5 ms·
> yet we are having less children than we want. How so? Evolution has not programmed into us any sort of drive for careful family planning to optimized the nu
by Sharlin 8y ago
> yet we are having less children than we want.
How so?
Evolution has not programmed into us any sort of drive for careful family planning to optimized the number of offspring. We simply have a drive to have sex. For the vast majority of human (pre)history, optimization of offspring number occurred the same way as with all sexually reproducing species: natural miscarriage and child mortality.
Now that we have control of our own fertility, there's still nothing that drives us to especially want to raise a somehow evolutionarily optimal number of offspring. As with almost any other human behavior it's up to societal values and norms and individual preferences.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoHumans have been able to calculate the present value of children for a long time now. One could easily see the value of extra hands in a farming society, and even now if you can raise a few high earners then you have some backup if/when your retirement doesn't pan out or you need medical assistance and company when you're old. Personally, I would optimize at 3-5 kids (depending on age of mother), assuming 1 or 2 of them don't turn out to be economically productive for whatever reason. And they also have each other as a support network. I would go for at least 2 kids since economies of scale start working for you and you can reuse all the stuff for first for subsequent ones. One child seems suboptimal as it seems like putting all your eggs in one basket.
- Sharlin 8y agoSure. A big cause of the recent population explosion has been reduction of child mortality due to modern medicine, while the number of births lagged behind. In a traditional agrarian society it made some amount of sense to have eight live births, as maybe three or four of those would survive to adulthood. But due to lack of contraception there's not much planning involved in that. A woman would just be continuously either pregnant or nursing. And of course there was a 5% or so chance per birth for the mother to die, which adds up!
- thefz 8y ago> Evolution has not programmed into us any sort of drive for careful family planning to optimized the number of offspring. Except it has, and does on a number of other species too. It is well explained in Harari's Sapiens.
- daxorid 8y ago> We simply have a drive to have sex. What? Take even a cursory glance at any IVF, PCOS, or infertility support group, and observe the outpouring of fundamental NEED and the grief of unfulfilling that need. Humans absolutely have a drive to have children, not simply sex. Sure, there are some people who lack this desire. Usually men, sometimes women, almost always young. The childfree movement (of which I was once a part) definitely epitomizes this. The proportion of people who don't care for kids does appear to be slowly rising, but make no mistake, they are still very much a minority. Humans, almost universally, want children.
- Sharlin 8y agoGranted, I oversimplified. On the other hand it’s not even exactly clear as to when early humans figured out the causation between sex and pregnancy. But my point was more about an evolutionary drive for not having children when resources are scarce. That’s group selection, something whose mere existence is rather controversial. On the other hand, kin selection has probably played a part in prehistoric human communities, so I guess it’s complicated.
- toasterlovin 8y agoNo, deciding not to have children when resources are scarce is not group selection. Parents have limited resources to invest in offspring. Yet offspring need a certain minimum amount of resources to be viable. If parents are not in a position to provide that level of resources, it is better for their own genes that they wait until resources are more plentiful, otherwise they risk wasting resources on an unviable child.
- toasterlovin 8y ago> The childfree movement (of which I was once a part) Glad to have you back from the dark side! I jest, but what changed your mind and/or how do you feel about things now?
- daxorid 8y agoWhat changed my mind was holding my (unplanned) daughter in my arms for the first time. I've posted a little about this before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17473013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17473013
- rayiner 8y ago> We simply have a drive to have sex. People want kids, not just sex. Among the 14% of Americans over 45 who never had children, 47% would have preferred to have two or more children, and only 44% would have preferred to not have had children. Among the 86% of adults over 45 who do have children, just 7% would have preferred not to have children. Put differently 12% either didn't have kids and are happy with it, or had kids and regret it. 85% are either happy they had kids, or regret not having them. People want to have a certain number of kids. It may be aspirational--like the weight they want to be or how often they want to go to the gym--but it's a real desire, quite independent of sex.
- Sharlin 8y agoYes, I oversimplified. But see my reply to a sibling post.