2 ms·
Secure delete is not reliable with modern filesystems. Just use full-disk encryption -- it's free.
by jrockway 16y ago
Secure delete is not reliable with modern filesystems. Just use full-disk encryption -- it's free.
- chbarts 16y ago> Just use full-disk encryption -- it's free. People can make bizarre assumptions without realizing it. This advice assumes that it's safe to have a disk full of noise (even if you deny it's encrypted data) in your control. That is perhaps a safe assumption under all foreseen circumstances, but it needs to be considered. Another piece of advice I see, to simply destroy all media that has ever held sensitive information, assumes that destroying media is safe, as opposed to being prima facie evidence of wrongdoing. Again, it might be safe in all circumstances under consideration, but the assumption needs to be made explicit and it needs to be considered. My point is that all these unexamined assumptions are quite unprofessional and reflect poorly on the commentators.
- wmf 16y agoGood thing HFS+ is not a modern filesystem. Also, I'm not sure what FDE has to do with recovering unlinked files.
- jrockway 16y agoWith secure delete, someone with your disk can't read deleted files. With an encrypted filesystem, they can't read the non-deleted files, either.
- newman314 16y agoSSDs with FDE... http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9131684/Full_disk_encryption_comes_to_SSDs_for_mobile_devices_laptops http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9131684/Full_disk_enc...
- coin 16y agoI haven't been able to find a free bootable full-disk encryption solution for the Mac. TrueCrypt is free but doesn't support bootable whole-disk encryption for the Mac. The only solution I found was PGP Whole Disk Encryption which isn't free.
- sp4rki 16y agoI've generally seen full disk encryption on a OS volume as a moot point. Why is there a need to have full disk encryption on a bootable volume, when the only thing you should be protecting from prying eyes is your content? Full disk encryption makes sense in a data volume, not in a bootable volume where just having a ~ directory and it's children encrypted covers mostly everyone's need for security.
- jrockway 16y agoSo you know for a fact that every application you ever use doesn't write data outside of ~? You may feel comfortable about that, but I don't. /tmp, for example, can contain plenty of sensitive data.
- sp4rki 16y agoIt doesn't if I don't give it permission to, but if you're concerned about it encrypt /tmp also or symlink it to ~/tmp (provided you're the only user). Nevertheless, I do understand that you have different requirements, but in the case someone really values the option of having his entire boot volume encrypted, the one time only price tag of PGP is a moot point and shouldn't be a deterrent. In fact, I'm now tempted to buy PGP's whole disk encryption thank you very much. In any case, I think it's generally overkill, but if you really needed, who am I to stand in your way! :) http://www.pgp.com/products/wholediskencryption/index.html http://www.pgp.com/products/wholediskencryption/index.html
- jrockway 16y agoI use Linux, so full-disk encryption was just a checkbox (erm, line that you select?) in the installer. Like I said, it's free, so why not?
- sp4rki 16y agoOh silly me, I kind of assumed you where using OSX because someone made the comment that there's no option for full disk encryption. My bad. If I had an option to encrypt my whole disk that easily in OSX I'd take in a heart beat, not necessarily because I think it's better but because it's a solution and it's simple... because I can so to speak.