4 ms·
There are now 5 million visitors a year. So it's not really shocking that more "mainstream" stuff does better these days than it might have done back in the day
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
There are now 5 million visitors a year. So it's not really shocking that more "mainstream" stuff does better these days than it might have done back in the day.
I tend to feel like I have no idea whatsoever what will do well here. I sometimes decline to post some article because I think it's not HN worthy, only to see it on the front page later.
I sometimes get accused of posting political pieces when, to my mind, they are interesting for sociological reasons. I certainly don't post things to promote any kind of political agenda per se.
I also didn't notice the things you are specifically commenting on. I recall different details from the front page. So there's possibly a certain amount of "You just happened to see X for some reason." which isn't conclusive proof of objective fact.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoYeah, HackerNews seems to be getting closer to Reddit by the day.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI don't know what you mean by that. I participate on Reddit. I experience HN and Reddit as completely different animals. I see them as very extremely an apples to oranges comparison.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoPerhaps my comment was the prime example ]= What I meant is: Three years ago, HackerNews seemed (to me) to be a forum for intellectuals to discuss things business/tech-y. Opinions were mostly well thought out. When they weren't, they were challenged (thanks for calling me out [= ). Now it just seems like the break-room banter. A lot of sensationalist articles seem to make the front page. A lot of purely comedic comments (which I do appreciate). A lot more unfounded anecdotes. A lot of promotional posts, etc. Also -- and I'm admittedly putting on my tin hat here -- I've seen a lot of discussions that seem like they're just troll accounts trying to further polarize the community. Maybe I'm part of the problem ]=
- DoreenMichele 8y agoHacker News is a single entity. Reddit is a conglomeration of sub forums, each with their own interests, rules and moderators. Reddit is a very cosmopolitan environment. It's like a big city, where you can participate in different social groups and there can be overlap in members, but it isn't guaranteed. Your behavior on one sub forum can impact your reputation on another, but it isn't the same as a situation where you deal with the same moderators and same group of people all the time for everything. I don't hang on "the front page" of Reddit. I have a few niche interests I dabble in a bit over there. I occasionally consider writing a blog post to talk about some of the differences between forums of various formats that I've experienced. It's more than I care to try to catalog in a comment here. But when you say "HN is like Reddit," that doesn't even parse for me. Because it's like "So, exactly what part of Reddit are you comparing it to?" It strikes me as a six blind men and the elephant scenario.
- dang 8y ago> Three years ago, HackerNews seemed (to me) to be a forum for intellectuals to discuss things business/tech-y. Had you read the site guidelines then (or now!) you'd know that the very first thing they say is that HN is about more than this. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sbov 8y agoIt really depends on the topic. Certain topics get very tribal, and generally the snarkiest, least useful comments float to the top.
- dang 8y agoPeople have been saying this literally since HN started. In fact the HN guidelines used to include a line asking people not to post about it ("it's a semi-noob illusion"). We removed that guideline for brevity a while ago, but maybe we should bring it back.
- kbenson 8y ago> I sometimes get accused of posting political pieces when, to my mind, they are interesting for sociological reasons. As politics has become more contentious in recent years, both parties have staked out more and more things as "theirs", which promotes people seeing information that is for or against (or even just about, and confirmation bias does the rest) one of these areas as being political. There's likely also an increased number of political articles as well, which contributes it's own little bit.
- hunta2097 8y agoHacker News' evolution feels a lot like Slashdot's, which also had it's roots in hardcore tech. I hope it doesn't impact the content or discussion too much.
- dang 8y agoThis perception has also been around forever: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6157485 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6157485. Presumably it's a mirage, since "turning into Slashdot/Digg/Reddit" would hardly have been a steady state.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWell, I posted a tweet recently about the difficulties facing (some?) Native Americans in registering to vote. I hesitated to post it knowing it was clearly a political subject. But my interest was in how it was a kind of "bug" in the political system. Most likely, the two things were not specifically intended to disenfranchise Native voters. Neither taken alone is malicious. Taken together, the outcome is de facto disenfranchisement. I'm very slightly Cherokee. I've begun following more Native American twitter accounts and I started a new blog to explore my Native heritage a bit. I've posted a number of items about Native issues because that's something I happen to be reading here lately. There's no political agenda there, though I keep waiting to be accused of such. I post things I happen to trip across. HN can upvote or flag (or just ignore) as it sees fit. I've largely given up on predicting what works here. I have essentially zero ability to do that.
- galaxyLogic 8y ago> I certainly don't post things to promote any kind of political agenda per se. Posting factual and informative articles is promoting a certain kind of political agenda, truth-based.
- geofft 8y agoThat's a nice-sounding claim but "truth" isn't a coherent agenda. There are many things that are true, and a finite life; which true things are worth paying attention to? Five hundred star-bellies Sneetches and five hundred plain-bellied Sneetches died in combat yesterday; reading just the obituaries of the heroic star-bellied Sneetches and how they gave their lives for peace is truth-based, but it's a very different agenda from the equally-truth-based approach of reading the obituaries of the martyred plain-bellied Sneetches and how they sacrificed everything for their people's freedom.
- galaxyLogic 8y agoIt's not truth-based if it omits different relevant claims. Naturally there is no such thing as absolute truth but there is a choice of whether more truthful should be of primary concern or not. Saying that truth doesn't matter because "everybody has their own truth" is a political agenda whose purpose is to make people believe any "truth" is as good as any other and therefore we should not even try to look for evidence.
- dang 8y agoHN has 5M visitors a month. Well, 4.5M at present. It fluctuates some.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThanks. I didn't bother to qualify the remark, though I figured it was likely outdated or inaccurate info. Glad to see better data posted here.