3 ms·
People ridicule the nonlocality of Pilot Wave theory. But I’d rather question locality than embrace Everett’s many-worlds theory. If you need to postulate such
by EGreg 8y ago
People ridicule the nonlocality of Pilot Wave theory. But I’d rather question locality than embrace Everett’s many-worlds theory. If you need to postulate such amazing complexity just to say basically nothing in terms of realism, then you’ve already lost.
Meanwhile as one good physics professor pointed out, none of these alternatives to PWT even rule out nonlocality. So why not just assume it and be done with the weirdness?
- ZhuanXia 8y ago> If you need to postulate such amazing complexity just to say basically nothing in terms of realism, then you’ve already lost. What about many worlds is complex? The Schrodinger equation predicts macroscopic decoherence. Macroscopic decoherence implies many worlds. Many worlds can hardly be called an interpretation. Rather, it is a prediction. It is just taking the Schrodinger equation literally. Every other "interpretation" is more complex, as they bolt things onto the Schrodinger equation, and often very ugly things, too.
- kgwgk 8y agoMacroscopic decoherence is about the interaction of a quantum system with its environment, resulting in a mixture state for the subsystem of interest. But if you describe the whole universe as a quantum system there is no environment, no decoherence, no many worlds, the universe will remain in a pure state if it was originally in a pure state.
- JProthero 8y ago>If you need to postulate such amazing complexity just to say basically nothing in terms of realism, then you’ve already lost. Defenders of the Many-Worlds Interpretation, and some other types of multiverse theory such as Eternal Inflation, would actually say that the multiverse idea is the simpler alternative, not the more complex one. Multiverse theories produce an abundance of universes, but the underlying description of those universes is typically simpler than alternatives that suppose a single, unique universe. Concepts such as wave function collapse or hidden variables, which actually add complexity to the theory, have to be introduced in order to get the theory to produce a unique observed reality. One could have argued with Aristarchus or Hubble that the idea that there were other solar systems, or other galaxies, added more complexity than was necessary to explain reality. From a broader perspective though, our reality would actually be stranger and more difficult to explain if the properties we observed of our solar system, or our galaxy, were the only ones that could exist. Ditto our universe, say the Everettians. Kepler desperately struggled to explain the properties of our solar system as the product of a unique and divine geometry before he discovered the more general truth [1], which allowed the existence of the infinity of alternative configurations which are now known to exist around other stars. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mysterium_Cosmographicum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mysterium_Cosmographicum
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoThis is only true if you ignore the fact that there's no explanation, in detail, of how quantum splitting generates an entire universe - never mind why it happens for observed events only, and not for unobserved quantum events. (Is that how it works, or not?) The photon bounced off a beam splitter - did that generate a new universe? How about if the photon moved one Planck distance through spacetime? The photon hit a detector? Okay - a universe. Yes? Or do you only get a new universe when the result is observed? By someone who's awake? And not on drugs, so they might be hallucinating? The argument seems to be based on "Obviously it just does, because how else do you explain this weird math, QED, isn't our explanation great?" - which I personally don't find very convincing.
- gotocake 8y agoThe evidence against Pilot Waves keeps stacking up. https://www.quantamagazine.org/famous-experiment-dooms-pilot-wave-alternative-to-quantum-weirdness-20181011/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/famous-experiment-dooms-pilot...
- twtw 8y agoThe experiments described in that article have zero impact on Bohm's pilot wave theory, which is the only current pilot wave theory that is actually workable.
- n4r9 8y agoThat experiment really has nothing to do with actual pilot wave theories. It just rules out a fluid-mechanical analogue of quantum mechanics (which anyone could predict anyway since fluid mechanics isn't non-local in the same way).