4 ms·
You can't run a government like this. Most people don't use most government services, yet the smaller number who do use them really benefit greatly from them.
by CydeWeys 8y ago
You can't run a government like this. Most people don't use most government services, yet the smaller number who do use them really benefit greatly from them. If we voted down all government services that <50% of people use then society ends up suffering greatly. Hell, most people don't even use firefighters; should we vote them down too?
- claydavisss 8y agoWe vote to fund firefighting because we all know we COULD make us of the service even if we haven't...this is still a self-interested vote but in the case of firefighting, most cities could drastically reshape their emergency services to put much of what firefighters do in the hands of an emergency response office that is much cheaper to run. its no coincidence that firefighters make sure they are in the critical path of vehicle accident response etc...they realize that structure fires are vanishingly rare and they might otherwise see drastic cuts. there isn't any real reason why a fire truck should be responding to someone with mild whiplash in a rear-ended vehicle (and no, the reason isn't because the vehicle might spontaneously combust).
- alexanderwept 8y agoNo one is saying that we should vote down all services that aren't used by <50% of the population. My only point is that decisions are democratically valid if they're ratified by the majority. The majority of people deciding to have libraries is just as democratically legitimate as the majority deciding not the have libraries.