3 ms·
That is the whole point of having armed forces! Armed forces exist to provide achieve foreign policy goals (deterrence, coercion) through the credible threat of
by mindcrime 8y ago
That is the whole point of having armed forces! Armed forces exist to provide achieve foreign policy goals (deterrence, coercion) through the credible threat of its lethality.
WTF? No, just no. The only foreign policy goal the armed forces exist to serve is defense of the homeland. Everything else is a misuses of the military. Just because it's commonplace in this day and age doesn't mean it's OK or that anyone should accept it.
- _iyig 8y agoSerious question: was liberating Auschwitz a misuse of the military?
- mindcrime 8y agoGiven that Germany had declared war on the US, and the liberation of Auschwitz was a direct consequence of defeating Germany, I'll say "no". But that doesn't mean that there's a general principle that "just because something has a desirable outcome, the action itself was proper or justified". Use of force should be reserved for all but the most dire circumstances in general.
- logfromblammo 8y agoThat's a seriously naive take. Militaries exist to project power onto foreign entities. Defense of national territory is but one use for that projected power. Keeping trade lanes open--such as those through the Straits of Hormuz or the South China Sea--is another use. Enforcing a trade blockade or embargo is another. The size and lethality of your military is measurable proof of your commitment to a particular political issue.
- closeparen 8y agoFor better or worse, defense of the homeland is not accomplished by literally standing at the US border waiting for someone to step over the line, but by working to neutralize threats and prevent their emergence abroad.
- mindcrime 8y agoFair enough, I'll admit the line is a little fuzzy. But there's clearly a point where we've gone way beyond any reasonable notion of "defense" and are engaging in offense, oppression, empire building, etc. And I'd argue that we're way over that line these days.
- gaius 8y agoThe only foreign policy goal the armed forces exist to serve is defense of the homeland. Securing access to raw materials is defending the homeland. I live on an island, patrolling the shipping lanes is absolutely something our military should be doing. Standing ready to assist our trading partners on whom we rely for food and fuel is absolutely something they should be doing.