6 ms·
It's simple. They cannot allow any ideology to subvert the party (CCP) ideology. They don't hate religion for the sake of hating religion. They don't hate FG
by mc32 8y ago
It's simple. They cannot allow any ideology to subvert the party (CCP) ideology. They don't hate religion for the sake of hating religion. They don't hate FG/FD, Christians or Muslims (or Buddhists for that matter) for being who they are. They do hate and will remove anything which may subvert the supremacy of the state. Simple as that.
- torgian 8y agoYeah this is pretty on point. They don’t hate the religions, they just want to minimize any gatherings that could potentially set off a movement to up-end the current rule. Funny thing is, a lot of students that I teach here talk about how they feel like they will have more freedoms in twenty years than they do now. I’m doubtful. People are happy where they’re at right now. As long as that continues, China will do what China does. I’m actually more surprised nothing has happened back in the States yet
- colechristensen 8y ago>People are happy where they’re at right now. Are they though?
- mc32 8y agoThey have experienced unrelenting growth for over 30 years and counting. Greatly improving their lives along the way. They are in a better place than ever before. Of course they are happy. More than anything, Chinese are pragmatic. will that continue into the future as the population ages? Remains to be seen.
- thisgoodlife 8y agoGDP annual growth rate in China averaged 9.6% for the last 30 years. So I guess they have a reason to be happy.
- colechristensen 8y agoI am not trying to convince anybody to be unhappy, but I have my doubts that GDP really has a lot to do with it one way or the other.
- dagss 8y agoGDP is not just a number you know. If one were previously hungry and cold and are now well fed and comfortable, of course that affects happiness. Why do you doubt that?
- mc32 8y agoAs Bill Clinton strategist Jim Carville once said, "it's the economy, [----]".
- Apocryphon 8y agoThe U.S. GDP has increased greatly since 2008, and yet there is widespread discontent in America.
- close04 8y agoWealth only really matters to the point where you can support a good living. That "good" will vary but beyond that increases in wealth bring diminished returns. Think about a salary: if it's below a threshold you are unhappy no matter what. Above that any raise brings more marginal increases in satisfaction, you start looking at other things for that. The US is past that point so now it needs more than wealth.
- yourbandsucks 8y ago.. that statement doesn't really have a lot to do with how things are/were in China. Americans don't even know what real poverty looks like.
- saiya-jin 8y agoGDP can be one marker for 'things are improving'. Of course it isn't the full picture - when you are living in increasingly restrictive state monitoring you against your own will, you feel the government is bunch of idiots, jobs have been shifting away and so on and on, people are not that happy. Rich are getting richer, poor poorer. If you are 2 joints away from serving prison sentence and having your life ruined for good (maybe less relevant these days). Losing 'friends' around the world - 30 years ago, americans were heroes, WW2 saviors of the europe and the world, America was land of endless opportunities and most importantly - freedom. Now its the opposite - unlawful killing of somebody with tons of civilians with drones wherever they want, and in the same time being very friendly with horrible regimes like the one in Saudi Arabia because oil and money. Freedom and US ain't the same thing after 9/11. Plus on top of that workaholic US mindset, that weird attitude that your job defines who you are and whats your position in society. None of this can make masses happy, in contrary.
- jessriedel 8y agoMy anecdotal experience talking with Chinese nationals is that they basically approve of the government and would not choose to switch to democracy.
- marcv81 8y agoFor what it's worth my anecdotal experience is exactly the opposite. Sample size = 4 people.
- echevil 8y agoYes they are. Especially younger generations in China nowadays are much more likely to be pro-Chinese government and less agreeing to western values. Plenty of young students who came to study in America for a few years also have a tendency now to become more agreeable with Chinese government
- bliblah 8y agoPeople who have never seen the grass on the other side can't make a judgement as to whether it is greener. I have visited countries where personal freedoms are curtailed but the general population had food, water, shelter and luxuries so they were content. It is only the moment they realize that those things are in danger or they covet what other nations have that problems arise. You can't miss what you never lost.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 8y agoYep. For example see what they have done to the peaceful Falun Dafa practitioners after they showed up in large numbers. This almost makes me think of mind viruses duking it out using expendable hosts - and studying it epidemiologically.
- epynonymous 8y agofunny, recently in hk i saw an anti-flg next to a flg advocate.
- epynonymous 8y agoyes, the ccp does not discriminate.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoDoes this view have to be contrasted as being primarily about persistence of the state? Consider social media for a minute as an increasingly appropriate metaphor for religion. Instead of uniting people, social media has mostly driven people into various ideological echo chambers. And these echo chambers tend to engage in typical cult-like in-group out-group behavior behavior, aggression towards perceived ideological enemies, ousting of followers whose faith wains, etc. And as these groups begin to interweave with politics, it's driving a major wedge in society. The point of this is that since we live in a society that values freedom above all, it makes sense that we allow these sort of organizations and associations. At the same time, I think it's increasingly difficult to argue that things from religion to facebook to twitter are having a net positive impact on society. In times when we were more homogeneous, this was different. When most of everybody holds a common and shared identity, there is no real out-group, and the identity can help create unity and unitedness. But as we become more diverse, the lack of a shared identity means we end up splintering off into a variety of large ideological cliques which view themselves as mutually incompatible (even if that's not necessarily entirely true). And that causes a lot of problems. And so if we had a governmental system that was based more about utilitarianism, rather than ours which is based more on the fundamental value of freedom, it seems to be logical to work to prohibit these sort of things - even with 0 consideration given to the fate of the state itself.
- bencollier49 8y agoWe're not becoming more diverse, what is largely happening is that communications and transport technologies have made geography irrelevant. Now your cultural opposite may live next door, rather than in another city or country. This has led to the degradation of real community; you could equally argue that transport is the issue. The point is that if you enable people to maintain cultural identies across geographical boundaries, you will cause the breakdown of local solidarity. To argue that we must therefore develop some sort of bland global monoculture is as terrifying as it is depressing.
- thecopy 8y agoThey want the communist party to be the primarly religion. Just like in the Soviet states where religion were systematically eliminated in favor of state religion[1]: > USSR became the first state to have as one objective of its official ideology the elimination of existing religion, and the prevention of future implanting of religious belief, with the goal of establishing state atheism (gosateizm). 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_Soviet_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_Soviet_Union
- reitanqild 8y agoSeems very similar to the reign of terror during the French Revolution though?
- thecopy 8y agoWhats your point?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> They want the communist party to be the primarly religion. They are quite satisfied with religion that supports the Communist Party; like earlier Communists they see religion subservient to the elite as the opiate of the masses in capitalist society, and have very much included that among the elements of capitalism that they have reintroduced. OTOH, they are extremely concerned that the churches remain subservient to the existing elite, reinforcing its rule, since otherwise they would simply by existing challenge it.
- beerlord 8y agoI think its also partly to take the attention away from their Uighur camps, and to paint the idea that they are 'anti-religion', rather than explicitly seeking to rid Uighur culture and religion from China.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- singularity2001 8y agoThe might underestimate the backlash of 4 billion Muslims and Christians being unitedly antagonized by such transgressions.
- candiodari 8y agoThey dealt with the "cultural revolution". I don't think they are currently afraid of losing control to religion.
- dragonwriter 8y agoIf they weren't afraid of exactly that, there would be no reason for the crackdown.
- torgian 8y ago4 billion muslims and christians don't live in China.
- singularity2001 8y agothey can still be antagonized and act on that