4 ms·
The objection is due process related including preventing them from using their funds to hire an attorney whilst teams of attorneys are brought to bear against
by Nasrudith 8y ago
The objection is due process related including preventing them from using their funds to hire an attorney whilst teams of attorneys are brought to bear against them. It stinks of a capricious attempt to deny the right to legal council to those who offend those at the top. Even Enron masterminds were allowed to use their assets which certainly came from their misdeeds which crippled the state and likely killed people via their outages. This mockery of justice is what makes it inhumane.
- jstarfish 8y ago> The objection is due process related including preventing them from using their funds to hire an attorney whilst teams of attorneys are brought to bear against them. This is my objection. It's obscene that the full resources of the state are brought down on defendants expected to subsist only on "modest living expenses." It's one thing when your opponent has the backing of their own narco-state, but these are presumably a bunch of 20-somethings with a net worth of less than $1M. You can't challenge someone to a duel and then handicap them by taking away their gun and making them wear a bag over their head. That's not a fight, that's an execution.
- Brockenstein 8y agoThe only problem is you're now arguing that someone who has enriched themselves illegally, stolen assets, or defrauded people can use that money to defend themselves and potentially drain it down to nothing, at which point they claim they can't be expected to pay restitution if they lose. Yeah, no way that won't be abused... There isn't a perfect system. And your argument that they need every cent of that money to mount a defense might be more than a little overblown.
- Retric 8y agoThe criminal justice system is not based on the assumption that people are guilty before trial. Otherwise trials would be pointless. Further, they could easily spend several times that much money defending themselves. Sure, if they had billions then that's a meaningful argument but not for <300k.
- jstarfish 8y agoI don't disagree with your sentiment, but the flaw with your argument is that you're presuming the proceeds were acquired illegally before a trial is even conducted. We don't yet know that what they did was illegal. We don't even know if the right people are being prosecuted in the first place. That's the entire point of the trial. We may not have a perfect system but presumptions that defendants are "obviously guilty" or "don't actually need all that money" defeats the purpose of having a system at all. Like arbitration, there's literally no point-- we're supposed to have progressed beyond kangaroo courts with arbitrary rules weighted in favor of the prosecution.
- ataturk 8y agoWelcome to corporo-fascism, friend.
- weberc2 8y agoI’m not much of a libertarian nor a cryptocurrency enthusiast, but stuff like this is plainly wrong and it would be satisfying to see someone in similar circumstances dump their assets into bitcoin or similar before the government could freeze or seize anything. I’m sure this isn’t a novel idea and happens occasionally (regularly?).
- Brockenstein 8y agoTwo things. You're making some assumptions that are problematic. 1. That this is wrong under Australian law, or somehow irregular. You not liking it, or having a knee jerk reaction is not the same as an actual moral judgement. 2. That courts generally have no recourse this sort of behavior. Lots of people have tried this sort of gambit, ditching assets and whatnot to avoid paying judgement. And everyone seems to think it's an original idea or that the courts can't nail your nuts to a wall for doing it. Furthermore: 3. It is beyond trivial for them to determine that you took the money out of a bank. And then demand to know where it's at. And then demand that you recover it. And then also punish you criminally for that criminal conduct. 4. Every lawyer everywhere beats their heads against their desk every time one of their brain trust clients do something so egregiously stupid as what you're imagining.
- russdpale 8y agoAll of this is true, but its also true that the government would still not be able to freeze your assets... And if you are willing go take the criminal charges for that conduct, then those assets will still be on the blockchain when you get out.
- Brockenstein 8y agoSo you're under the belief that you have hundreds of thousands of dollars obtained in some scheme and there's a court order to pay it back. And you're under the belief that if you hide those assets and tell the court to eff off, that you may go to prison for a separate crime than for what the judgement was originally for and after you serve your time that nullifies the original judgement and/or makes you untouchable legally? It sure does seem like several folks have grandiose surefire ideas of how to beat the system. And believe they're stubborn enough that they can out wait everyone, that the courts, government, plaintiffs will all just give up and give in. Good luck with that. It sounds like a child's fantasy to me.
- Brockenstein 8y agoWell Australia and U.S. law are not the same... so what Enron execs were allowed to do in U.S. courts 10-15 years ago really doesn't have any bearing.
- rangibaby 8y ago> he objection is due process related including preventing them from using their funds to hire an attorney whilst teams of attorneys are brought to bear against them. see: Kim Dotcom