3 ms·
> Schools in Europe and Australia are funded by centralized government This has the other problem that in Europe, governments write all the education program t
by ekianjo 8y ago
> Schools in Europe and Australia are funded by centralized government
This has the other problem that in Europe, governments write all the education program to the letter and this leads to complete brainwashing of the kids or silly educational policies (like completely changing how kids learn how to read, which led to about half a generation of kids with very poor reading/orthographic skills in France just to name one disaster), so pick your own poison.
- mschuetz 8y ago> leads to complete brainwashing of the kids Says the one (I presume) from the country that recites the pledge of allegiance in school.
- gknoy 8y agoI find that saying the pledge of allegiance (when I visit my kids' schools for things) is an interesting affair. It's an opportunity to reflect on both the ideal of the Republic, and the ways / extent that the state of the Union has changed over time. I find it poignant that I am pledging allegiance to the Flag and the Republic, rather than to the political party in charge, or to the federal government, etc. Are the differences meaningful? Why? What can I be doing better as a citizen? These are all questions that can run through my mind when saying the pledge with mindfulness. You're right, there's probably an element of brainwashing there. However, one can also use it as an opportunity to meditate on civic duty. :)
- Arnt 8y agoThis is HN not facebook. People here are used to reading metrics, so you can elaborate. Show numbers instead of saying "very poor". Link to graphs.
- yorwba 8y agoThey're probably referring to alternative teaching methods like "reading by writing". AFAIK, that method was developed to encourage students to practice more by putting more emphasis on writing and to prevent demotivating feedback by not correcting mistakes. There has been a bit of a splash in Germany recently when a study found very strong negative effects compared to the traditional method and several regional governments decided to ban schools from using those methods. (So it's not about centralized education forcing silly policies onto schools but the other way around.) I'm having trouble finding quality sources in English, but the German conference poster [1] has graphs and you asked for graphs. The line plot shows a longitudinal study and the box plot is of a cross-section with higher sample size, where the horizontal axis represents time in steps of half a school year. The vertical axis shows a measure of writing ability normalized to units of standard deviations from the mean. red = traditional method using a primer green = reading by writing blue = "reading workshop", another method were kids are supposed to decide for themselves what to learn next The longitudinal study (line plot) also controlled for pre-existing knowledge at the beginning of the study. Students enrolled in schools using the "reading by writing" method had significantly better initial conditions, but students using the traditional method showed much greater improvements. In the cross-section, the traditional method had consistently both higher means and lower variances. Conclusion: the two alternative methods "cannot be recommended unconditionally". [1] https://www.psychologie.uni-bonn.de/de/abteilungen/entwicklungs-und-paedagogische-psychologie/mitarbeiterinnen-und-mitarbeiter/m.sc.-tobias-kuhl-1/poster-buko-rechtschreiberfolg-nach-unterschiedlichen-didaktiken-21.09.2018 https://www.psychologie.uni-bonn.de/de/abteilungen/entwicklu...
- Brockenstein 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Math https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Math No matter where you are, sometimes we want to try something new, sometimes things have to change, and sometimes it doesn't work or there are growing pains. The other side of the coin is that states and local governments aren't that much better equipped to set education standards. That's how you get things like trying to teach bronze age mythologies as science and a bunch of feel good proclamations about how "we know how best to teach our kids and that's why we should be running the show". No system is perfect, but having some centralized standards gives you something to shoot for and gives people from other regions the ability to have some expectations about what students (should) have learned.