3 ms·
As a guy living in Eastern Europe: definitely not the case around here. It's just that life is way too uncertain and everybody is fighting for scraps. Many cou
by pdimitar 8y ago
As a guy living in Eastern Europe: definitely not the case around here.
It's just that life is way too uncertain and everybody is fighting for scraps. Many couples either decide they don't want to bring a child in such uncertain conditions -- like me and my wife -- or they risk it and end up providing very subpar support for their kids. You should see two parents crying and hugging each other and their kid in front of a store because they cannot afford to buy it a $50 LEGO set... It can break your heart and give you a new perspective on the perceived notion of "the world, globally speaking, gets better".
We the people adapt quite well to basically everything, I'd say. But the developed world you speak of is basically the smaller part of the civilized territory on the planet. Go ask people in Nepal, my country Bulgaria, or Hungaria, or Serbia, or Brazil about the average living standard and what miracles many parents achieve just so their kids get decent education, are well-fed and have some small entertainment budget on top of that.
I mean we are most certainly both correct for the respective filter bubbles we are living in. But I still wanted to offer you another perspective.
- toasterlovin 8y ago> Many couples either decide they don't want to bring a child in such uncertain conditions -- like me and my wife -- or they risk it and end up providing very subpar support for their kids. What I'm saying is that "subpar" is not an absolute measure. Its meaning is constantly being revised according to what other people are doing. Is life in Eastern Europe today, in 2018, worse than it was 100 years ago (well, not exactly 100 years ago, since that was around WWI, but you get the idea)? And yet the birth rates are way lower. So clearly our conception about whether having children is viable is being scrambled by something in the modern environment. My hunch is that it's constant exposure to media and, with it, the constant sense that we are doing poorly (because the media primarily portrays fantasy lifestyles).
- OctoberThoughts 8y agoOur concept of whether having children is viable also carries a lot more weight, since contraception is now available and effective. You can think it's a terrible idea, but when the only way to prevent it is abstinence...
- toasterlovin 8y ago> Our concept of whether having children is viable also carries a lot more weight I'm in total agreement. The plummeting birth rates speak to that. I'm taking a biological viewpoint. If a biologist were examining human natural history, the single most peculiar feature would be how birth rates became disconnected from material wealth in the last 100 years.
- pdimitar 8y agoIt is very much connected. Many people don't have the necessary stability to raise kids, so they don't. And no small amount of rich people don't want kids because they don't want to dedicate that much attention to something else but themselves -- egotism is not illegal after all. But I think this second example amounts to much smaller contribution to the birth rate decline.
- pdimitar 8y agoYour questions are valid but I cannot agree with their premise. Yeah, life in Eastern Europe is very definitely much better compared to, say, 1900, but it's not that simple; back then they didn't have 10 bills to pay a month nor did they have to do grocery shopping. People lived on the farm and produced food and whatever they didn't have, they bartered their extra goods for it. Pretty simple and overall easy life (although working on the farm can be quite exhausting and consume 16+ hours a day sometimes). All balanced out with bad healthcare for example: chances were much higher you could die of a disease that's trivial to cure today. I mean, it's apples to oranges. Many things are objectively better... and many others are objectively worse. There's nothing scrambling our concept about whether we should have children. As several people in this discussion pointed out, having children was linked to benefits down the line back in the past, and nowadays they are mostly only a cost center. And finally, whether we compare 2018 with 1900 or not, life in many places of the world is hard and many people don't want to raise a child in very uncertain conditions. You don't care if 1900 was worse; you only suffer because you cannot buy your kid a toy -- or even their favourite food. Comparing to the past in such a situation is quite pointless.
- watwut 8y agoThe lego set example strikes me as odd, because lego is optional and I grew without such toys bc parents could not buy them. I am well off as parent, but 50$ toys are something that I don't buy. And I am no rare, it is just normal not to buy expensive toys. No matter how rich you are, the kid is going to cry at some point or the other due to inability to buy toy. Where it gets bad is when you can't buy something all the other kids have. I understand that there is such a thing as poverty and it sux, but 50$ lego set is not that example. It is when you can't afford schools supply and such.
- pdimitar 8y agoI agree it wasn't the best example. I was aiming at something that you would buy your kid twice a year... and even though that expense is pretty rare, the parents still don't have the money. I failed to convey the message. Sorry. My overall point is there are quite a bit of things the kids need outside of immediate survival. For example, between ages 1 and 10 you basically have to buy them new shoes twice a year... And not having the money for that would suck a lot.