4 ms·
the Web was far more pleasant when it was about hyperlinked documents and not this cloud-computing-inspired frenzy It was also a lot less useful though, as it
by onion2k 8y ago
the Web was far more pleasant when it was about hyperlinked documents and not this cloud-computing-inspired frenzy
It was also a lot less useful though, as it was mostly about consumption. All of the creating happened elsewhere. People made things on their computer in other apps and then published them to the web. Now though, the web platform is shifting towards being a creative place in itself. People can make and share things entirely within a browser. I'd think that's a significant positive change.
- userbinator 8y agoPeople can make and share things entirely within a browser. I'd think that's a significant positive change. Forums and blogs don't count? Those were present long before this "turn browser into OS" trend started.
- onion2k 8y agoForums and blogs don't count? I've been making web things for a long time. When the grandparent posted "when it was about hyperlinked documents" I took that to mean "When we wrote things for Mosaic". Forums didn't really exist on the web back then. I'd say that comments, forums, etc were one of the first creative tools. We've come a long way since then, but there's much more to do, and it's all very exciting. It's definitely making the web better IMO.
- pdkl95 8y ago> I've been making web things for a long time. I've been making internet things since before the "web" existed. > Forums didn't really exist on the web back then Gopher didn't really have the necessary interactivity, but nobody cared at the time because if you wanted to talk about something in a global forum, you used NNTP (or email lists). The web (HTML+HTTP) had comment/forums/etc from the very beginning, because it was designed with IBM 3270 style form submission features (<form>/<input> tags and HTTP POST). I used these (and other interactive features) regularly in text browsers over my 2400 baud modem. Even if I had better bandwidth, there was no way I could run NCSA Mosaic in the 4MB of RAM installed on my 386DX. Yes, it was slow, but submitting comments only required special support by the server, which then returned a new hypertext document to the client. The feature that arrived later was Javascript, allowing some features to be done directly on the client. However, this was not a necessary required for writing forums software; that always worked as server side software. Shoving everything into the client didn't create many new opportunities; a lot of that existed already in separate software. What did happen is we attached everything to the same single point of failure and created a lot of security problems because risk is transitive.
- cromwellian 8y agoNo, what we did was trade off one set of security problems to having dozens of clients for every TCP protocol (IRC, NNTP, SMTP, IMAP, FTP, WAIS, Gopher, fingerd, etc) with their own set of security flaws, but which had less oversight, and that gets you things like the Morris worm. And because every one of these had their own rigorous protocol, and their own binary clients, if there was a flaw in the protocol itself, it could take ages to get a fix to the protocol from the IETF and all clients deployed with the fixes. So for example, the obvious and horrible security of usenet led to the first massive spam bots, which then led to a bunch of even more horrible mitigations like Cancelbots, which led to a bunch of counter-mitigations like Resurrector-bots. These days, with ephemeral, mobile code, a security hole in the client/server protocol of a particular app can be fixed in an instant and rolled out to everyone. And the Web is better at this than the native mobile or desktop platforms, now behind curated App Stores, with a lower update frequency, and whose very closed-source curation process means they don't get as much rigorous testing as the Web in running untrusted code. The Web has been running untrusted global scale mobile code for decades now, and most of the exploits on the Web have occurred as a result of bad server programming, not holes in Javascript. So Web 1.0 request/response apps won't save you, all it will do is punish everyone with bad latency and higher server loads.
- swiley 8y agoI would disagree that the web was more about consumption. There where more personal pages because html was simple and there was little reason for large businesses to build pages around consumption or write html for you. Older browsers even had edit modes and would use the http PUT method to send updated versions of the document. The original intention of the web was a sort of global wiki, not this tool to connect you to some coorperate service.
- onion2k 8y agoThere where more personal pages... Than Instagram accounts? YouTube channels? Facebook pages? Twitter profiles? No. There's far more now. The landscape has changed and things look very different, but those things are personal pages where people publish what they want to say. The only thing that's changed is that the platforms people publish to have far less scope for personalisation. I'd definitely agree that those pages are worse than homepages we had in the 90s as far as a personal voice is concerned. They're mostly boring, homogeneous things that only very close friends of the owner want to read (and even then...). Nonetheless though, they are homepages.
- cknoxrun 8y ago> All of the creating happened elsewhere. People made things on their computer in other apps and then published them to the web. The interesting thing there is that most people use those tools (Instagram, etc.) through an app, not through a browser.
- 908087 8y agoI'd argue that things like "likes" have created an environment where people generally publish what they think other people would want them to say (e.g. things that will be "rewarded" with internet points), rather than what they actually want to say.
- onion2k 8y agoThat's just 'better' metrics. Back in the day we had hit counters and server logs, and some of us tweaked our content to drive them up. There were early forms of SEO, clickbait, content marketing ("content is king" was something every web person knew). The desire for recognition was there at the start.
- kitsunesoba 8y agoI beg to differ. The web I participated in through the early to late 00s, most of which came before the web app craze, had a far, far better ratio of creation:consumption. This held true both in meta sense (the web itself) with tens of thousands of individually run sites and blogs instead of a handful of hypercentralized content warehouses, as well as in the proliferation of numerous creative communities and individuals making things. I know because I spent the majority of the 00s on these sorts of sites. Today, all of that’s died almost entirely and no subreddit or facebook group or anything can hold a candle to it. Today, the web is all about endless monetized entertainment streams designed to maintain the attention of as many eyeballs as possible as long as possible. It’s effectively turned into the modern equivalent of network TV.