4 ms·
> "Race alone is never the reason a student is granted admission," Lee said. "And race is never the reason a student is denied." > He downplayed the influence
by oh_sigh 8y ago
> "Race alone is never the reason a student is granted admission," Lee said. "And race is never the reason a student is denied."
> He downplayed the influence of any single numerical rating, saying the final decision comes down to a 40-person committee that spends weeks reviewing and discussing applications.
I love how Harvard's defense is "We aren't 100% racist, we're only a little racist, but for good!"
- akhilcacharya 8y agoYour problem appears to be holistic admission in general. And to that, ok, I do agree and it's not consistent or deterministic by design. But the idea that people should get so mad about this that they sue and raise a fit is silly. There are two competing implicit narratives here - 1) The school you go to doesn't matter and you should do the best where-ever you are (I personally heard this quite a bit). 2) You will be irreparably harmed for life because you didn't get into School N instead of School N - 1. Which is it?
- solveit 8y agoThe problem isn't holistic admission, the problem is that Harvard is using the cover of holistic admission to black-box the admissions process so nobody can prove what shenanigans are actually going on. That only works until somebody does a simple regression, but most people don't understand regressions or any sort of statistics at all.
- sincerely 8y agoWait, where are those narratives coming from the same person?
- akhilcacharya 8y agoSometimes, yes! But I've heard both repeatedly! It is absolutely maddening.
- johntb86 8y agoI doubt that Harvard would be excited about arguing in favor of 1).
- yhoneycomb 8y agoIt's infuriating because it's racist, not because it's any one school in particular
- olalonde 8y agoThat's what affirmative action basically is. The ideology behind it is that we, as a society, need to compensate for systemic racism that existed in the past. I'm also against the idea of discriminating based on skin color, regardless of intention, but it is what it is.
- forapurpose 8y ago> systemic racism that existed in the past ... and in the present.
- Harvard2018 8y ago>... and in the present. Yes. For example, Harvard is currently systematically discriminating against Asians.
- usaar333 8y agoIf Harvard was scoring Asians no worse than Whites, there would be less outrage. Instead, data is suggesting that Harvard actively is discriminating against Asians in favor of all other groups (including Whites). That is absolutely not justified by "systemic racism" of the past (esp. given that Asians also suffered systematic racism in the past)