3 ms·
ViaSat-3 is 6400kg (Aka, a large sat) and placed in GEO. It is also using rad hard hardware and has significant redundancy. Comparing that to cube sats in LEO i
by godelski 8y ago
ViaSat-3 is 6400kg (Aka, a large sat) and placed in GEO. It is also using rad hard hardware and has significant redundancy. Comparing that to cube sats in LEO is like comparing apples and oranges. Small sats are... well small and generally equipped with COTS devices, which greatly drops the price. Also there is a significantly different cost to putting something in LEO vs GEO. (GEO costs several times more per kg)
- rayiner 8y agoIs there a cube sat with COTS hardware that has a 1 tbps capacity? Otherwise, you’re comparing real systems that are being deployed next year with paperware. Online I’m seeing entire constellations of 300-600 small satellites weighing in at 5-10 terabits of capacity. You need about 500 5G towers to get that, which will cost you about the same as a single Falcon 9 Heavy launch. Can you launch an entire constellation of cube sats for $75 million? (Far less with 5G small cells.) Also, what does the mobility story look like? You’d be a fool to spend billions on fixed-only infrastructure in 2018.
- godelski 8y ago> Is there a cube sat with COTS hardware that has a 1 tbps capacity? > Online I’m seeing entire constellations of 300-600 small satellites weighing in at 5-10 terabits of capacity. >>> Some googling will show you white papers with estimates of ~4500 nanosats (30x10x10cm), but you can reduce the number of those by not rolling out usage worldwide and then scale up I'm sorry, but it feels as if you're willfully ignoring a VERY important part of my comment. Yes, you need a large number. But you don't have to start at the 4.5k constellation estimate. I'm also not saying it is strictly cheaper, but I am saying there are some lucrative advantages to it. That's what I'm getting at. But I guess the responses I'm getting answer my original question.
- rayiner 8y agoI’m not ignoring that, I’m asking how the economics works. 5G will involve deployment of tens of thousands of cells in the US alone. Even 4,500 nano sats won’t offer similar capacity unless each sat has massive capacity. Moreover, mobility is crucial. If you can’t put the reciever in a cell phone, the utility is greatly diminished. Unless my math is wrong, it sounds like the answer to your question is: people are investing in 5G rather than sats because it offers more capacity and a dramatically more valuable (mobile) service. The benefit of being able to cover the world with internet isn’t important to the FCC or US cellular companies.
- godelski 8y agoWell here's something to get you started. One of those whitepapers I told you that you can easily google. Mind you, none of them is exactly complete (once they are, they stay internal to the company). https://arxiv.org/pdf/1508.02383.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1508.02383.pdf