5 ms·
At the risk of coming off as some bleeding heart liberal, what's to stop corporations from doing this kind of stuff all the time? What percentage of it goes un
by tombert 8y ago
At the risk of coming off as some bleeding heart liberal, what's to stop corporations from doing this kind of stuff all the time? What percentage of it goes unnoticed?
Everyone knows about lobbying, but until very recently, I didn't know about the whole "astroturfing" thing.
EDIT: Not sure why I'm being downvoted for this... I didn't really intend to make my post partisan, though I realize that the self-deprecating "bleeding-heard-liberal" might appear that way.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoGovernment intervention and citizen activism. That's about it.
- dragonwriter 8y agoBecause regulatory comments aren't a vote or popularity contest, or even subject to much public attention, but are instead, in the normal case, subject to substantive review and response, ballot box stuffing in a way which makes them appear to come from less expert general public commenters doesn't really help the corporation. It only really helps on an issue where the regulatory process has public attention where the substantive outcome is a foregone conclusion but wants additional public political cover. This is quite rare for federal rulemaking. (A milder—in volume terms—version where you try to make substantive comments seem like they are coming from involved parties with a different interest than yours—say, on a healthcare reg, a payer presenting fraudulent provider comments, might be useful, except in that case there is a lot more risk that someone would follow up on the particular comment and turn up something fishy.)
- moorhosj 8y agoI think the recent tax cut is an example of a process with a predetermined outcome where politicians were seeking political cover to make a vote the majority of Americans disagreed with. It’s certainly possible that bots on twitter, Facebook, Instagram and reddit could be employed to amplify a particular message and provide that cover.
- dragonwriter 8y agoOh, sure, there's probably lots of that around political issues outside of the regulatory comment process.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y ago> At the risk of coming off as some bleeding heart liberal, what's to stop corporations from doing this kind of stuff all the time? This doesn't strike as being a conservative vs. liberal issue. Most of us can probably agree that it's an unacceptable attack on the foundations of a representative democracy. And as a social conservative with strong "law and order" leanings, the apparent fraud and identity theft make me very angry. The unwillingness of the federal government to investigate this only adds to my frustration and anger, because it smacks of (at least) passive corruption.
- philipov 8y agoThe hidden assumption that explains the grandparent comment is "conservative == attacker of the foundations of democracy" and being opposed to that makes you a communist or something. It demonstrates just how far the overton window has been shoved by partisan rhetoric.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- austincheney 8y agoUggggghhh, this isn't an attack upon democracy any more than being spammed on Reddit. It isn't corrupting a vote for office or legislation. It is, however, an easily corrupted online comment system that is merely informative and not in any way asserting an outcome or action. If you want to reduce spam and bot participation there needs to be a formal registration process with multifactor authentication of unique identifiers and it must not be anonymous.
- kbenson 8y ago> Uggggghhh, this isn't an attack upon democracy any more than being spammed on Reddit. It isn't corrupting a vote for office or legislation. It is, however, an easily corrupted online comment system that is merely informative and not in any way asserting an outcome or action. Actually, since the FCC proposal specifically called for soliciting public comments to inform the decision, those comments can be seen as influencing the outcome, since lawmakers were expected to read and consider them. It is an attack on Democracy in a very roundabout way (roundabout because this wasn't an election, it was regulatory action put in place by officials that were put in place by elected officials). But in any case, citizens were asked for what they thought in a way that affected an outcome they would have to legally abide, and it appears that their voices where stifled. That actually is a fairly obvious attack on Democracy in general, even if it's only an attack on our Democracy at a distance.
- shmerl 8y agoThis isn't a "liberal" issue. It's about corruption of the government. No one decent should support that.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoCorporations do do it all the time. It's called the PR industry. It used to mean placing positive stories in the trad media. Now it means placing positive stories in the trad media, and also using shills and bots to influence social media. Nation states also do it. Is this story true, or is it manufactured? https://medium.com/dfrlab/trolltracker-twitter-troll-farm-archives-8d5dd61c486b https://medium.com/dfrlab/trolltracker-twitter-troll-farm-ar... Is the Bloomberg chip story true, or is it manufactured - maybe to demonstrate that the US can easily put market pressure on selected Chinese businesses? (I don't actually know the answer to either of those questions. Worldwide, only a handful of people do.) Cognitive violence and zero-trust media have become endemic. This is a problem for any democracy, because you can't have genuine democratic accountability system when mass media of all kinds are weaponised for political ends.
- forapurpose 8y agoI kind of agree with your points, but how do you connect these points about mass media to comments supposedly submitted by private citizens to a government agency?
- dv_dt 8y agoNothing but the participation of citizens. Go read https://www.reddit.com/r/KochWatch https://www.reddit.com/r/KochWatch and https://www.reddit.com/r/Mercerinfo/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Mercerinfo/ Go research how similar write-ins have been done for decades for broadcast decency TV standards.
- emiliobumachar 8y agoHopefully the fear of punishment will keep corporations from repeating this crime. It depends of how this case will go. This was clear-cut fraud, whether the author can be found remains to be seen.
- forapurpose 8y ago> until very recently, I didn't know about the whole "astroturfing" thing You've been on HN since 2015 and you didn't know about astroturfing? You encounter it daily here. This isn't a criticism of you, but I despair a bit. How new is this issue to other commenters?
- rfrey 8y ago>You encounter it daily here. I assume you’re referring to all the commenters with whom you disagree.
- forapurpose 8y agoPlease stop making assumptions about me.
- Operyl 8y agoIt seems like perhaps you shouldn’t make blanket assumptions about the commenters and submitters here either then, because you were pretty harsh in your own comment.
- dang 8y agoMost users who assume they're encountering astroturfing are jumping a mile to that conclusion. It exists, but overwhelmingly these perceptions turn out to be projection–as far as we can tell from evidence. If you think you see it happening, let us know at hn@ycombinator.com so we can investigate. But there's a reason why the site guidelines ask you not to bring this up in the threads: it damages good faith and is nearly always false. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html