3 ms·
How Little Do Users Read?
- brlewis 19y agoQuote: I was able to fit very nice formulas to describe users' reading behavior for pages containing between 30 and 1,250 words. For longer pages, reading became quite erratic. Pages with a huge word count are probably not "real" pages anyway Steve Yegge, are you reading this? :-)
- jrockway 19y agoThe case of Steve Yegge is different. He's not trying to sell you anything; he's just talking. If you want to listen, you'll probably learn something, so it's in your best interest to read. If you're not interested in learning anything, it's no skin off of Yegge's ass, so why should he care? In other words, nice joke, but it doesn't apply here.
- brlewis 19y agoYes, it's all joke. I find it very funny that Steve's writings would be discarded from the data as "probably not real pages" and I imagine Steve would too.
- gaika 19y agoGood observation, wrong conclusion. Too many words never stopped people from reading a book. Same thing applies to a web page: you quickly scan a page, but read it if it's worth it.
- webwright 19y agoI don't think that's the right conclusion either. I think user mind-set is huge, here. Are they in shopping mode? Learning mode? Surfing mode? I'd say 90% of the time that I scan, I'm looking for the bit of content that I care about-- NOT trying to decide whether the article is worth reading.
- Goronmon 19y agoCouldn't that just be further distilled down to users scanning material until they decide it's worth taking the time to read more thoroughly? Even if I'm in surfing mode, I'll stop to read an article if it's something that piques my interest. I mean, isn't that the whole idea behind people getting lost in the depths of Wikipedia? You may have only brought it up in the browser to fact check something quickly, but all of a sudden you find yourself reading about completely unrelated materials 20 minutes later.
- bodom 19y agoBreaking things up with headings, lists, and bold stuff helps people browse. I'm sure that helps longer articles. The post may have mentioned it, but I didn't read it all.
- mosburger 19y agoTL;DR OK - I'm joking (sort of). I do think it's telling that he finishes the article with this: "Clearly, the average visitor won't make it too far through most of my articles. But I've consciously targeted a small, elite readership with a firm commitment to usability. If you target a broader audience or have sales cycles that are shorter than 5 years, you'd be wise to put your word count on a strict diet." I think this actually says more than the pretty graphs and statistical dissection. Know your target audience. And for most of us, our target audience has a very short attention span. From his second graph, it looks like the sweet spot is a bit under 100 words. Yikes!
- bootload 19y ago"... From his second graph, it looks like the sweet spot is a bit under 100 words ..." Maybe this is why Amazon wanted their book reviews under 100 words. With all the data they gather it's possible Amazon examined this metric. In "Amazonia" a book by *James Marcus" the first question Bezos asked Marcus was, "what's your GPA?" then "how quickly can you do a (mini-review) book review". Which happened to be on or under 100 words ~ http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A22101-2004Jul1.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A22101-2004Jul...
- aneesh 19y agoIronic that an article on how little users read is so long!
- bouncingsoul 19y agoI would have more respect for usability groups trying to quantify everything if they actually did a rigorous job. The habits of 25 similar people's monitored† browsing are interesting, but don't tell me they represents the entire internet using world. What's with seeking averages for everything? When you have completely different situations the average is not useful information: When I go to a book store I pick up a lot of books, skim them, and put them back because they are boring or not what I wanted. Eventually I will find an interesting one, find a hidden courtesy chair, and read 50 pages. You could study this information and say on average I read 3 pages of all books. That's correct, but it's wrong and misleading. It's not really worth critiquing the rest of the study since it's just not rigorous enough from the outset, but a couple more points: 1. He threw out visits lasting longer than ten minutes. Obviously that's going to affect his conclusion. 2. They have no idea what percentage of the text on a page was actual content. I'd guess 25% of the words on any newspaper site page are not the actual article. He should correct for this. 3. He tacks it on the end, but it seriously challenges the usefulness of this entire study: the content matters. People will read what appears interesting to them and ignore what doesn't. † Surely knowing their behavior is being monitored alters their behavior. If these are work computers then they're probably wary of spending too much time on the internet if it isn't directly related to their work. Maybe they bookmarked articles to read at home. Or maybe they altered their browsing because they're worried about being judged.