10 ms·
The extraordinary influence of the Iliad and Odyssey
- steve_gh 8y agoCan I also recommend Adam Nicolson's "The Might Dead: Why Homer Matters", as an excellent read, which explains how and why Homer is still relevant today.
- natmaka 8y agoDominique Venner analysis: https://www.counter-currents.com/2010/09/homer-the-european-bible-part-1/ https://www.counter-currents.com/2010/09/homer-the-european-... TLDR; https://thegoldenone.se/2018/02/21/dominique-verner-epic-quote-on-the-iliad/ https://thegoldenone.se/2018/02/21/dominique-verner-epic-quo...
- stlee42 8y agonatmaka, are you aware that those websites preach racism? linked from 'about' page: https://www.counter-currents.com/2012/05/new-right-vs-old-right/ https://www.counter-currents.com/2012/05/new-right-vs-old-ri... quote: "Second, because of the leading role of the organized Jewish community in engineering the destruction of European peoples, and because the United States is the citadel of Jewish power in the world today, the North American New Right must deal straightforwardly with the Jewish Question." Holy shit. also, https://thegoldenone.se/2015/04/20/why-hitler-is-so-popular-and-why-we-need-new-role-models/ https://thegoldenone.se/2015/04/20/why-hitler-is-so-popular-...
- zero_intp 8y agoThose pages are filthy cesspits of depravity, "The true right rejects egalitarianism root and branch." Fuck these people
- natmaka 8y agoNo, I wasn't aware, nor do I share the opinions expressed in the documents you point to, but if I find a pertinent and interesting document I point towards it whatever the website publishes otherwise. Even if I knew I would have proposed this link to a document in my opinion pertinent and where I don't find any racism-preaching (this particular website/the Web/the universe all have their share of shit). I'm all for exposing and debunking dumb and dangerous doctrines instead of feigning not to know about them and letting some think that they have to be true because no one criticizes them, therefore I don't refrain to directly link to such material, while expressing at least that (and, better, why) I don't agree (as you just did). The author discussed in the documents I linked to is Dominique Venner. He wrote a book titled "Histoire et Tradition des Européens: 30 000 ans d'identité" which seems pertinent to me in this thread because it exposes a thesis about the relative importance in European cultures of Homer's literary work. Venner was considered far-right, I don't know he was nor if it extended to sheer racism and such fuckery, but it may explain why one may find many material from/about him on such websites but not much elsewhere as, IMHO sadly, censorship and ad hominem are far too common. Racism is as dumb and dangerous as censorship.
- zokessss 8y agoInterestingly, Indian culture is also heavily influenced by epic poems i.e. Mahabharata and Ramayana
- christudor 8y agoThese are essentially holy scripture in Hindu culture, aren’t they? The Bhagavid Gita is taken from the Mahabharata, for example...
- christudor 8y agoI wish reviewers would stop latching on to the concept of “relevance” when describing the merits of an ancient text. Such a strangely utilitarian way of thinking about literature, as if its value lies in what it can do for us today. Also, this seems to me to be utterly unfounded: “Which poem is better, the Iliad or the Odyssey? I don’t have hard numbers to back this up, but today it seems pretty clear that the Odyssey wins hands down in the mass popularity stakes.“
- jasode 8y ago>Also, this seems to me to be utterly unfounded: “Which poem is better, the Iliad or the Odyssey? I don’t have hard numbers to back this up, but today it seems pretty clear that the Odyssey wins hands down in the mass popularity stakes.“ The "which is better" is unanswerable but in terms of popularity, the evidence seems to show that The Odyssey is more well-known to today's readers. One reason is that many USA high schools use The Odyssey instead of the The Iliad in reading assignments. As for another datapoint to popularity, compare the number of ratings & reviews of The Odyssey (~760k) vs The Iliad (~305k) on Goodreads[1][2]. Similar popularity differences can be found on Amazon for other translations. The 2004 film Troy may have increased awareness of The Iliad but it still seems like The Odyssey is more popular. [1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1381.The_Odyssey https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1381.The_Odyssey [2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1371.The_Iliad https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1371.The_Iliad
- koboll 8y agoThe Odyssey is the archetype for an entire genre of "road trip" stories throughout history. It's also, more broadly, a key point of influence for many aspects of the Campbellian hero's journey. The Iliad simply hasn't exerted the same level of influence on storytelling.
- watwut 8y agoThe roadtrip part is smaller part of the Oddysey (maybe 30% definitely less then half), most of that is politics at home and getting control of the house. It is much different then other example of the narrative structure listed as examples of hero's journey.
- coldtea 8y ago>Paradoxically, in spite of its Christianization, the Byzantine Empire: ". . . saw to the transmission of the old authors. The classical tradition was thus maintained in Byzantium where, from 425 to 1453, the schools of Constantinople remained its pillars. This is why it is unsuitable to speak about the “Renaissance” in the Eastern Roman Empire. In the West, on the other hand, the rediscovery of Homer was a striking fact for the first Italian humanists." The Christianization of the Byzantines was not some crude "Old Testament as literal truth" kind of dogma, but a mix of New Testament ideas with neo-platonism and influences from ancient Greek thought. The early theologians (considered "saints") had all studied those philosophies and had extended knowledge of ancient Greek thought. Early Christianism was much more subtle than the crude version of Christianism post protestantism (protestantism itself being a fundamentalist movement, to go "back to roots" and back to the book, it's easy to understand why. It was a version of the religion for simple minded Germanic folk at the time that couldn't handle much subtlety). Homer, to get back to the point, was official reading in Byzantine school education. Worth noting, that unlike the western empire, that had the rule of the pope, the Byzantium had separate church and state.
- simonh 8y agoThe separation of church and state thing is arguable. I suppose when one of the titles of the Emperor is “Equal Of God”, that does make him somewhat immune from ecclesiastic authority.
- coldtea 8y agoThere was all kind of tension and power plays between the two kinds of authority. Titles don't reveal everything. Even popular revolts (especially helped by the army), for example, would often dispose of one emperor and get another in power. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3163118?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents https://www.jstor.org/stable/3163118?seq=1#page_scan_tab_con...
- azeotropic 8y agoThis is a really bizzare comment. The early Protestant reformers were all highly educated academics. Luther was a classically educated professor of theology. Calvin was a university educated lawyer who had published commentaries on Seneca (a Stoic philosopher). Philip Melanchthon was a university lecturer on oratory and Latin literature, and published a Greek grammar. It is a bit of a stretch to paint them as simple-minded Germanic folk (especially since Calvin was French). All of them were familiar with the theology of the early church fathers and appeal to it in their writings. While the pope had plenty of temporal power in the renaissance, it's certainly incorrect to say that any pope ruled anything that could be called the western empire before that. Instead of a strict separation of church and state, the Byzantine emperor Justinian appointed 3 successive popes after re-conquering Italy from the ostrogoths.
- frereubu 8y agoOne of my literary touchstones is "War Music", a re-telling or re-imagining of the Iliad by the British poet Christopher Logue. I've read a couple of translations, but this is the one that really set my head alight because he takes liberties with the content (including occasionally delicious anachronisms like "the thumping of helicopters overhead") without taking liberties with the story. It feels faithful to the original yet very modern in its expression. He was dedicated to performing poetry, and I think this comes out in the text - I found myself hearing the sounds of the words in my head as I read it.
- christudor 8y agoTotally agree with this. I think War Music is one of the greatest ‘translations’ of an ancient work ever written.
- netcan 8y agoI'm fascinated by old stories. Stories are the oldest medium, and they've proven to be surprisingly good stores of information. Erik the Red was real, and he navigated to lands across the ocean just like the old stories said he did. I think the writer sells short the comparison of Homer to the bible. It goes a lot deeper than "the one book everyone knows." Homer is often thought to be describing events during the bronze dark age, the period between the collapse of middle eastern bronze age empires and the rise of iron age empires (like the greek one). This is what the bible is too, to a large extent. The exodus, judges, King David, prophets, heros... Stories about the legendary dark age written by decendants during the early iron age. As civilization (and population) re-grew these stories formed a cultural core. Judeans got swept into the aramean, babylonian, persian and later hellenic empires. The library of knowledge grew enourmously. But, the old stories still remained at the heart of the cultural. Something similar happenned in greece. Greeks civilisation grew. greek scholarship got advanced, and worldly. They later created a world empire, existed under the roman empire. Still the stories remained, a stable foundation for more culture to graft onto. In both cases, we have stories from the bronze age, that somehow remained important enough for 100 generations to remain at the heart of cultures today. Stories of desert nomads and aegean pirates on the margins of civilisation.
- beaconstudios 8y agoperhaps because the messages they carry transcend time. Fundamentally many of the old stories we still value have moral or philosophical components that are foundational to our cultures.
- watwut 8y agoWhat does that mean, practically? For Odysseus for example, what foundational message does it have? I read it and it was interesting and even fun, I don't know what philosophical or moral component you have in mind. It had nuanced characters, but even that seems to be ignored by our popular culture which focuses exclusively on sirens and such.
- deleted 8y ago
- eruci 8y agoAt the same time we have an utterly boring/dogmatic salad of tales, such as the Bible and Quran, which remain important in the modern world - due to the still prevalent ignorant multitude. They would not mind if you desecrate the Iliad though. It belongs to a different audience.
- netcan 8y agoThat's a little harsh, perhaps. The legacy of be blical stories is far deeper tham dogma. The other day, i watched a (very sacreligious) cartoon (castlelvania e1). In it, Dracula's wife is burned at the stake for witchraft, by the church. On her way out, she calls out to dracula. "Forgive them! Don't take vengence. They don't know what you're doing." This is exactly what the author is talking about. The dogma isn't there. If the scene was boring or banal it wouldn't have been recreated in the cartoon. Still, its a reference everone gets, and the metaphor is extremely deep.
- Latteland 8y agoWell, in our modern world, we still face passionate denunciation of women and people hating on gays Etc because someone wrote something thousand of years ago. So it's okay though point out problems with these originalist documents.
- eruci 8y agoWe've become more civilized about biblical tales, but try making fun of the Quran and you'll get all these savages foaming at the mouth.
- ctrl-j 8y agoReplace bible with quran, and savages with "savages from the US south" and you have an equally repugnant statement (with the same level of whatever accuracy exists there.) Extremist fanaticism exists in all religions - and your garbage xenophobic bigotry doesn't belong on HN.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rezmason 8y agoSidenote: In the past, if you were wealthy and powerful, or nationalistic, you'd try to trace your ancestry or your people's lineage back to Troy. Caesar did it, the Habsburgs did it, and so did Trithemius, for some reason. That is Johannes Trithemius, a 14th and 15th century librarian and abbot with a marked interest in the occult. (Turns out he was also an early practitioner of cryptography.) Early on, Trithemius built an awesome library at his monastery, but then they split up and he became a counselor to the Holy Roman Emperor, Maximilian. The Emperor was of Habsburg descent, and the Habsburgs and other Franks were claiming Trojan ancestry... so Trithemius wrote an elaborate fake history of the Franks, leading back to Troy, and had it published. There's a lot more to this guy than just that. He wrote "Steganographia" and "Polygraphia", which are dripping with occult influence but turn out to be a combination of fake alphabets and substitution ciphers. But because of his man-crush on Maximilian, he committed this extremely intricate forgery and obliterated his reputation. That's how significant the Trojan War was in the 1500s. Fun fact: Polygraphia's fake alphabets include Theban, which Wiccans now use to write spells, and two fake Frank languages (one that he said was used by a fake Frank philosopher) to bolster his fake Frank history. Oh and he invented the bibliography. Here's one now. https://books.google.com/books?id=6lE-OdAQPJsC&lpg=PA59&ots=WkWL16iQfa&dq=trithemius%20conjures%20the%20past&pg=PA56#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=6lE-OdAQPJsC&lpg=PA59&ots=... http://microcosmographia.com/2012/12/15/johannes-trithemius-and-the-orthographies-of-invention/ http://microcosmographia.com/2012/12/15/johannes-trithemius-... https://reader.digitale-sammlungen.de/de/fs1/object/display/bsb10943192_00496.html?zoom=0.5&numScans=2 https://reader.digitale-sammlungen.de/de/fs1/object/display/... http://old.post-gazette.com/healthscience/19980629bspirit1.asp http://old.post-gazette.com/healthscience/19980629bspirit1.a...