3 ms·
I am unable to find any statement in the available descriptions of this incident to dissuade me from the opinion that the Camry driver behaved in a very neglige
by kazinator 8y ago
I am unable to find any statement in the available descriptions of this incident to dissuade me from the opinion that the Camry driver behaved in a very negligent way.
There is no traffic violation called "boxing in".
The vehicle already in the freeway has the right of way; the merging vehicle must accommodate itself to the situation, not the other way around. If necessary, the merging vehicle must stop (way in advance of the merge point) and wait for a suitably long gap which takes into account the acceleration time.
It's possible that a vehicle on the freeway can make a hostile move which interferes with the merging driver's judgment, such as unexpectedly changing to the right lane or accelerating. I don't see any claim of this sort about this situation (which doesn't mean that it didn't happen).
For a merging vehicle to fail to adjust its speed to the traffic, and to drive side by side with a vehicle which has right-of-way, to the point of then having to swerve to avoid an obstacle, doesn't look good for the driver of the merging vehicle.
I get the point that the software should take into account psychotic maniacs of this nature; no disagreement there. It is a fact of driving in North America that people merge on the freeway by seizing the right of way, relying on vehicles passing the on-ramp to hit their brakes, and will pull crazy stunts like driving side by side with a car that doesn't slow down from them, even past the end of the merge lane where they run out of room. Software should defend itself against these maniacs. I say defend; it is a defense against reckless, unlawful motorist behavior.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoThis is completely unrelated to the fact that a single engineer was able to override the software to take the car for what is effectively a joy ride. This should never have been possible to happen. The fact that Waymo hushed this up also doesn't instill trust.
- ehsankia 8y agoFirst off, the "single engineer" was Levandowski, the person who basically started Google's self-driving team and was the lead for the project, not any random person. Second, this was back in 2011, and that was in the early days, "Waymo" wasn't a thing until 2016. This is just a bunch of engineers experimenting, not a real product. Lastly, the person who did this is long gone.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoFirst off, the "single engineer" was Levandowski, the person who basically started Google's self-driving team and was the lead for the project, not any random person. So what? That does not dicount the fact that a single engineer rigged the software in a way which allowed a deadly machine to be used on public roads. If anything it makes the issue much worse that the lead engineer performed such an, arguably, criminal hack. Actually I appreciate your answer. It illustrates perfectly why the SV croud cannot be trusted with policy decisions regarding autonomous vehicles.
- AstralStorm 8y agoBetter ban people from installing anything in their cars. Who knows if that cell phone holder will kill. (Here's where I show you the absurdity of what you're asking for.) Preferably also prevent mechanics from taking apart cars, they make mistakes and install unapproved parts. It is far more dangerous than an actual test drive with an actual safety driver.