5 ms·
I honestly don't know why they are focusing on towers. I honestly believe we need to skip that and use LEO sats. While more expensive upfront, it also provides
by godelski 8y ago
I honestly don't know why they are focusing on towers. I honestly believe we need to skip that and use LEO sats. While more expensive upfront, it also provides the ability to give global coverage. Some googling will show you white papers with estimates of ~4500 nanosats (30x10x10cm), but you can reduce the number of those by not rolling out usage worldwide and then scale up (entering markets in other countries. Even ones that have NO internet access currently).
You have low latency, high speeds, and don't need as many towers. But you HAVE to be in LEO.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoBecause of how orbits work, I don't think you can really "focus" on an area by reducing the number of satellites without a corresponding decrease in availability and/or throughput. If you have a constellation that has consistent coverage over the US, you're also going to have simultaneous coverage over a good chunk of the rest of the world (although possibly not anywhere more northern than the United States).
- godelski 8y agoYou do realize that I addressed this as actually a feature, right? You don't need 4500 to provide global coverage and handle 100m users. And besides, this isn't about orbits, that is about load balancing. Orbits alone doesn't even describe your coverage area. They do provide an upper bound on your viewable area, but you're never going to reach that.
- late2part 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geostationary_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geostationary_orbit
- mastax 8y agoGive it a decade and there should be one or two to try out. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink_(satellite_constellation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink_(satellite_constellat... [2]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OneWeb_satellite_constellation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OneWeb_satellite_constellati...
- godelski 8y agoI'm fully aware of these programs, and a few more (I very recently left the space industry). I'm more concerned that these initiatives are not being pushed forward faster. As well as these things seem to focus on "We can provide the world with internet" and not "We can provide America with 5G and continually scale to include substantially larger markets". I think that's why they aren't getting funded. Because they are stating the benefits of the grand design when companies like Verizon and AT&T are just focused on the next step.
- walshemj 8y agoBackhaul
- rayiner 8y agoA ViaSat-3 costs about $600 million and offers 1 terabit of capacity. That's about as much as 50 5G cells, which you can build for about $150,000 each (or about $7.5 million to support the same capacity).
- godelski 8y agoViaSat-3 is 6400kg (Aka, a large sat) and placed in GEO. It is also using rad hard hardware and has significant redundancy. Comparing that to cube sats in LEO is like comparing apples and oranges. Small sats are... well small and generally equipped with COTS devices, which greatly drops the price. Also there is a significantly different cost to putting something in LEO vs GEO. (GEO costs several times more per kg)
- rayiner 8y agoIs there a cube sat with COTS hardware that has a 1 tbps capacity? Otherwise, you’re comparing real systems that are being deployed next year with paperware. Online I’m seeing entire constellations of 300-600 small satellites weighing in at 5-10 terabits of capacity. You need about 500 5G towers to get that, which will cost you about the same as a single Falcon 9 Heavy launch. Can you launch an entire constellation of cube sats for $75 million? (Far less with 5G small cells.) Also, what does the mobility story look like? You’d be a fool to spend billions on fixed-only infrastructure in 2018.
- godelski 8y ago> Is there a cube sat with COTS hardware that has a 1 tbps capacity? > Online I’m seeing entire constellations of 300-600 small satellites weighing in at 5-10 terabits of capacity. >>> Some googling will show you white papers with estimates of ~4500 nanosats (30x10x10cm), but you can reduce the number of those by not rolling out usage worldwide and then scale up I'm sorry, but it feels as if you're willfully ignoring a VERY important part of my comment. Yes, you need a large number. But you don't have to start at the 4.5k constellation estimate. I'm also not saying it is strictly cheaper, but I am saying there are some lucrative advantages to it. That's what I'm getting at. But I guess the responses I'm getting answer my original question.