4 ms·
Only the leading space is important and editors take care of it when you hit the tab key.
by mixmastamyk 8y ago
Only the leading space is important and editors take care of it when you hit the tab key.
- ComputerGuru 8y agoOr just use a language that doesn’t have that problem, then you don’t need a magic editor.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoIt's not a problem, it's a lot simpler than typing matching braces everywhere. Python is one of the easiest languages to learn.
- simion314 8y agoI am not the person you replied but in C style syntax when you type { in an IDE the { is inserted automatically so there is no risk to forget about it, also if you copy paste a piece of code you just run the action to reformat the file or the selected code and the braces will correctly fall onto place. I am not saying that Python syntax is a big issue, but is one more thing to keep in mind and it potentially trip up children(probably something more visual that is impossible to make syntax errors is better but I did not find something that is engaging enough)
- mixmastamyk 8y agoHis point was about not needing a "magic" editor. Neither does python, it works with spaces or tabs as long as you are consistent, and tells you where you aren't.
- simion314 8y agoMy point is that if I define a metric for easier to use by a beginner programmer (child) then C syntax > Python syntax If you define a different metric, maybe pretty syntax then it would compare in reverse. Though I don't have experience or seen people testing this on children and "proving" that having to keep in mind spaces/tabs is harder then the braces and semicolumns (when using a decent IDE) so I may be wrong.
- stormking 8y ago> My point is that if I define a metric for easier to use by a beginner programmer (child) then C syntax > Python syntax That's pure speculation, not a fact.
- simion314 8y agoMy speculation is based on the FACT that python syntax involves the programmer to indent correctly where C like syntax is not , so the only way you could disagree is that maybe 1 the cost of keeping indentation in mind for beginners is 0 2 or the cost is greater then zero but there is some different cost in C like syntax that affects beginners Keep in mind I am talking about syntax here and not the C language
- knicholes 8y agoIf a kid can understand a for loop, I think the kid should be able to understand indentation.
- ComputerGuru 8y agoHardly. One you can see, one you can't. And that's without accounting for the real cause for consternation: tabs vs spaces, and tabs being magically changed to spaces or vice versa because of your too-smart-but-not-smart-enough editor.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoAs mentioned previously, Python warns about inconsistent indentation. Also, I learned programming at age 12 and understanding indentation didn't take more than a few seconds.