3 ms·
> does the simulation include these factors? Yes, that's what the "put through a virtual Kepler’s detection scheme" part refers to. So she: 1. Generated a bun
by munificent 8y ago
> does the simulation include these factors?
Yes, that's what the "put through a virtual Kepler’s detection scheme" part refers to. So she:
1. Generated a bunch of random planet sizes.
2. Simulated what the detector would have reported for each.
3. Compared those virtual detections against the real detection data.
If the two results had matched, it would imply real solar systems have random planet sizes and the bias they see is from the detector. Since the two results are different, it implies the actual solar systems are not randomly sized with the apparent uniformity coming from detector bias.
(There could, of course, be a third factor where planets are randomly sized but the measured bias comes from something else.)
- Eyght 8y agoAnother possibility is intergalactic bar billiards[1] [1] https://sites.google.com/site/h2g2theguide/Index/i/540914 https://sites.google.com/site/h2g2theguide/Index/i/540914
- majia 8y ago2. Simulated what the detector would have reported for each. I think this would be really hard. For example, you need to simulate how the detector responds to different planet compositions, different signal to noise ratios at different distances from the star. A sphere in vacuum model may be a gross simplification.
- Sharlin 8y agoWell, we already deduce exoplanets' masses, orbits, diameters, and so on from the sensor data that basically amounts to a tiny change in the light curve of the star. The astronomers are probably pretty well aware of the limitations of their models and potential confounders.
- gmjoe 8y agoHow would the composition of a planet affect how much light it blocked of its star when passing in front? And signal to noise ratios are presumably quite easy to simulate. So not really sure what's so hard about it.
- captaincrowbar 8y agoComposition determines density. A rocky planet would block less light than a gas giant planet of the same mass, because it would be denser and therefore smaller.
- gmjoe 8y agoBut does density have to do with anything Kepler measures? Since it only measures how much light decreases, I assumed it's only measuring planet size, and that we're totally ignorant about planet mass and density?