58 ms·
I'm embarrassed by the lack of comprehension people have for the idea of the OSI saying something isn't open source. The OSI has been around for a long time, ha
by unethical_ban 8y ago
I'm embarrassed by the lack of comprehension people have for the idea of the OSI saying something isn't open source. The OSI has been around for a long time, has a consistent track record of helping organize FOSS licenses and create a framework/lexicon for this very purpose. They absolutely have the right to say if something is open source or not, according to their rules, just like anyone here gets to make their opinion heard on something. "Appeals to authority" make sense when the authority is credible, and shortcuts having to explain the four freedoms, etc.
---
To the article: It sounds like the SSPL will eventually be OSI-OSS, but I wonder if they couldn't have worked with GNU to create a new version of the AGPL. Granted, GNU might take exception to the idea of "oka you don't have to share the code, you just have to pay us" portion.
- gfosco 8y agoI think it's more about the tone and the caps lock, than the exact words, although you shouldn't be embarrassed if some people disagree and think the phrase has been generalized. If anything, I think it might be embarrassing how many "defenders" jumped in and prolonged this drama, instead of just downvoting and moving on with their day. How's this for a conundrum: I support the OSI being able to claim it isn't "open source" according to them, but I think the top-level post by the VP was unprofessional and rightly called out. (I have not commented elsewhere in this thread.)