4 ms·
Not _only_ about trust. One of the things DoH gets you for free is that it means that your ISP doesn't get to touch DNS requests, which was not true previously.
by tialaramex 8y ago
Not _only_ about trust. One of the things DoH gets you for free is that it means that your ISP doesn't get to touch DNS requests, which was not true previously. You can get Internet service from whatever bunch of money-grabbing assholes are available where you live, and get DNS from somebody else without that being tampered with since it's encrypted on the wire. You do still have to trust the DoH provider (outside of DNSSEC).
In the UK for example, the current government proposals for yet more Internet censorship assume that they can "just" order ISPs to censor DNS. This, their white paper says, is relatively cheap and so ISPs might even be willing to do it at no extra cost, which is convenient for a supposedly "small government / low tax" party that keeps thinking of expensive ways to enact their socially regressive agenda...
But DoH and indeed all the other D-PRIVE proposals kill that, to censor users with D-PRIVE you're going to have to operate a bunch of IP layer stuff, maybe even try to do deep packet inspection, which TLS 1.3 already made problematic and eSNI skewers thoroughly.
So there's a good chance this sort of thing for _ordinary_ users (the white paper already acknowledges that yes, people can install Tor and it can't do anything about that) makes government censorship so difficult and thus expensive as to be economically unpalatable. "Won't somebody think of the children" tastes much better when it doesn't come with a 5% tax increase to pay for it...
- xg15 8y agoConventiently, the same will also apply to me trying to block apps from talking over the network with things they should not talk to.
- Ajedi32 8y agoYou could always point your DNS at your own DNS-over-HTTPS server, then configure that server to forward requests over an encrypted connection to another DNS-over-HTTPS server. Don't know if there are any tools available right now that will do that for you, but there's no technical reason why it isn't possible.
- xg15 8y agoI think the problem will be apps with a DoH service hardwired. There wouldn't be anything for me to point anywhere short of patching the app. Yes, apps could theoretically already do this today if the developers are willing to run their own endpoints. However, my guess is this will become vastly easier to do when there are already public DoH endpoints available to connect to.