4 ms·
> And, crucially, he did them to preserve the Constitutional order, not to overthrow it. Quite the opposite really. Many of the things FDR did were highly popu
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> And, crucially, he did them to preserve the Constitutional order, not to overthrow it.
Quite the opposite really. Many of the things FDR did were highly populist and there was no existing constitutional framework allowing the federal government to do them. Then when the courts started striking down his legislation, he threatened to pack the court if they didn't start bending to his will.
But that meant there was no constitutional framework. There was no reasoned debate over the expansion of government power, nor constitutional amendment setting out its limits, only a threat by the executive to dismantle the court as a check on his power if they didn't get out the rubber stamp.
> A good analogue to FDR's unique situation is Abraham Lincoln
It is a good analog, but Lincoln is subject to many of the same criticisms. If the Confederacy had won the war, he would have gone down as the President who dissolved the Union.
He's a legend because he won and the winner writes the history books, but that's no proof that the extreme measures were actually necessary. A President who resolved the conflict through diplomacy rather than bloodshed would have gone down as a footnote in history. You get a lot more credit for winning a war than preventing one, whether you should or not.