You just named my two favourite scotches. Strangely enough, I've also identified Macallan and Glenlivet as two scotches that are less pleasant than they "shoul

You just named my two favourite scotches. Strangely enough, I've also identified Macallan and Glenlivet as two scotches that are less pleasant than they "should" be, given their price. This must be characteristic of having an Islay gene. Talisker is also high up on my list.