3 ms·
I said a good case could be made for expanding the Court, not for packing the Court. For example, Congress could pass an expansion plan that adds a new Justice
by tzs 8y ago
I said a good case could be made for expanding the Court, not for packing the Court. For example, Congress could pass an expansion plan that adds a new Justice every 4 years until the new size is reached.
As far as prompting a civil war goes, we had a minority party use filibusters for years to block most judicial appointments of the majority party from even getting considered, with the intent of holding them open until they could get a majority. That same party also held a Supreme Court seat open for a year, refusing to even hold a hearing on the nominee--a nominee that they had just told the President was someone they could approve of! (And they openly talked of holding the seat open during the entire term of the next President if that President was not of their party).
And now that the aforementioned minority party has a majority in Congress, they are rapidly filling all those seats they held open, often with young lawyers with little judicial experience, and some rated "unqualified" by the ABA, and accuse anyone who tries to actually vet the candidates of partisan obstructionism.
If that didn't get anyone up in arms, I doubt a little court packing would do so.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoIf the Democrats gain control of the Senate and the White House, and they expand the Supreme Court, it will almost certainly be "packing" and not "just expanding".
- dctoedt 8y agoGorsuch occupies a stolen seat but realistically can't be removed. So a tenth justice would neutralize him, and an eleventh justice would restore things to the way they would have been were it not for McConnell's despicable obstruction with Garland (for which he should be expelled from the Senate, but I know that will never happen).
- tptacek 8y ago"Stolen"? (I would, I hope obviously, prefer Garland to Gorsuch.)
- dctoedt 8y agoYes, stolen — McConnell's refusal to put the matter to a vote, in the hope of holding out for a GOP president, was a gross subversion of the implicit constitutional norm that when a president officially nominates someone, it's the Senate's duty to render an up-or-down vote. That was one of the many, many reasons I finally left the GOP this year after being a Republican since age 9 (I got in trouble for putting a Goldwater sticker on my parents' car).
- tptacek 8y agoWhat's the difference between a "down" vote and a refusal to let it out of committee? Doesn't this just mirror the cloture drama from a few years back? Also: again, aren't Senate rules delegated specifically to the Senate in the Constitution, and subject to no external oversight? It seems pretty clear that the Senate has the authority to blockade nominations. By contrast, the Constitution is clear about duties and timelines elsewhere (for instance, bill vetoes). There's lots of good reasons to leave the GOP! I'm glad you did! I just don't see this as one of them.
- dctoedt 8y agoBlocking an up-or-down confirmation vote strips away the only actual oversight we have under the Constitution, namely the prospect of uncomfortable publicizing of a senator's voting record during his or her next reelection bid — or when s/he runs for president. (I read once that whenever any senator looks in the mirror, s/he sees a future president.)
- tptacek 8y agoIs this really a materially relevant argument? Does anyone have any illusions on where any of the 2016 GOP Senators stood on Garland? They all effectively cast a "no" vote. There's nobody in the country who thinks otherwise. Even The Daily Caller wouldn't put that argument forward. So what's the harm to the Constitution? Bills have been not-getting-out-of-committee for a very long time prior to the McConnell blockade, and you can easily make an argument that killing things in committee is actually more harmful to transparency than what McConnell did --- whatever else you might say about the blockade, it was pretty transparent!