17 ms·
Why auction perpetual rights and not lease them? You could also add a use-it-or-lose-it to avoid dog-in-the-manger exclusion of rivals. "selling" the rights s
by gumby 8y ago
Why auction perpetual rights and not lease them? You could also add a use-it-or-lose-it to avoid dog-in-the-manger exclusion of rivals.
"selling" the rights seems short sighted, no matter how you set the price.
- teraflop 8y agoAs far as I can tell, the rights are not perpetual. For example, I arbitrarily picked a recent auction for "FM Broadcast" rights (https://www.fcc.gov/auction/98/factsheet https://www.fcc.gov/auction/98/factsheet), and the description states that the rights being auctioned are for an eight-year license period.
- jcrawfordor 8y agoAlthough it's a bit patchwork, most spectrum rights (from auction to licensure) are use-it-or-lose-it. On licenses as simple as an FM broadcast license, stations must report to the FCC if they will not be broadcasting for any period of time, and if they remain "dark" for too long they face cancellation of their license for non-use. On spectrum auctions it's usually a condition of the license that it will be cancelled if certain conditions specific to the spectrum aren't met, e.g. offering a certain range of services to a certain volume of customers.
- rayiner 8y agoIdeally, the government is not in the business of deciding what each block of spectrum should be used for. What Coase proved is that if you auction the spectrum and allow secondary-market transactions in the spectrum, then the spectrum will end up in the highest value use--i.e. the most economically efficient use.[1] It doesn't matter "how you set the price" initially--secondary market transactions will take care of reallocating the spectrum to the best uses. The FCC auctions don't implement fully Coasian auctions--they auction licenses for a limited duration. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coase_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coase_theorem
- xyzzy123 8y agoThey might end up with their best use, but the public (well ok, government...) would not be compensated for the full value of the public good, right? e.g. If you initially sell for $1 to BobTelco then BobTelco (and any future “owners”) eventually capture the real value of that spectrum.
- whatshisface 8y agoIt's a pattern repeated across just about every market system: the reward for finding out about a mispricing is equal to the magnitude of the error.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoThe public can participate in the upside if they buy shares in the public companies that operate their businesss on the spectrum.
- bildung 8y agoBut that isn't democratic anymore. Whereas one person equals one vote in the case of the public receiving the profits, participation in the stock market means more profit the more you wealth you already have (for buying shares).
- rayiner 8y agoYes the point is to ensure that resources sre allocated efficiently, not use the resource as a revenue generation tool for the government.
- harrumph 8y agoOne point: Coase did not write the theorem you're attributing to him -- Stigler did, by cherry-picking the anti-regulatory pieces of Coase's 1960 paper while importantly ignoring Coase's own warnings about the conditions Coase lays out for the case against regulation. These are, and I quote from Coase: "very unrealistic assumptions". The U of C crew nonetheless elevated Coase's conjecture to the rank of a general theory, and a tsunami of right-wing economics quackery has followed this parlor trick. I suspect there is no honest reading of Coase that supports the notion that the public benefit of the spectrum must be thrown to the market. Readings of the market-fundamentalist Chicago Boys who ran with the favored pieces of his work, sure, but not of him.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 8y agoWhy auction perpetual rights and not lease them? Depends if the buyer has a means (and incentive) to clean up the spectrum when their license ends. Some applications like TV and cell phones make cleaning up the spectrum easily possible - you just turn off the broadcast towers. But if the government leases the spectrum to a company who uses it for consumer products like wireless doorbells and thermostats and burglar alarms and toy drones and two-way radios, those things are going to keep using the spectrum for years after their license expires.