2 ms·
When's the most recently that private companies haven't owned the infrastructure facilitating daily life? Railroads are private businesses, the telephone compan
by philwelch 8y ago
When's the most recently that private companies haven't owned the infrastructure facilitating daily life? Railroads are private businesses, the telephone companies are private businesses, payments have to go through credit card companies and banks, TV and radio are private businesses. Roads are public, but you have to go through private businesses to buy, maintain, repair, and fuel your car.
Commercial infrastructure providers have always had similar power, and sometimes even use it. The main reasons for them not using it has always been a combination of purely commercial motives for running a business--which is undermined by the founding myth of Silicon Valley as a haven for idealistic hippies trying to change the world--and the potential for competition--which is undermined by the monopolistic tendencies of the tech industry and the cultural groupthink on the West Coast.
Ironically, Silicon Valley, the Internet, and the field of computer science itself all originate from WWII-era military R&D.
- tomohawk 8y agoWhen companies get to monopoly status (which the SV companies are), many of the kinds of things they could do as non-monopolies are no longer legal. They also face greater political scrutiny and legal action. This is as it should be. The railroad companies are heavily regulated, as are the phone companies, as are the energy companies, etc. They tried applying 1930s phone laws to the internet, and that didn't work out. At some point, they'll have to nut up and make some laws that prevent monopolies from doing bad things, or they'll have to allow the FTC to start breaking 'em up.
- philwelch 8y agoYeah, it’s a hard problem. And I think GP is right in the sense that being good stewards of their power will forestall any legislative action targeted against them. The Bell monopoly persisted for years by being on good terms with the government. Which is ironically an incentive for them to take defense and intelligence contracts.
- manfredo 8y agoRailroads and telephone companies are regulated. AFAIK, telecoms can't just refuse service to people because they disagree with their politics. Likewise, a toll-road can't just say, "we're not letting traffic from X company use this infrastructure." Private companies that sell cars are de-facto incapable of refusing service to certain groups, since another entity can just by the car and resell them to the banned party. Private common carriers like UPS and whatnot are also bound by similar rules if I'm not mistaken. I think it is fairly unprecedented that many of the pieces of infrastructure central to running a business are increasingly owned and run by companies that are allowed to refuse service to people on a whim. At least unprecedented since the early 20th century.