4 ms·
Would rather save the bucks and go with a Ryzen 2700 unless I was doing avx512 work but who’s doing that these days?
by gigatexal 8y ago
Would rather save the bucks and go with a Ryzen 2700 unless I was doing avx512 work but who’s doing that these days?
- mrbonner 8y agoCould you elaborate why AVX-512 is not important? I guess that you are referring to GPGPU programming is what everybody is doing right now instead of SIMD in the CPU.
- gigatexal 8y agoI could be talking out of my butt but it’s my understanding that AVX512 isn’t used in but few niche programs.
- oconnor663 8y agoIsn't that niche the same as the niche of programs that can realistically max out a modern desktop CPU? Video encoding, compression, and things like that?
- gigatexal 8y agoaccording to this only x265 uses AVX512: https://software.intel.com/en-us/articles/accelerating-x265-with-intel-advanced-vector-extensions-512-intel-avx-512 https://software.intel.com/en-us/articles/accelerating-x265-... But I wouldn't doubt that things like Video encoding / compression uses this. Again, I was not saying it's not valuable just saying that for my use case where I don't encode videos for a living or run a large Handbrake/Plex video farm / library the i9 cpu is not worth as much to me as the cheaper, cooler running Ryzen 2700.
- gigatexal 8y agoIt’s important yes but hard to implement I think and not widely used is what I was getting at. For me compiling and running VMs I’d take the Ryzen over this.
- dragontamer 8y agoThe i9-9900k does NOT support AVX512. The i9-9900x does. (x, not k). Confusing? Yeah. Blame Intel's marketing. Still, the i9-9900k is faster at AVX2 (256-bit), which is useful in H264, Photoshop, and a number of graphical productivity applications. And you can see the benefits of it: the i9-9900k gets close to Threadripper performance on Handbrake due to the AVX2 support, even with half the cores.
- gigatexal 8y agoThe Ryzen chips do AVX2 as well though for some reason the Intel parts often do better. Media applications makes sense to use such cpu features.
- tracker1 8y agoForm other parts of this thread AMD implementation is only 128b, while the lower i9...k is 256, and x also has 512.
- jarjoura 8y agoYea marketing is really confusing here. The 9900k is coffee lake v2. The 9900x is skylake (server) v2. Two totally different chips.