3 ms·
This sounds like a good way to redistribute funds, but at the cost of lowering total revenue. If taxes are raised to make up for the often hometown-branded but
by pessimizer 8y ago
This sounds like a good way to redistribute funds, but at the cost of lowering total revenue. If taxes are raised to make up for the often hometown-branded but often highly liquid gifts, it will be fine, but 1) I imagine raising taxes is going to be highly sticky, and 2) it's a flat, regressive tax, making it either forced gift-buying for people who probably shouldn't be buying themselves gifts or a government subsidy for the voucher-brokers.
If you're a Japanese politician, you should probably invest heavily in voucher-brokers, then lobby for a rise in the tax.
- gowld 8y agoI'd expect that the end-state would be that tax rates go up to maintain desired revenue levels, the localities all bid up to the max amount of refund, and the whole system works not quite as well as the day before the system was invented -- except that a bunch of works gets expended on the useless competition for funds, and the money distribution gets unfairly balanced based on whichever locality has more clever marketing. This is exactly counter to the concept government -- a system that should be run as a monopoly ends up being full of waste due to competition with no net improvement.
- pessimizer 8y ago> the money distribution gets unfairly balanced based on whichever locality has more clever marketing. You might be able to mostly solve this by automatically registering people to a default hometown, and making it very annoying to change your registration. That latter part might be doable by simply allowing the municipalities to administrate their own hometown lists, so you'd have to contact your current hometown to transfer your registration to a your new hometown. They'd be economically motivated to make it as difficult as canceling a gym membership.
- csours 8y agoLiquid gifts you say? Well it just so happens my 'hometown' is Loretto, Kentucky. https://www.google.com/maps/dir//Maker's+Mark+Distillery,+3350+Burks+Spring+Rd,+Loretto,+KY+40037/ https://www.google.com/maps/dir//Maker's+Mark+Distillery,+33...