4 ms·
FTC hearings on tech companies included economists who take money from them
- gjsman-1000 8y agoMy fear is that if a breakup occurred, it would only allow Chinese tech companies to come marching in, destroying American competition. (This could backfire pretty bad...)
- golemotron 8y agoNot with some protectionist regulation in place.
- maxxxxx 8y agoFor a long time I have been told that small nimble companies will succeed so it seems healthy to me to break up these big, slow companies. I wonder if there is some level of Stockholm syndrome going on that makes people think we need these huge, dominant companies.
- rayiner 8y agoOr alternatively, maybe it's true that there are major economies of scale to most businesses, and big companies get big not through "lobbying" and "regulation" but because they're far more efficient than small companies?
- magicnubs 8y agoOr at least, having one big company serving 100 people can be more efficient than 10 smaller companies delivering 10 people each a similar service.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIs this really more efficient for society and innovation in the long run? It just cements the status quo.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThis makes sense, but ask yourself why a search engine company and a phone software developer should be part of one big company. Vertical integration has almost no justifiable reason to be protected, it's primary purpose is for locking you into an ecosystem, which gates out new, innovative players.
- maxxxxx 8y agoYes, they are efficient and well run but they also can suppress threatening innovation. At some point big companies can buy out any potential competition. You can see that in tech where a lot of startups don't even try to run a profitable business but plan on getting bought out. Same in medical tech where startups just do basic research that's sold to the big guys.
- pfisch 8y agoYes, as long as it is one step in the breakup of lots of other monopolies/conglomerates and not just politically motivated targeting.
- PunchTornado 8y agoWhy would you want to break them? A guy builds a company and then for some reason somebody who never helped build it thinks it's ok to break it into little parts? sounds communistic to me... let the free market decide and if needed, then regulate it more.
- will_brown 8y ago>let the free market decide and if needed, then regulate it more. That is exactly what happened over a 100 years ago. That additional regulation was called the Sherman Anti-Trust Act of 1890. When the US DOJ broke up Standard Oil, who had control of 90% of the market just like a certain search engine does today, consumers and the market were better off...and even Rockefeller who lost his illegal monopoly, saw his fortune double as a result of the breakup making him the richest man in the world.
- Kaveren 8y agoI'm tired of the big tech alarmism. Nobody needs to break up any of these companies. Having power does not make a company evil. You can ask legitimate questions about Amazon's treatment of employees. Boycott them if you're so inclined. Are they being paid fairly? Are they being exploited and over-worked? I think it's a conversation worth having. At least be sensible and call for regulations that address this in particular, not trying to break up Amazon entirely. Google is guilty of what, exactly? Do you dislike how they treat you, the user, as the product? Change your Google privacy settings or better yet switch to Google alternatives (Protonmail, DuckDuckGo, Microsoft Office, OpenOffice, the like, YouTube is too useful to abandon). All I see is a big push to vilify tech companies so politicians can look like they're for the little guy. Take the recent Google internal vulnerability case. All of the sudden politicians come out of the woodwork, when public disclosure of this sort of thing was never an issue before. In reality, people doesn't seem to understand that enforced disclosure of internally discovered vulnerabilities will make more proactive actors look less secure than companies which aren't as rigorous (and have less to disclose). If you very understandably don't trust Facebook with your data, simply get off it. Use Signal, SMS, email, Discord, Slack, anything else you want to talk to your friends and family. I suppose telling people not to use Facebook, Instagram, or Google services doesn't have the same ring to it as tearing companies down though. Edit: Changed nonsensical sentence about Google's vulnerability disclosure. Clarified. Edit: Reclarified still nonsensical Google vulnerability disclosure paragraph. Edit: Changed "more" to "less" in the disclosure paragraph. Third time's the charm.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoCorporate power is very different from personal power. The layers of management and decision making in a corporation don't often admit to any moral dimension - just success/fail measurements and next quarter profits. So yes, a corporation may not be evil, but it is almost by construction, amoral. Which may be worse in a sense.
- dragonwriter 8y agoConstruction of success/fail measures has a moral dimension. If a corporation only had profits as a deciding goal, that isn't something that comes from outer space independent of morality, it's a consequence of moral value judgments, particularly of it's stockholders (but board members and executives have a role, too.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kareemsabri 8y agoWhat a shit article. Yeah, if you go to the level of economists who work at elite universities and firms, and are the type to testify before government bodies, most of them are one degree of separation from the world's biggest corporations. So what? Either what they're saying is evidence-based and defensible, or it isn't. The article seems to want to smear these people on the basis of their links, no matter how tenuous, to big tech corporations. It's amazing watching [a subset of] the American public clamor for the destruction of incredible things that could only be created in America, and should really be sources of pride, imho.
- ocdtrekkie 8y ago"It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it." -Upton Sinclair The issue is that nearly every single one of these people are paid to believe big tech is not a problem. This isn't even a scenario where there were competing viewpoints: The deck was entirely stacked with paid supporters. And as far as the fact that these companies were created in the first place: Today's giants only exist because we properly employed antitrust regulations against the previous generation of giants. Google would not exist without the antitrust case against Microsoft. And an innovative future depends on us applying antitrust law again, to the likes of Google, Facebook, and Amazon. We should be proud of what our country has accomplished, but we must break them up on occasion to allow for new growth. Movement and innovation is what keeps us on that leading edge, and resistance to apply regulation against these companies will allow other countries to surpass us.
- kareemsabri 8y agoThat's a much stronger claim than "they, or their firms/universities, have consulted for big tech".
- kareemsabri 8y agoYou edited to include additional claims, and some counterfactuals. I see no reason to believe that the anti-trust rulings against Microsoft, which were actually rather weak when all was said and done, is what allowed Google to come into existence. I don't see how they had any effect on Google, or how Google was stymied by Microsoft's monopoly. Can you substantiate that claim? Likewise, you have to prove that these companies are destroying the ability for other folks to innovate through abuse of monopoly power (the point of the hearings), not just say that they're big so we need to "break them up".
- lolyallturfin 8y agoNext week: Hacker News thread about investigated companies included commenters who take money from them (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18257185 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18257185)
- SilasX 8y agoSo? Of course you should be able to pay experts to represent you in these hearings, or hire them for unrelated purposes. The issue is whether such payments are appropriately disclosed.