6 ms·
> I don't see it. I could see the Democrats impeaching five Supreme Court justices, or the Republicans impeaching four. All nine being impeached? I really have
by tzs 8y ago
> I don't see it. I could see the Democrats impeaching five Supreme Court justices, or the Republicans impeaching four. All nine being impeached? I really have a hard time seeing that happening.
More likely than impeachment would be expanding the court. The Constitution doesn't say anything about the size of the Court other than it must have a Chief Justice. The number of Justices is set by legislation.
A very good case can be made for such an expansion to slow down the amount the Court can change in the short term. 9 worked fine when both parties had strong moderate factions, and so the Court would move a little more conservative under Republicans and a little more Liberal under Democrats. Now the moderate factions have diminished, especially among Republicans, and 9 doesn't provide enough hysteresis.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> A very good case can be made for such an expansion to slow down the amount the Court can change in the short term. No, it can't, at least in terms of a normal legislated expansion, because the immediate effect would be to vastly accelerate the change in the direction of the then-dominant party. Also, a larger court (even beyond the one-time transition) doesn't provide any more stability on average, though it does reduce the variability in the rate of change (doubling the size of the court doesn't change the percent of the court that changes, on average, each Presidential term. But it makes the standard deviation of that percentage less.)
- tzs 8y agoI think reducing the variability does lead to more stability on average. It makes it more likely that a President and the next President appoint the same or nearly the same number of Justices, and so that when the Presidents are from different parties they counter each other. Also, I suspect that on a significantly larger court Justices would be more likely to retire younger, because they would know that their leaving is not going to cause major changes even if they leave during the term of a President they disagree with.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoFirst: If one side decides to expand the court, I'm pretty sure that "hysteresis" won't be the reason. "We want our side to have more influence" will be the (unstated) reason. Second, though, I'm not sure that you'd get more hysteresis. Let's say that, with a nine-member court, a two-term president is likely to get to appoint two or three justices. Now expand the court to fifteen members, as one side has suggested. Well, now a two-term president is likely to get to appoint four or five justices. I don't think that changes the hysteresis at all.
- meepmorp 8y agoExpanding the SC would be a terrible idea. Apart from the nakedly partisan optics, it guarantees that the other party would just put more justices on the bench when they have a chance. In theory, maybe, it makes sense. Practically, it’s a bad idea.
- kevinh 8y ago> it guarantees that the other party would just put more justices on the bench when they have a chance. This seems like a better situation for Democrats than it is currently (not having a majority at all for 30+ years).
- wanderer2323 8y agoCatalyzing the breakdown of the government institutions -- because that is what the court-packing for the reason of 'we have lost the majority' will be -- should not be 'a better situation' for anyone. We're already at the stage where the unwritten decorum rules surrounding the political process are ignored or dismantled by both parties. With the side not in power already openly advocating politically-motivated violence against another and threatening to withhold civility until they are given the power back, US is on the course to its own 'Stop quoting laws to us who have swords' moment -- whatever form that will take in 21st century.
- rayiner 8y agoThe fact that people are actively talking about court packing, much less saying a "very good case can be made for" it blows my mind. I would not be surprised to see a civil war within my lifetime if that happens.
- mattnewton 8y agoI thought the same about Merrick Garland’s “process”. Everyone’s realizing the rules are just social conventions and everyone thinks their side is justified in breaking them this one time.
- tptacek 8y agoPeople say this all the time about Garland, but I'm as Democrat as anyone on this board (as the FEC site will ruefully attest this cycle) and I just kind of don't care. The Garland thing was by-the-book. The Republicans held the Senate. Obama couldn't get the votes to appoint. It's not like the Constitution is fuzzy about what happens when that happens. Blocking all Supreme Court nominations was just good tactics. It is certainly one among many decisive factors that won the GOP the White House.
- tzs 8y agoWas it by the book? The Constitution says that the President nominates and by and with the "Advice and Consent" of the Senate appoints Justices. Is refusing to even consider a nominee providing "Advice and Consent"? They could have blocked all Supreme Court nominations while at least maintaining the appearance of doing their job by holding hearings, bringing them to a vote, and defeating them on the floor.
- tptacek 8y agoWhy wouldn't it be? Has the meaning of "consent" changed since the time of the framers? Obama proposes a nominee, the Senate majority refuses consent. Lather and repeat. Would that not have been foreseeable to Madison and Adams? The whole "hearings" thing just seems like theater. Nobody on either political pole had any misconception about what was happening.
- forapurpose 8y ago> A very good case can be made for such an expansion to slow down the amount the Court can change in the short term. Very interesting. Also, for context: In the 1930s Franklin Roosevelt advocated expanding the Supreme Court when it kept interfering with his New Deal plans.