3 ms·
What they denied was that the servers were used in production. They also said they didn't find the firmware on the server as shipped from Supermicro, it was dow
by IBM 8y ago
What they denied was that the servers were used in production. They also said they didn't find the firmware on the server as shipped from Supermicro, it was downloaded from their website [1].
>Update: A source familiar with the case at Apple told Ars that the compromised firmware affected servers in Apple's design lab, and not active Siri servers. The firmware, according to the source, was downloaded directly from Supermicro's support site—and that firmware is still hosted there.
Apple issued the following official comment:
Apple is deeply committed to protecting the privacy and security of our customers and the data we store. We are constantly monitoring for any attacks on our systems, working closely with vendors and regularly checking equipment for malware. We’re not aware of any data being transmitted to an unauthorized party nor was any infected firmware found on the servers purchased from this vendor.
>I also find it very interesting that the FBI, the one organization at the center of this saga who is allegedly investigating the spy chip, has remained completely silent, neither confirming nor denying the story.
That's not true. Christopher Wray, in a congressional hearing, said "be careful what you read" in a response to a question about the story [2].
[1] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/02/apple-axed-supermicro-servers-from-datacenters-because-of-bad-firmware-update/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/02/apple...
[2] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/10/10/fbi-director-wray-on-super-micro-servers-be-careful-what-you-read.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/10/10/fbi-director-wray-on-super-m...
- jessaustin 8y agoThat is neither a confirmation nor a denial, although it is obnoxious. Who is this guy, Chairman of the Fed? A simple "I can't comment on ongoing investigations" would have sufficed. Instead, he's warning Congress about their reading habits? It sounds like something JEH would have said...
- dmschulman 8y agoChristopher Wray is the Director of the FBI
- jessaustin 8y agoYes we know. Hence the reference to JEH...
- mrb 8y ago«Christopher Wray, in a congressional hearing, said "be careful what you read"» Like philwelch mentioned, the FBI has a policy of never publicly commenting on ongoing investigations. Wray's statement—extremely vague and neither confirming nor denying the story—thus implies there is an ongoing investigation... Hmm.
- dlgeek 8y agoIt really doesn't and for exactly this reason. If you never comment on ongoing investigations, you also can't ever deny a non-existent investigation, or a lack of denial is confirmation.