6 ms·
I'd prefer to see a bit more of a break up at the low-end of the scale. > "18 experienced unwanted sexual overtures or sexual badgering" Badgering is beyond t
by roenxi 8y ago
I'd prefer to see a bit more of a break up at the low-end of the scale.
> "18 experienced unwanted sexual overtures or sexual badgering"
Badgering is beyond the pale, "unwanted sexual overtures" are unwelcome but I don't see how they are ever going away; if men don't make a first sexual overture there aren't going to be a lot of men who end up having sex. Some of those overtures are going to be unwanted, but the men basically have to try to find out.
Things like Tinder where you can filter for "interested only" are pretty much a new phenomenon and havn't really had time to influence the culture of anyone aged over 30.
Anyway, I'd like to know how persistent these "unwanted sexual overture" is before it is reported in the survey as harassment. Minor point in a larger picture.
- sgarman 8y agoEven if I did agree with your core argument (I don't) how is a VC meeting the appropriate time and place for that?
- glangdale 8y agoUmmmn, you appear to have missed the bit where this "unwanted sexual overture" was put in context i.e. "one or more inappropriate incidents by angels or VCs" Here's an amazingly novel idea: maybe angels and VCs who are lonely should have social lives where they can make sexual overtures? Making sexual overtures in a professional context where you hold a position of power (i.e. you are a angel/VC and you're making overtures to a female founder) is grossly unprofessional regardless of whether they are persistent.
- BigJono 8y agoHere's a novel idea. Most founders work long hours. Their work is their life (for the most part). I wasn't aware you had to take a vow of celibacy to start a company... Also 'inappropriate incidents' is completely undefined.
- rainonmoon 8y agoThat seems like a problem with the culture that women shouldn't have to bear the consequences of.
- manfredo 8y agoInterestingly, when my company proposed banning all workplace relationships (as opposed to only those between team members and superiors in the reporting chain) the biggest pushback was from women.
- Falling3 8y agoThat's likely because banning consensual relationships is a incredibly poor attempt at fighting sexual harassment.
- manfredo 8y agoAllowing workplace romances inherently entails romantic advances between coworkers (some, or all of which constitute harassment depending on your views on the acceptability of asking out coworkers). If women are put off by these advances (as stated in the original comment to which I replied) one would expect that women would be more interested in halting this. But interestingly, women at my company seem to value the chance at making relationships with coworkers more than stopping advances from coworkers.
- RobLach 8y agoAre you suggesting founders are required to treat professional events as places of business as well as the sole venue for finding a potential partner/lover because they'll have no chance otherwise? That's silly. Working long hours doesn't immediately excuse you from adhering to social contexts, especially when there are obvious power structures present which evidently is rampantly abusive across industries. 'Innappropriate incidents' is entirely subjective and can't be defined beyond a personal context. If one party believes the manner in which someone else operates in a context is inappropriate, that's enough of a definition, especially in the context of such a survey.
- manfredo 8y ago> Ummmn, you appear to have missed the bit where this "unwanted sexual overture" was put in context i.e. "one or more inappropriate incidents by angels or VCs" I think you're missing the point here. How did the survey define which unwanted sexual overtures are inappropriate? You write that this was put in the context of harassment, but how this context was presented to the respondents has a big impact on what their responses really mean. At face value, it seems like the study considers all romantic advances to be inappropriate. This seems like an overly simplistic definition, as per my example here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18225474 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18225474 Asking for further context is entirely warranted. Studies like these can often be made (intentionally or unintentionally) to seem alarmist due to poorly defining categories of harassment. For instance, I was counted as a victim of sexual assault in one of my university's surveys because I answered yes to the question "have you received unwanted sexual advances in the last year?". Yes I had, but all of them were from people who ceased their advances after being denied and generally acted with respect. While there's always some element of discomfort in being put on the spot like that, I would absolutely not consider any of these instances harassment in any way shape or form. Asking someone out on a date or inviting them over for intimate contact, and ceasing all advances after being denied was considered an act of sexual harassment by this survey. I'm not kidding, if someone asked a person out respectfully, they got told no, and both parties walked away with no further contact this was considered sexual harassment. This also disturbed me because it not-so-subtly implied that I had harassed literally every person I had asked out on a date and was denied, even though I've never continued pursuing someone after being told no.
- glangdale 8y agoI think you're just making stuff up. Have fun!
- manfredo 8y agoIt was explicit from the results that responding "yes" to this question was considered sexual assault. After the results were published they provided the breakdowns of responses. They included "yes" responses of this question as part of the student population that had been subject to sexual assault. I had talked to other students about it, and while many told me that they interpreted the question along the lines of "have you ever received unwanted advances after being told to stop" that emphasis was not part of the original question. If someone truthfully answered the question that was asked, they would have to answer "yes" even if they declined a respectful invitation to go out.
- Swizec 8y ago> Some of those overtures are going to be unwanted, but the men basically have to try to find out. Sexual overtures at a bar: okay. Sexual overtures at a sex party: very okay. Sexual overtures at a house party: prob okay. Sexual overtures at a grocery store: eeeeh maybe if you're really hot and she gives you the look. Sexual overtures at the office: very not okay Sexual overtures at a VC event: way not cool. Sexual overtures at an office party: not good. Sexual overtures at an official after-party of a business event: nope. Sexual overtures at the after after party with those 10 people who wanted to party some more after a business event after party: depends, read the room. It's about context. Don't be a creep.
- abstractbeliefs 8y agoI'm really glad someone has identified that it's about context and each instance should be judged on a case-by-case basis. I'm equally surprised that at the same time, it comes with a list of pre-judged decisions where you have removed the context in favour of just the title of the event. There are absolutely situations in bars and house parties where one should not make any kind of move. Likewise, there are office parties where one could. Before I get to the next bit, it's important to realise and understand that "no" really does mean no. With that in mind, it's also true that there are men and women who say "no", but still mean yes. This is one small facet of that whole debate, but the point is subtleties matter. People saying "no" when they mean yes is still a real thing, like it or not, and some people have a hard time differentiating when this is the case. There are also people who of course don't care, but they are far less controversial. What we need to do is all pull together to work to clarify how we communicate interest in each other. And that means all people, of all sexes and genders and orientations and class.
- Swizec 8y ago> I'm equally surprised that at the same time, it comes with a list of pre-judged decisions where you have removed the context in favour of just the title of the event. I believe some situations require more assurance of “it’s okay” than others. In the office, I’d have to be super very absolutely certain it’s okay before saying anything. At a singles event in a bar I might lead with a sexual overtone and see what happens. And no always means no. Once you say no I say sorry and move on. Although I do like the policy of a sex club I was at once: If you do anything you have to apologize for, you are banned from the club for forever. More venues should adopt that policy.
- danharaj 8y agoDo you understand how repugnant you sound implying that some men need to use businesswomen as captive audience for their sex drives or they won't get sex? Let me remind you that a work setting is nothing like Tinder, nothing like a bar, nothing like any place where trying to get laid is considered OK. You wouldn't ask someone if they wanted to shag at a funeral, would you?
- roenxi 8y ago> Do you understand how repugnant you sound implying that some men need to use businesswomen as captive audience for their sex drives or they won't get sex? No, I'm implying there is a very high background rate of men asking women for sex, and I havn't compared this instance to the background but I assume women get propositioned at a very high rate _wherever_ they are. > Let me remind you that a work setting is nothing like Tinder, nothing like a bar, nothing like any place where trying to get laid is considered OK. My parents met in the workplace. I have a friends who have too. I havn't looked up the statistics but I assume it is double-digit percentages of marriages start as workplace relations. It is unfortunate if you think that isn't acceptable, because it clearly is. > You wouldn't ask someone if they wanted to shag at a funeral, would you? I wouldn't, but I don't see why it would be unacceptable. There are a lot of people at funerals who are't particularly committed to grieving but making a statement of social support, and they'd just be there doing what they do at any social event.
- dbt00 8y ago> My parents met in the workplace. I have a friends who have too. I havn't looked up the statistics but I assume it is double-digit percentages of marriages start as workplace relations. It is unfortunate if you think that isn't acceptable, because it clearly is. Conflating financial power relationship dynamics with garden variety workplace romance is some serious moving of goalposts. Seriously, one of the major reforms in venture capital in the last 25 years has been to reduce the amount of power tripping that goes on between VCs and founders. That's the idea that YC is founded on. This is another example, and an incredibly shitty one. Why defend it?
- valtism 8y agoI am floored at how you can miss how the context of these advances make it abhorrent.
- manfredo 8y agoHow could they make that judgement when no context about the advances were provided? Say I sought VC funding, and met a single investor. In the end, I decide to accept funding from another firm. Afterwards said single investor congratulates me on getting funded and asks me out on a date now that we no longer have a conflict of interest. I decline because I'm not interested in this investor. Did I receive an unwanted romantic advance from an investor? Absolutely. I was asked out on a date when I didn't want one. But was I harassed? It seems dubious to say so. At the time of the advance I had no business relationship with this investor. If the questionnaire specifically said unwanted advances _during_ the search for funding that would be a different situation. But that context isn't given, hence the confusion.
- sgustard 8y agoAll of the reported incidents were "unwanted sexual contact" or "sexual coercion" or "sexual badgering." I would propose that asking someone on a date should be considered none of those things, unless you're doing it wrong.
- manfredo 8y agoThe exact phrase was, "experienced unwanted sexual overtures", not "unwanted sexual contact". If we consider asking someone out on a date to be a sexual overture, then asking someone out on a date and they decline is indeed an instance of "unwanted sexual overtures". Someone made a sexual overture, and it was not wanted. Since YC has not provided how these terms were defined in the questionnaire, we're left to speculate - hence the confusion and contention exhibited in this thread.
- brenschluss 8y agoThe fact that a legalistic definition is required for you to understand how an unprofessional gesture is perceived by women is striking. Do you think it would be helpful to have a rule book for men that exactly stipulates what kind of interactions with women are professional, respectful, and friendly? Are men that stupid? (I’m saying this as a man myself).
- paulie_a 8y ago> if men don't make a first sexual overture there aren't going to be a lot of men who end up having sex This line of thinking makes it more difficult for actually decent guys to get a first date. By the way, women like sex too and will make those overtures. If you haven't had a first date with a person, keep the overtures off.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> if men don't make a first sexual overture there aren't going to be a lot of men who end up having sex There are plenty of contexts in which men can make first sexual overtures other than investor/founder business (or similar economic power relations.) > Things like Tinder where you can filter for "interested only" are pretty much a new phenomenon Things like a brain where you can filter for “am I in an economic or other power relationship where a sexual overture is inherently implicitly coercive even if it is not explicitly coercive” are, however, not new, though apparently vastly underused. Well, maybe not underused. Misused is probably more accurate; leverage rather than ignorance of the power dynamic seems common.
- itronitron 8y agothe power asymmetry makes this a non-starter, not even romantic overtures are okay (which are the overtures that typical mortals usually make)
- pentae 8y agoAlso, as far as successful mating/reproduction strategy goes, an attractive female partner who is also a founder of a tech startup would be pretty high on the list. I wonder if we flipped this survey on it's head and asked how many women would be interested in being with a partner who has founded a successful tech startup what the results would be?
- rmc 8y agoMaking sexual overtures, in a bar, or on a Tinder date is one thing. In the workplace? From someone who can make or break your company?