’s absolutely absurd to interpret the article as saying writers didn’t acknowledge emotion.
- coldtea 8y ago>I interpeted “feelings” as “explicit emotional introspection”. There’s a little of this in the Oddysey Huh? There's lots of this in Oddysey. Even more so in ancient tragedy, and whole lots in lyrical poetry, Sappho etc.
- drb91 8y agoNote I said “a little”, not “little”. You can quibble about the amount but I was trying to explicitly say that the Oddysey IS an example of this in ancient lit. Still nothing compared to Macbeth or Hamlet, though.
- hodgesrm 8y agoWhile it's autobiography rather than fiction, the Confessions of St. Augustine explore the author's state of mind as deeply as any modern work I can think of. It was written around the end of the 4th Century AD. [0] But this article started with an example from the middle ages rather than the ancient world, so lets look there as well. Medieval literature does explore human feelings quite deeply. The stories of Chaucer (Canterbury Tales), Dante (Inferno, etc.), and Boccaccio (Decameron) exhibit characters with a rich internal life. Arguing to the contrary mostly proves you have not read them. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confessions_(Augustine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confessions_(Augustine) (Edit, left this out.)