4 ms·
> You can't really let people have a say with regards to everything they pay for, because a lot of people have an "I got mine" attitude, so as long as no house
by sneak 8y ago
> You can't really let people have a say with regards to everything they pay for, because a lot of people have an "I got mine" attitude, so as long as no house has burned down in their neighborhood lately, they might be tempted to vote against funding the fire department as well.
While I despise your position, I admire your honesty about the fact that these policies are paternalistic and violate consent.
What makes you the person who gets to decide for them what they should or shouldn’t spend their money on?
- PhasmaFelis 8y ago> What makes you the person who gets to decide for them what they should or shouldn’t spend their money on? I don't know who is qualified to be that person, but somebody has to if you want to avoid tyranny-of-the-majority. "You can do any goddamn thing you want as long as you can convince 51 voters out of 100 to back you" is not sustainable. (See e.g. unpunished lynchings in the post-Civil War South.)
- magduf 8y agoIt might not be sustainable in your opinion, but it is literally what democracy is. Do you support democracy or not?
- hnbroseph 8y agoThe person deciding is ostensibly the person elected to do the deciding.
- cbg0 8y ago> these policies are paternalistic and violate consent. Like I said, if you don't like living in a society where the rules aren't to your liking, you can go live by yourself in the woods where there's no one to violate your consent.
- magduf 8y agoWhat if the majority of voters in that society vote for "I got mine" policies? That's what we're arguing here; this isn't a situation about a handful of malcontents.