I wouldn't. My response was totally about a better way of doing it, otherwise I would have mocked this up and published it. My own opinion is that the lack of

I wouldn't. My response was totally about a better way of doing it, otherwise I would have mocked this up and published it. My own opinion is that the lack of consistency in registration and signup forms across the web is a real problem for regular users, and we do not need another yet more confusing option. I picked this up from watching regular people attempt to signup/signin to web services. The web could use a standard style guide published by some sort of group. ie. this is what a reg form should look like, this is where a login box should be etc. It is a stretch to think it would work, but it would help regular users a lot (I am not talking about all forms having the same design, talking about standard field names and positions, standard features (eg. double prompt for password, show strength, password reset, no password in clear, email as username etc, always have a logout button in top-right, etc.). There have been no real breakthroughs in design wrt the signup/signin/logout process online. HTTP auth didn't catch on, and that was the last chance we had at standardizing it.