3 ms·
I'll be honest the downvotes confuse me. HN has a very prevalent habit of whenever something is posted - a newsworthy item, a new startup, or whatever - many of
by pc86 8y ago
I'll be honest the downvotes confuse me. HN has a very prevalent habit of whenever something is posted - a newsworthy item, a new startup, or whatever - many of the top-level comments are people just listing off things that may be tangentially related. Especially if the article is about some obscure tool or product you'll fine a dozen top-level comments just linking to other obscure tools or products in the same niche, or completely unrelated ones with the same homepage design, or completely unrelated ones that use the same tech stack, or something to that effect.
The article is about Myanmar so unless there is something interesting about the fact that Russia is doing sort-of-the-same-thing-but-not-really things, it's not really relevant, is it?
- addicted 8y agoI’ve drastically reduced my wandering into HN comments precisely because of this. Someone posts a Show HN about something they’ve worked on, and the top comment is usually something that is mildly related but completely tangential to the actual posting. It should be easy enough to ignore, but it has been happening so often I’ve started having a visceral negative reaction that makes me not want to even open the comments anymore. Which is disappointing because the HN comments are usually a treasure trove of information.
- viraptor 8y ago> many of the top-level comments are people just listing off things that may be tangentially related. That's half the reason I come to HN :-) > The article is about Myanmar Is it? I read it as an article about the role of social networks in spreading information about groups of people via channels that collect diverse viewers. Essentially what happens when you gather random people on the street and shout something polarising. The specific case of it this time is Myanmar and FB, but I'd like to understand more about it as a general phenomenon. The link was interesting because it shows an example of news reporting leading to that situation and links to interesting papers in references.
- imgabe 8y agoThe point is that this is not unique to Myanmar or to Facebook, so the calls to "solve" this problem by censoring Facebook as many would suggest would be ineffective.