19 ms·
New law lets you defer capital gains taxes by investing in opportunity zones
- TACIXAT 8y agoAlright, a house I own (and am currently failing to sell) is in an opportunity zone. Hypothetically, is there a way I could benefit from this?
- sokoloff 8y agoRent it out while you wait for the area to improve. Or hold it and wait. Or, if local zoning doesn't block it, see if you can rent it out as commercial.
- ethagknight 8y agoYou have to make a 100% investment above your acquisition cost, so you probably cannot benefit unless you can sell it to an housing investor who could do that.
- adamhooper 8y agoThe benefit is for investing capital gains into OZ's, not necessarily from selling assets that are in existing OZ's. So if you had a gain on your house (beyond the homeowner exclusion) you could potentially invest the remainder of that gain into an OZ project and get those benefits. There are all sorts of stipulations you need to follow to qualify however - not all of which are fully in place yet from Treasury. We should be getting the first version of the regs as soon as tomorrow (imminent we've heard from folks in DC) and then we'll know more. Things like having to improve the basis of whatever you invest in by 100% within a 30 month period exist, so you can't just buy something in an OZ and park it, you have to actually do some improvement to what you purchase.
- fourcolordeck 8y agoNot really, your own personal residence is exempt for capital gains (250k single, 500k married).
- dev_dull 8y ago> write off on their taxes. Thankfully the poster got it right but the headline from the article itself is very misleading. Deferring taxes != writing off investments. Also, why does the headline writer take shots at billionaires for putting money to work in economically challenged areas? I swear some of these people will never be satisfied with the way rich spend their money.
- jjeaff 8y agoIt looks like there is an opportunity to reduce the taxes owned on the initial capital gain as well as avoid all taxes on the additional capital gain if held long enough.
- Thriptic 8y agoAgreed, it's very silly. No one attacks people in the upper middle class for using mortgage deductions, tax advantaged investment vehicles (ie 401Ks), education accounts, tax loss harvesting etc to minimize tax burden; however, whenever a wealthy person tries to minimize their tax burden, they are immediately judged. It is not reasonable to state that one group of people can take advantage of tax code incentives and other groups cannnot.
- ip26 8y agoMiddle class folks who are using the mortgage deduction generally use it exactly as intended. They don't have an army of accountants on retainer to figure out how to game the tax code and accomplish things that weren't really intended. The example that always sticks in my head- maybe this isn't true, but I've heard there are strategies of buying failing companies for pennies, shuttering them, and then writing off their losses on your own taxes. You incurred no risk, you lost no money, and now you pay no taxes. Whether it's actually intended to happen that way, it doesn't seem right, and ordinary people can't do it. Anyway, I'm not an accountant, but the upset over the tax exploits of the wealthy revolve around the concern that they are managing to exercise the tax code in a way that was never intended to pay less than they were meant to owe. Middle class folks don't wind up in the crosshairs because they generally file very ordinary returns, following both the letter as well as the spirit.
- drb91 8y agoYes, let’s gentrify faster.
- crwalker 8y agoIf you think gentrification is bad, you should see the alternatives. They are real. https://goo.gl/maps/veQSXmD7Z5G2 https://goo.gl/maps/veQSXmD7Z5G2
- drb91 8y agoDepends on your definiton of bad, I suppose. Care to state what you think is bad? You linked to google maps, from which I can draw a million conclusions, none of them worth devoting effort to responding to without clarification.
- baddox 8y agoIf I had to guess, probably the dilapidated homes and streets covered in trash.
- sokoloff 8y agoDo you think the burned out, half-missing roof house adds beneficial je ne sais quoi to the neighborhood? Which of those houses would you like to have a next-door neighbor? Which of those houses would have the greatest positive effect on your willingness to move there, raise a family there, and invest there?
- anigbrowl 8y agoSome places were overbuilt, and it would probably be better to tear down the remaining structures, clean it up and designate the block as a park. The wrong approach to development can make things substantially worse for people who live in marginal neighborhoods.
- drb91 8y agoI base where I live on things other than aesthetics and money, like the people.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoI believe the way that the program works is you can defer taxes from your original capital gains (and the cost basis gets increased so your deferred taxes are less than you would pay otherwise), reinvest them in an "opportunity zone", and not pay capital gains on your investment on the opportunity zone, if you hold it long enough e.g. Bob bought Apple stock for $50 a share back in the day, and sells it for $200/share. He defers his taxes until 2026. Instead of paying capital gains tax on $150/share, the cost basis is adjusted by 15% so in addition to benefiting from the time value of money, future Bob will only be taxed on $142.50 of capital gains. Bob can buy a house in an "opportunity zone" (from scrolling around the embedded map, there's plenty of million dollar+ houses in these areas. There's also lots of sports teams and stadiums in these areas, so maybe Bob buys an NFL team or a parking lot next to their stadium), rent it out for 10 years, sell it, and not have to pay any capital gains tax on the appreciation. Definitely not a bad deal for him!
- ethagknight 8y agoYes its more akin to a 1031 exchange, but opened up so that non-real estate capital gains are eligible.
- bcheung 8y agoIs it just capital gains? Wondering if it applies to any other forms of active or passive income. How are profits from these investments treated? Can you "swap til you drop" like with a 1031 exchange?
- westurner 8y ago> Is it just capital gains? Wondering if it applies to any other forms of active or passive income. I would also like some information about this. +1 for investing in distressed areas; self-nominated with intent or otherwise. If it's capital gains only, -1 on requiring sale of capital assets in order to be sufficiently incentivized. (Because then the opportunity to tax-advantagedly invest in Opportunity Zones is denied to persons without assets to liquidate; i.e. unequal opportunity).
- anigbrowl 8y agoUsing the map in the article I was intrigued to discover that my home isn't in an 'opportunity zone' but if it were located 30 feet to the right it would be. That may explain why my neighborhood has been infested with signage for cash-up-front house sales (which I have been systematically removing).
- adamhooper 8y agoWhat irks me about this article is its sole narrative on billionaires helping billionaires. Nowhere in the regs does it say that somebody with a $100 gain couldn't invest that into a project. Granted there are other regulatory issues that will limit a lot of this activity to accredited investors (via Reg D private placements), but OZ regs have nothing to do with a persons net worth or income. As other posters have commented, the benefits are three fold - deferring your gain until the end of 2026, a 10% step up in basis on the gain if you hold for 5 years, an additional 5% step up if you hold for a full 7 years, and an exemption on tax for the appreciation of the assets you've invested in if you hold them for 10 years. Here's a link to an ebook we just put out if anybody has interest in reading how it will work in the real estate space - https://www.realcrowd.com/blog/2018/10/the-real-estate-investors-guide-to-opportunity-zones https://www.realcrowd.com/blog/2018/10/the-real-estate-inves...
- tanderson92 8y ago"Poor people are just as free to avoid taxes on their long-term investments in illiquid capital-intensive projects as millionaires and billionaires" is not a take I expected to see, but thank you HN for proving me wrong.
- dwiel 8y agoNot only that, but this poor person has to use capital gains for this ...
- tanderson92 8y agoFilling out and finding ways to minimize taxes due to 1040 Schedule Ds, that regular feature of tax season that people making $50k/yr or less know and love.
- manigandham 8y agoDoes nobody gain at all from the investments in an opportunity zone? Are those benefits just ignored?
- dawhizkid 8y agoWho decides what is an OZ or not? I honestly would be surprised if the person(s) who gets to decide what is or isn't an OZ now and in the future hasn't already been bribed by an interested investor.
- heurist 8y agoState governors selected the zones over the last year.
- com2kid 8y agoI am wondering why Pioneer Square, one of the hottest locations in Seattle, has been classified as an OZ. Aside from the crippling poverty outside the doorsteps of all the tech company offices that is. ...
- btgeekboy 8y agoPioneer Square is not a hot location; all of the tech action is happening to the north in SLU and a bit into the downtown retail core. Pioneer Square is a dump and sketchy as hell.
- com2kid 8y agoThere are a ton of tech companies in Pioneer Square. Geekwire has this 5 year out of date map, https://www.geekwire.com/2013/pioneer-square-tech-map-techies-hanging-shingles/ https://www.geekwire.com/2013/pioneer-square-tech-map-techie... but just walking through there, Pioneer Square is tech city during the day. From trendy bars to expensive boutique clothing stores. Other startups, such as Real Self, have come into being since that (ancient) list was made. There are multiple co-working spaces within blocks of each other, The Pioneer Collective, Galvanize, Impact Hub, and at least 2 accelerators that I know of are based near Pioneer Square.
- sytelus 8y agoTLDR; The Opportunity Zone program is designed to provide tax incentives to investors who fund businesses in underserved communities. Investors are able to defer paying taxes on capital gains that are invested in Qualified Opportunity Funds that in turn are invested in distressed communities designated as Opportunity Zones by the governor of each state. Up to 25 percent of the low-income census tracts in each state can be designated as Opportunity Zones.
- Bjartr 8y agoCensus tracts? The ones that are almost nine years out of date or the up to date ones will have in a couple of years?
- sprashanth 8y agoA good chunk of Olympic National Park seems to be an opportunity zone. Can anyone fill me in on what an 'investment' there might entail? IIRC, commercial activities are usually heavily restricted in national parks.
- ur-whale 8y agoDoesn't look like the park itself is an OZ. OTOH, the OZ west of the park seems to be reservation land, which likely brings its own set of problems when it comes to investing. [edit] source: https://www.policymap.com/maps?i=9964345&btd=6&period=2018&lind=111&cx=-97.75981946970943&cy=38.21448287372515&cz=3&slc=J8my6tS https://www.policymap.com/maps?i=9964345&btd=6&period=2018&l...
- bobthepanda 8y agoThe devil is in the details. What's the definition of an "opportunity zone", for instance? We already have a similar program for EB-5 visas; the definition of economically challenged area is often an up-and-coming area gerrymandered to include just enough poor people. Source with rather clickbaity introduction: https://www.citylab.com/equity/2017/05/kushner-companies-real-estate-and-eb-5-cash-for-visas-reform/525792/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2017/05/kushner-companies-rea...
- adamhooper 8y agoHere's a map showing all the OZ's: https://www.policymap.com/maps?i=9964345&btd=6&period=2018&lind=111&cx=-97.75981946970943&cy=38.21448287372515&cz=3&slc=J8my6tS https://www.policymap.com/maps?i=9964345&btd=6&period=2018&l... Anything purple on there is designated an OZ.
- bobthepanda 8y agoLooking at New York, I see the area around the Navy Yard, Long Island City, Bushwick, Astoria, and Flushing - all areas that are already undergoing huge amounts of real estate development and are hardly "struggling." I'm worried that this has good intentions but will have unintended effects; it's entirely possible that turning on a fire hose of money would just wash the existing residents away. While on paper that would improve the income level and whatnot of a census tract, you really just shuffled people around the metro area, most likely to a place with worse access to jobs and stores and whatnot. It's important that we increase housing at a macro level, but we also don't want to strand people by suburbanizing poverty.
- heurist 8y agoOpportunity zones are state-selected census tracts. I am more curious about the required "opportunity fund". I have not seen a good definition for that yet.
- seniorsassycat 8y ago> Q. What is a Qualified Opportunity Fund A. Qualified Opportunity Fund is an investment vehicle that is set up as either a partnership or corporation for investing in eligible property that is located in an Opportunity Zone and that utilizes the investor’s gains from a prior investment for funding the Opportunity Fund. > Q. How does a taxpayer become certified as a Qualified Opportunity Fund? A. To become a Qualified Opportunity Fund, an eligible taxpayer self certifies. (Thus, no approval or action by the IRS is required.) To self-certify, a taxpayer merely completes a form (which will be released in the summer of 2018) and attaches that form to the taxpayer’s federal income tax return for the taxable year. (The return must be filed timely, taking extensions into account.) > The fund must hold at least 90 percent of its assets in Qualified Opportunity Zone Property https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/opportunity-zones-frequently-asked-questions https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/opportunity-zones-frequently-as...
- 0003 8y agoAlso see the code here: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/subtitle-A/chapter-1/subchapter-Z https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/subtitle-A/chapte...
- fallingfrog 8y agoYou know, we should just drop the other shoe and reduce all taxes on rich people to zero. It's what they pay anyway. It would save us the money of pretending to tax them.
- manigandham 8y agoThey definitely don't pay 0. They actually pay a significant portion of all taxes collected. You won't pay as much in your entire lifetime as the annual bills for some of these people. I find it strange to see such animosity against "the rich" on an forum dedicated to startups from a company that has helped created billions in market cap and mint several new billionaires in the process.
- omegaworks 8y ago>I find it strange to see such animosity against "the rich" on an forum dedicated to startups from a company that has helped created billions in market cap and mint several new billionaires in the process. There is a huge difference between someone becoming so wealthy that they and the next 5 generations of their heirs don't need to do any real work for the rest of their lives, and someone figuring out a way to create a sustainable organization that provides real value to lots of people. It is more than reasonable to want to encourage society to favor the latter over the former.
- manigandham 8y agoHow do you think people become wealthy in the first place? It's almost always connected to providing value to lots of people. These ranks change all the time as wealth is created and lost. Very few stay rich through generations, but even then it's always invested in something, like businesses that benefit others. These same wealthy people are the LPs that fund the VCs that fund the SV startups. It's a cycle.
- omegaworks 8y ago> It's almost always connected to providing value to lots of people. Actually, accumulated wealth to that extent is almost always connected to anti-competitive practices and monopolizing a space to such an extent that people have no other choice then to do business with you.
- jpatokal 8y agoLooks like a big chunk of Menlo Park/Palo Alto is a designated OZ: https://www.policymap.com/maps?i=9964345&btd=6&period=2018&lind=111&cx=-97.75981946970943&cy=38.21448287372515&cz=3&slc=J8my6tS https://www.policymap.com/maps?i=9964345&btd=6&period=2018&l... Including heartbreaking scenes of crushing poverty like this: https://www.google.com.au/maps/place/DLA+Piper/@37.4595117,-122.1425751,3a,75y,90.23h,89.59t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1suXbTZ64lWTsToKwvU8D8QA!2e0!7i13312!8i6656!4m5!3m4!1s0x808fbb6dd7463e47:0x877cdb5583601213!8m2!3d37.4595462!4d-122.1425615 https://www.google.com.au/maps/place/DLA+Piper/@37.4595117,-...
- Ninjak 8y agoThat's the slice of EPA west of the freeway. Yes, the Four Seasons is there, but it's legitimately an impoverished area compared to surroundings. Compare the run-down apartments on Woodland against the neighborhood in PA across the creek. Seems like a legitimate OZ.
- asah 8y agoCan confirm
- fosco 8y agoI am I understanding this correctly... it sound like this was successfully exploited by businesses and poor cannot take advantage of the benefits? if accurate I think this is a problem with many of the incentives that are provided, maybe providing the tax incentive would be better directed towards saying to take advantage of this opportunity you must provide something that the public can use?
- rdlecler1 8y agoSo what happens if you make a monitory investment in a startup in an Opportunity Zone that then moves? This may not be in your control.
- NTDF9 8y agoMeanwhile the annual deficit is greater than $1T, for which the government will cut services for the average person (except Military of course). What a ponzi country!!
- talltimtom 8y agoSo in the midst of an investment boom we are engineering ways not only to reduce tax on gains, but to ensure the gains will be reinvested. Yet at the same time this provides no value if people pull out their investments in a down-market. Sounds like A bubble-policy.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoWell if they pull out there will be some commercial / residential property assets going cheap. That's why investing via closed end property funds is much better individual properties are very illiquid .
- perpetualcrayon 8y agoMy worry. As was mentioned in the article these billionaires have teams of lawyers / accountants working to ensure the money stays in their hands. What's keeping them from having those teams of lawyers concocting vapor-corps in these opportunity zones (or whatever the loophole is) which will make little to no positive (and maybe negative) impact on the opportunity zone while ensuring the billionaires keep the incentives regardless. EDIT: Or worse yet there will be organizations whose sole purpose is to take in billionaires money, do as little work as possible, and generate enough paperwork to ensure the billionaires qualify for the tax incentives.
- deytempo 8y agoI think you are referring to non profit organizations
- perpetualcrayon 8y agoDoes anyone else think it's categorically wrong for a government to incentivize greed?
- koboll 8y ago"Incentivizing greed" is literally how capitalism works. Or rather, it's knowing that greed will exist regardless, and then incentivizing the channeling of that greed toward better outcomes for society.
- beagle3 8y agoIsrael had (maybe still has?) what was called “angel taxing” which said investment in a startup (for some definition of startup) is optionally marked to zero at the point of investment, which means that if you had any gains, you could net them against this investment. This is the opposite of deferring capital gain taxes - it is pulling capital losses forward. If the startup folds, the marking down is justified. If it is successful, the capital gains when eventually selling it reflect the zero base; so overall, taxes stay the same except it incentivizes capital investments immediately after capital gains.
- duxup 8y agoI'm skeptical as we've seen with folks like the Kushners plenty of folks will build some fancy high end / highly profitable development "near" places that could use some improvement.... but they don't really help anyone in those zones.
- noetic_techy 8y agoProbably massive amount of money to be made by a company that can systematize this whole process. They know the laws and the codes, they know what gets returns in some areas and not others. I predict cookie cutter improvements being dropped into these zones at some point as everyone figures out where works and what doesn't. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
- ams6110 8y agoThat's certainly possible, and unintended consequences are always a risk when trying to manipulate behavior via the tax code.
- jsoc815 8y agoI don't think that such results qualify as unintended consequences. I somehow ended up attending a meeting at Treasury on some existing tax credit program. Other than me, everyone attending seemed to be some sort of insider and nearly everyone seemed to know each other. So, to my way of thinking, an unintended consequence would be some no-name schmuck being the one to systematize and beat the known quantities at the game. (IMHO)
- noahl 8y agoAnd this would be ... a spectacularly good outcome. In order to do this, the company would have to develop a workable, repeatable model of how to economically improve an "opportunity zone". There's some evidence that this is a very hard problem, notably that social service agencies have been trying to do it for more than 100 years. But sure, if a company can find a solution, that would be great. The danger is that the company would find a solution that somehow followed the letter of the law but not the spirit, like finding an investment with nominally high returns that doesn't actually improve the lives of the people living in the opportunity zones. That's definitely a danger, and possibly a likely outcome. But another possibility is that there are fairly straightforward ways to improve the lives of people in these zones that haven't happened because the people in them don't have the capital to do it. If that's the case, then incentivizing outsiders to put in that capital should be a good thing. I don't know what will happen, but it seems like it's worth a try. It would be nice if the program was well managed, because good management could probably reduce and mitigate the negative gaming-the-system outcomes and promote the good ones. But I don't have a lot of confidence in Congress to do a good job with updates, so I hope the original bill was written well enough.
- lr 8y agoIf someone were to directly buy a distressed property in one of these zones using money from capital gains, and fix it up (and even live there for 5-10 years), would they realize the same tax benefit as investing in a "fund"?
- hyprlogik 8y agoThis article is great at defining off the bat what the heck an opportunity zone is. /s
- anon49124 8y agoSilicon Valley Community Foundation (SVCF) lets donors realize tax benefits now and transfer funds promised later. It has an endowment of around $14 Billion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicon_Valley_Community_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicon_Valley_Community_Found...